• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | Discussions 2024

Status
Not open for further replies.
You know the difference between intervention and invasion? Russia is trying to conquer land in Ukraine ( invasion ) call it special if you like its still the same. While an intervention is to interveen between 2 parties or more ( like Russia did between Armenia and Aserbadjan )
To carry out this task it was the blue helmets, in fact it was bombings on Serbia (Belgrade).
 
Yes many different opinions even in the west. Still has right to be heard whether they are American, British, Hungarian, Australian or anywhere/anyone else. This is important as not all believe or follow western narrative obviously even as they come from western societies.
And alot more population in eu are aware of situation and don't support Ukraine especially should their own countries be expected to fight. I'd say awareness and care factors are much higher than say AMERICA AND AUSTRALIA. Not our backyard not our problem fully support western action over there. 😉👍😤😤 Putin. 🙄🤦‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️😉
Oh he has a right to be heard, I just believe he is simply wrong and over simplifying the issue in its entirety.
That said in the west there is a strong contingent of those that argue the west, specifically the US but others as well should simply abstain from the contest or not butt into affairs not directly related to they’re vaunted “sphere of influence”. We have enough problems of our own. In part this is true, but what in the complicated game of life and international relations is ever that black and white. The west could take this position, but would it be the correct course of action for the west in general over the long term? It can just as easily be argued from the proof of history that ignoring or taking a hands off approach can in the long run be more damaging in the mid to long term and butting in now.
So the anti-interventionist or Russian defenders ( no pejorative inferred here) can certainly point to Farage’s statements. And while generally I like Farage I believe he is wrong.

If we as a people and nation are going to pull together and support a policy or direction irrespective of which political party is sponsoring it? Which I suspect has more to do with Farage’s POV than a common sense application of history
 
Taking Nigel Farage’s opinion as a policy leader is like taking Medvedev’s
While you might not agree with him he is still much more influential in western politics than Medvedev is influential in Russian politics. It is a mistake to dismiss or not attempt to answer his positions.
 
Russian people are furious upon it's leaders due to not acting against U.S. unmanned reconnaissance flights that conduct target painting for ATACMS strikes upon Russians territory, so U.S. now facing a dilemma.

Americans may need to sacrifice a Global Hawk drone or two, to preserve Putin's reputation, and ensure trust of Russian populace about him, so the shepherd could keep guiding sheep to the slaughter as smooth as always.

America's greatest weapon are not in form of some missiles nor drones.
It's the wrong people at the right places.

Even if it means hurting their military work, there are priorities set.
Yeah the exact same thing could be said of Russia right now as well.

Where would we be, where would Russian people be right now if their leaders had successfully integrated Russia into NATO and the western economies?
Much ado is made about NATO expansion and encroachment of Russia.
What criticism could be leveled at Russia and Putin for applying 17th century geopolitics and Russian pride.
 
While you might not agree with him he is still much more influential in western politics than Medvedev is influential in Russian politics. It is a mistake to dismiss or not attempt to answer his positions.
Medvedev is deputy chairman of the Russian security council, all Farage is at this point is the chairman of a political party with one seat in the House of Commons. Both of them are pretty equal in their unimportance really.
 
NATO made literally every attempt after the fall of the Soviet Union to make partnerships with Russia.
In 2000, acting Russian president said he would consider joining NATO,.... Putin Says 'Why Not?' to Russia Joining NATO

Then the NATO-Russia Council was created in 2002.
Ref. Russia–NATO relations - Wikipedia

NATO-Russia Council​

In 2000 Putin told George Robertson, the Secretary General of NATO at that time, that he wanted Russia to join NATO but would not like to go through the usual application process. In 2001, following the September 11 attacks against the United States, Russian President Vladimir Putin reached out to President George W. Bush, the President of the United States at the time. This was the height of U.S.-Russian relations since the end of the Cold War. Russia even shared intelligence that they had with the United States, which proved vital to the U.S. forces in Afghanistan.[citation needed] As a member of NATO, the United States' newly positive relationship with Russia would positively impact Russian-NATO relations.

The NATO-Russia Council (NRC) was created on 28 May 2002 during the 2002 NATO Summit in Rome.
Cooperation between Russia and NATO focused on several main sectors: terrorism, military cooperation, Afghanistan (including transportation by Russia of non-military International Security Assistance Force freight (see NATO logistics in the Afghan War), and fighting local drug production), industrial cooperation, and weapons non-proliferation. As a result of its structured working groups across a range of areas, the NRC served as the primary forum for consensus-building, cooperation, and consultation on topics such as terrorism, proliferation, peacekeeping, airspace management, and missile defense.[45][48]

"Joint decisions and actions", taken under NATO-Russia Council agreements, include:

  • Fighting terrorism
  • Military cooperation (joint military exercises and personnel training)
  • Cooperation on Afghanistan:
    • Russia providing training courses for anti-narcotics officers from Afghanistan and Central Asia countries in cooperation with the UN
    • Transportation by Russia of non-military freight in support of NATO's ISAF in Afghanistan, industrial cooperation, cooperation on defence interoperability, non-proliferation, and other areas.
Then came George W Bush....

Reversal of the US policy in 2001​

A drastic reversion of the US and NATO policy toward Russia occurred in 2001 under George W. Bush. Most importantly, the US unilaterally withdrew from the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty with Russia in 2001–2002, which was followed by US signing bilateral agreements with Poland and Romania (with NATO support) to build ballistic missile defense (BMD) systems on their territories against Russian wishes. Although none of these events depended on NATO enlargement - not even the agreement to build BMD sites in Romania and Poland, given that the United States also has bilateral BMD equipment arrangements with a wide variety of non-NATO members (including Bahrain, Egypt, Israel, Japan, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, South Korea, Taiwan, and the United Arab Emirates) this withdrawal was interpreted by Russian political elite and by many Western political scientists, as a sign of USA exploiting political and military weakness of Russia at that time, and lead to the loss of Russia's trust into US political intentions.

Against these headwinds, calls from within the ranks of the US military to increase collaboration fell on hard ground.

Stagnation and gradual deterioration of relations (2004–2013)​

NATO–Russia relations stalled and subsequently started to deteriorate, following the Ukrainian Orange Revolution in 2004–2005 and the Russo-Georgian War in 2008.
 
In 2000, acting Russian president said he would consider joining NATO,.... Putin Says 'Why Not?' to Russia Joining NATO

Then the NATO-Russia Council was created in 2002.
Ref. Russia–NATO relations - Wikipedia


Then came George W Bush....
While it could be argued that leaving the. ABM treaty was provocative. It certainly wasnt about Russia. As evidenced from a Dec 2001 White House press release regarding the withdrawal.
Almost everything in it was directed towards continuing nuclear arms reductions and continuing to work with Putin to further enhance the cooperation between the two nations

So while on the face of it this can be pointed to as a defining moment. Life is seldom that orderly

 
Also maybe it was this report from Jan 2001 of Russian deployment of nukes to Kaliningrad that was the impetus for Ageis ashore unit in Poland.

I’m not a Russia basher or expert. It saddens me that opportunities were missed or squandered. And yes the west made mistakes. But trying to paint this elevation in tensions and conflict as a US or nato problem of aggression. Just isn’t supported by reality. Putin made many missteps as well. I can remember it being argued at the time how their crackdown in Chechnya was tolerated because they were fighting their own fight with Islamic fundamentalist.
Georgia was ignored because there was in reality little we could do at the time.
They were give a pass because of leadership in Washington.
None of this is can. E used as a pass for Russia to invade Ukraine. Russias influence was rejected. So again if someone can justify beyond pointing a finger at nato aggression as the justification for invading a sovereign state. I’m still waiting
 
While it could be argued that leaving the. ABM treaty was provocative. It certainly wasnt about Russia. As evidenced from a Dec 2001 White House press release regarding the withdrawal.
Almost everything in it was directed towards continuing nuclear arms reductions and continuing to work with Putin to further enhance the cooperation between the two nations

So while on the face of it this can be pointed to as a defining moment. Life is seldom that orderly

I understand from the Wiki article that after the US unilaterally pulling out of the ABM treaty, the signing of bilateral agreements with Poland and Romania (with NATO support) to build ballistic missile defense (BMD) systems on their territories was against Russian wishes, so it would seem they (Russia) at least thought it was about Russia. But whatever, it was a defining moment, relations went down from there on.
 
I understand from the Wiki article that after the US unilaterally pulling out of the ABM treaty, the signing of bilateral agreements with Poland and Romania (with NATO support) to build ballistic missile defense (BMD) systems on their territories was against Russian wishes, so it would seem they (Russia) at least thought it was about Russia. But whatever, it was a defining moment, relations went down from there on.
True i acknowledged that. But as the article from RFE pointed out rumors and concerns regarding Russia deploying nukes to Kaliningrad predate this.
My point was not to shift the blame entirely back on Russia.
Only that the converse point being that NATO has behaved as the aggressor and that blame somehow can be shifted only to them. Is equally weak. There were mistakes, missteps, and abject failure of some to recognize what the other was intending, On both sides.
Germany was legitimate in their complaint about the unfairness of the treaty ending WW1 and how it negatively impacted Germany post war.

So when this “shift” occurred is meaningless. It happened, did something happen that might have provoked it? Seems it might have been possible.

How exactly does this reflect on Russian justification for invading Ukraine? This argument of who provoked who, is only relevant if one ignores the free will of independent nations to choose their own course.
If that is of no concern then just say so.
 
is only relevant if one ignores the free will of independent nations
Indeed. Want to note, ALL nations that have joined NATO did so willingly & ASKED to join. It's a defensive alliance & Putin knows its no threat, he uses it as an excuse to exploit political gains and wage his senseless wars against his neighbors.

No NATO nations where pressured or invaded into forcing them into a alliance. They joined out of their own independent free will as a nation that has every right to.

They joined out of fear of being invaded by a cosplaying wannabee Soviet Union dictator in the East. Now Putin only has himself to thank for the two newest members joining NATO. 🤡

As the phrase goes. "Putin, the best NATO salesman."
 
True i acknowledged that. But as the article from RFE pointed out rumors and concerns regarding Russia deploying nukes to Kaliningrad predate this.
My point was not to shift the blame entirely back on Russia.
Only that the converse point being that NATO has behaved as the aggressor and that blame somehow can be shifted only to them. Is equally weak. There were mistakes, missteps, and abject failure of some to recognize what the other was intending, On both sides.
Germany was legitimate in their complaint about the unfairness of the treaty ending WW1 and how it negatively impacted Germany post war.

So when this “shift” occurred is meaningless. It happened, did something happen that might have provoked it? Seems it might have been possible.

How exactly does this reflect on Russian justification for invading Ukraine? This argument of who provoked who, is only relevant if one ignores the free will of independent nations to choose their own course.
If that is of no concern then just say so.
I would hardly imagine NATO's expansion eastward towards Russia's borders as ever being seen as being in Russia's best interests by Russia, nor would NATO be unaware of Russia's concerns of its motives, so this was no mistake imho. The belated but not unexpected Russian pushback at some point if NATO kept pushing was also not unpredictable imho. So here we are, potentially on the brink of a MAD situation.
 
I would hardly imagine NATO's expansion eastward towards Russia's borders as ever being seen as being in Russia's best interests by Russia, nor would NATO be unaware of Russia's concerns of its motives, so this was no mistake imho. The belated but not unexpected Russian pushback at some point if NATO kept pushing was also not unpredictable imho. So here we are, potentially on the brink of a MAD situation.
Well I suppose you might be correct. I would point to Sweden and Finland two fairly independently minded western nations lack of credibility given to Russian claims of encroachment and after seventy years decided it is in their best interest to join nato.

NATO membership is voluntary correct? What in russias actions indicate there was any voluntary choice given to Ukraine?
Maybe as I hav said the E. European nations willingly sought out and joined NATO for good reason.


But that doesn’t matter does it. Peace at all cost ……..to others
 
Well I suppose you might be correct. I would point to Sweden and Finland two fairly independently minded western nations lack of credibility given to Russian claims of encroachment and after seventy years decided it is in their best interest to join nato.

NATO membership is voluntary correct? What in russias actions indicate there was any voluntary choice given to Ukraine?
Maybe as I hav said the E. European nations willingly sought out and joined NATO for good reason.


But that doesn’t matter does it. Peace at all cost ……..to others
Political power is like any other power, electrical, pneumatic, etc., the universal principle that high pressure will always flow into low pressure applies. As NATO grows stronger, it will naturally flow into areas of weaker strength. So NATO and Russia were bound to clash eventually being the two strongest powers in the area.
I didn't mean to imply peace at all cost, imho war is inevitable from time to time due to the principle I mentioned above, empires rise, then they get old, corrupt, weaken and then fall. The potential for WWIII is there, it the escalation continues, it becomes more likely, if so, so be it.
 
Political power is like any other power, electrical, pneumatic, etc., the universal principle that high pressure will always flow into low pressure applies. As NATO grows stronger, it will naturally flow into areas of weaker strength. So NATO and Russia were bound to clash eventually being the two strongest powers in the area.
I didn't mean to imply peace at all cost, imho war is inevitable from time to time due to the principle I mentioned above, empires rise, then they get old, corrupt, weaken and then fall. The potential for WWIII is there, it the escalation continues, it becomes more likely, if so, so be it.
Here is a great example of how we got where we have and reason for outcome. Lack of interest, understanding and respect regardless of belief.
You know who you are enjoy 🙄😉
 
Political power is like any other power, electrical, pneumatic, etc., the universal principle that high pressure will always flow into low pressure applies. As NATO grows stronger, it will naturally flow into areas of weaker strength. So NATO and Russia were bound to clash eventually being the two strongest powers in the area.
I didn't mean to imply peace at all cost, imho war is inevitable from time to time due to the principle I mentioned above, empires rise, then they get old, corrupt, weaken and then fall. The potential for WWIII is there, it the escalation continues, it becomes more likely, if so, so be it.
Interesting
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom