• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7th Jan - 4th June '24

Status
Not open for further replies.
To penetrate the containment building it'd take some kind of air launched bunker buster. Or a crap ton of C4
Remember, this building is designed to withstand a large hydrogen explosion.

However, the problem is if the cooling system is compromised, say if water inlets were destroyed. That would take a precision attack and could be carried out by drones.
A continuous flow of water through the core & spent fuel ponds is a necessity, otherwise the fuel heats up and eventually melts down
I should note that even if the cooling system was damaged, the engineers on the ground would come up with another way of getting water into the core & spent fuel (perhaps diesel driven fire pumps?). I would be surprised if there was an accident at Zaporizhzhia.
 
Hate to be this guy... but how do we know it's Ukraine?
Because last time I checked Russia controls the plant.
So, is it possible that Russia would hit the dome with just enough explosives NOT to penetrate, and accuse Ukraine?
Call me naive, but I don’t think that is the case.
 
If it was definitely Russia, there would be outrage all over media, basically, not a peep.
Ukraine would more likely try to damage a nuclear power plant than Russia. Simply because they have been obviously desperate for a while now in hope to drag Nato-europe into conflict. That being the last thing Russia is interested in.
 
This story of the ZNPP comes out periodically and it's always the same. With the same considerations.
Given the fact that there's no evidence of who's the owner of the drone...from a practical standpoint, only Ukraine would benefit from causing some sort of incident, which forces the russians to leave ZNPP.
Russia would have no interest nor gain from doing this, unless they want to risk to fight against NATO.
Also they don't need to cause some kind of pyrotecnical firework over a primary containment with a drone, to be sure that it won't blow up and to blame Ukraine...to do what?
To deter an already deterred and well bored western population from further supporting Ukraine?
But besided this...NATO involvement over an hypotetical incident at that plant? Impossible.

Also as someone pointed out...the only ones complaining about this mishebavior is the IAEA...western media and govts, are being misteriously silent over this...so...

Second of all...again...it is impossible to cause a core meltdown by targeting the primary containment with a drone.
They're made to withstand much higher forces and energies.
An in general...a core meltdown resulting from an attack from the outside? Nearly impossible, it would take a ton of effort and precision.
These reactors (apart from the n°4 which is in HS mode) are all in cold shutdown...there's a ton of other ways to prevent such an event.

Of course IAEA, and Grossi, cannot say....hey nothing happened, be carefull next time...or...hey, hit harder!
They're obsviously strongly condemning it.

But that's the end of the story...the rest is fearporn.
 
Last edited:
Second of all...again...it is impossible to cause a core meltdown by targeting the primary containment with a drone.
They're made to withstand much higher forces and energies.
An in general...a core meltdown resulting from an attack from the outside? Nearly impossible, it would take a ton of effort and precision.
These reactors (apart from the n°4 which is in HS mode) are all in cold shutdown...there's a ton of other ways to prevent such an event.
No you could do it, if you completely destroyed the cooling system (by destroying all water lines going into the reactor building) and prevented emergency services from pumping water by shelling them.
Apart from that I completely agree with you.
 
No you could do it, if you completely destroyed the cooling system (by destroying all water lines going into the reactor building) and prevented emergency services from pumping water by shelling them.
Apart from that I completely agree with you.
But yeah, that's a major job and can't be achieved by a couple of drones.
 
Ukraine getting desperate? Hoping to achieve what?
First of all, how do you know it was Ukraine? That's already jumping to conclusions.

Secondly, ZNPP Unit 6 is in cold shutdown, so if someone wanted to cause a radiation incident, they chose the wrong target.

Interestingly, this didn't even make the headlines in Russian media (and I do follow Russian media quite closely).
 
Secondly, ZNPP Unit 6 is in cold shutdown, so if someone wanted to cause a radiation incident, they chose the wrong target.
They have chosen the wrong NPP, since only unit 4 is in hot shutdown mode, not that changes a lot.
As with most of the things on this war...there's no way to reach a 100% certain conclusion.
The only certain thing is that...IAEA is onsite...and that no one pointed the finger to Russia...
 
First of all, how do you know it was Ukraine? That's already jumping to conclusions.

Secondly, ZNPP Unit 6 is in cold shutdown, so if someone wanted to cause a radiation incident, they chose the wrong target.

Interestingly, this didn't even make the headlines in Russian media (and I do follow Russian media quite closely).
The spent (or partially spent) fuel is still rather radioactive and gives off decay heat, even in a cold shutdown. This is managed by a continuous flow of coolant.

The following is a dissertation from JT Claassen,
Pressurised water reactor cold shutdown transient analysis" https://repository.nwu.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10394/19156/Claassen_JT_2016.pdf?sequence=1

It simulates the failure of the residual heat removal system of a Westinghouse CPR 1000 (A PWR, of which the VVER series is a type of)

"
In reference to graph 4.5 below, where a RHR (Residual Heat Removal) failure was injected at time t=0 we note that there is a
very gradual increase in the average core coolant temperature starting at 100.38C and rising to
205.75C in slightly over 9 hours. More importantly the fuel peak temperature also shows a gradual
increase in roughly 5 hours, tracking at the same rate of rise as the coolant temperature. However
after 310 minutes the peak fuel temperature increases from roughly 151.87C to 2211.17 C over a
period of 2hours and 27 minutes, or at a rate of 14 degrees per minute. Thus if corrective action has
not been forthcoming at this juncture, rapidly escalating events going forward is very likely to negate
any mitigating actions taken.
"
It should be noted that a fuel cladding temperature of 2000 is sufficient for significant Zr oxidation, which releases hydrogen gas.
So, as one can see, the failure of the cooling system of a reactor, even one in cold shutdown, proves catastrophic.

That simulation presumes no attempt is made to provide cooling via low pressure coolant lines, which could happen if engineers were forced to leave due to shelling.
 
Last edited:
The spent fuel (or partially spent) is still rather radioactive and gives off decay heat, even in a cold shutdown. This is managed by a continuous flow of coolant.

The following is a dissertation from JT Claassen,
Pressurised water reactor cold shutdown transient analysis" https://repository.nwu.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10394/19156/Claassen_JT_2016.pdf?sequence=1

It simulates the failure of the residual heat removal system of a Westinghouse CPR 1000 (A PWR, of which the VVER series is a type of)

"
In reference to graph 4.5 below, where a RHR (Residual Heat Removal) failure was injected at time t=0 we note that there is a
very gradual increase in the average core coolant temperature starting at 100.38C and rising to
205.75C in slightly over 9 hours. More importantly the fuel peak temperature also shows a gradual
increase in roughly 5 hours, tracking at the same rate of rise as the coolant temperature. However
after 310 minutes the peak fuel temperature increases from roughly 151.87C to 2211.17 C over a
period of 2hours and 27 minutes, or at a rate of 14 degrees per minute. Thus if corrective action has
not been forthcoming at this juncture, rapidly escalating events going forward is very likely to negate
any mitigating actions taken.
"
It should be noted that a fuel cladding temperature of 2000 is sufficient for significant Zr oxidation, which releases hydrogen gas.
So, as one can see, the failure of the cooling system of a reactor, even one in cold shutdown, proves catastrophic.

That simulation presumes no attempt is made to provide cooling via low pressure coolant lines, which could happen if engineers were forced to leave due to shelling.
Yes, the paper does acknowledge issues with the methodology, so the specifics may be wrong, but the general idea is correct, that if you nullify the cooling system on a reactor in cold shutdown, you have a serious problem.
 
The only certain thing is that...IAEA is onsite...and that no one pointed the finger to Russia...
Oh that's right silly me. How could I forget Russia has to tell the IAEA its actions and motives before committing them. Also somehow forgot the IAEA has access to Russian military planning. (Sarcasm)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
First of all, how do you know it was Ukraine? That's already jumping to conclusions.

Secondly, ZNPP Unit 6 is in cold shutdown, so if someone wanted to cause a radiation incident, they chose the wrong target.

Interestingly, this didn't even make the headlines in Russian media (and I do follow Russian media quite closely).
As stated above……somebody fucked up.
And you read a lot more into my post than I actual put in.
Never said ANYTHING about wanting to cause a radiation incident.
 
I hate to do this, but I happen to be a little more convinced it was Ukraine. They have said Russia keeps weapons there, and I'm sure that's true. But also, Russia has no reason to force themselves to retreat and get radioactive contamination in Russia and Belarus, and almost certainly bring direct involvement from other countries.

Also, they are active in the plant. They could simply sabotage it directly. Of course, attacking the containment building which is very hard to do could mean they knew it wouldn't do much and would make for good propaganda.

Even if Russia didn't directly sabotage it, I'm sure they could cook up a fake US-enough looking weapon that could actually damage the containment building. Of course, Ukraine mostly relies on drones and has very limited serious weaponry or capacity to produce serious weaponry, mostly just soviet Era weaponry and drones.

I think, however, it could easily force a retreat and cause other countries to up support or even directly intervene, very beneficial to Ukraine. And despite Chernobyl and Fukushima still being exclusion zones, some argue even Pripyat only really needed a few weeks of evacuation as the most radioactive isotopes fade fast. Ofc kicking up dust isn't the best and cancer rates would be high, but overall - the <15 mile area that gets heavily contaminated in meltdowns isn't a major concern for Ukraine with all the benefits. Any radiation in Russia is a serious concern for Russia and may cause increased draft dodging and even civil disobedience.(something very dangerous for a government. You can't oppress protestors if the police refuse to do so)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom