• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | Discussions 2024

Status
Not open for further replies.
There was approximately 500,000 American casualties attributed to Europe still though.
Well, if you compare to 15 to 20 millions civilians casualties in Europe, I'd say the proportion is self-explanatory. Thing is, US should begin to worry about their problems and leave other countries alone. I know that's magical thinking, but that's what I like about Trump. He's mainly concerned about his country. During his last terms he didn't initiate any was as far as I remember. Let's hope it will stay that way.
 
Well, if you compare to 15 to 20 millions civilians casualties in Europe, I'd say the proportion is self-explanatory. Thing is, US should begin to worry about their problems and leave other countries alone. I know that's magical thinking, but that's what I like about Trump. He's mainly concerned about his country. During his last terms he didn't initiate any was as far as I remember. Let's hope it will stay that way.
Here’s the fun apart about having the strongest military on the planet and one of the largest economies, it’s literally not an option to be isolationist. Don’t believe the bs that the U.S. was isolationist in the 20s/30s we weren’t we never have been and never will be. Even Trump will claim he’s gonna focus on US affairs but I’d put money down him and Netanyahu finally act on Iran.
 
Here’s the fun apart about having the strongest military on the planet and one of the largest economies, it’s literally not an option to be isolationist. Don’t believe the bs that the U.S. was isolationist in the 20s/30s we weren’t we never have been and never will be. Even Trump will claim he’s gonna focus on US affairs but I’d put money down him and Netanyahu finally act on Iran.
I’m not really sure trump claimed to be an isolationist. He’s actions last time weren’t that of a isolationist.

The ambition was to simply not start something new and tone down our interventionist tendencies of the last decade and a half.
 
What angers me is that Zelensky tried, since the beginning of the war (and let's remember that a big part of the Donbass population identifies itself as Russian and would like to be a part of Russia), to drag everybody into a spiral of escalation (no-fly zone, remember?) by not even asking, but demanding help from the West without even thinking about negotiating with Putin. And the West obliged.

However, let's also remember that historically, if we look at WWII, the highest price was paid by European countries, while the US fought a proxy war with minimal to no civilian casualties. It's easy to escalate when you know that probably your country won't be affected, while potentially Europe could become a wasteland.

Also, Ukraine was not part of the EU and us Europeans had no obligation whatsover to military help UA. Why help UA and not other countries at war? Of course, I'm all for humanitarian help and giving asylum to refugees, but IMO this conflict is a matter between Russia and UA, and both have their share of responsibility. NATO shouldn't have absolutely get involved in this. So I personally hope it'll return this way and EU countries can return to its internal affairs. I surely don't want to fight a war for a country I don't remotely care about.
And what will you say when the enemy is at your gate?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Torch
I surely don't want to fight a war for a country I don't remotely care about.

And what will you say when the enemy is at your gate?

I don’t particularly care about the Ukraine one way or the other. All I need to know is they are fighting and killing Russians by the tens of thousands. The fact that they have destroyed 25,000+ armored fighting vehicles/Tanks is just a super duper value added bonus. I want to hurt the Russians and weaken them far beyond their ability to export violence and be a threat to the west.

We have a far bigger fish to fry so the trick will be to leave Russia a conventional force large enough to dissuade Chinese adventurism. While we mount up for the title fight with China.
 
Here’s the fun apart about having the strongest military on the planet and one of the largest economies, it’s literally not an option to be isolationist. Don’t believe the bs that the U.S. was isolationist in the 20s/30s we weren’t we never have been and never will be. Even Trump will claim he’s gonna focus on US affairs but I’d put money down him and Netanyahu finally act on Iran.
I actually agree on the Iran matter.
And what will you say when the enemy is at your gate?
Do you mean when NATO decided to gradually expand itself arriving to Russia's borders?
 
What angers me is that Zelensky tried, since the beginning of the war (and let's remember that a big part of the Donbass population identifies itself as Russian and would like to be a part of Russia), to drag everybody into a spiral of escalation (no-fly zone, remember?) by not even asking, but demanding help from the West without even thinking about negotiating with Putin. And the West obliged.

However, let's also remember that historically, if we look at WWII, the highest price was paid by European countries, while the US fought a proxy war with minimal to no civilian casualties. It's easy to escalate when you know that probably your country won't be affected, while potentially Europe could become a wasteland.

Also, Ukraine was not part of the EU and us Europeans had no obligation whatsover to military help UA. Why help UA and not other countries at war? Of course, I'm all for humanitarian help and giving asylum to refugees, but IMO this conflict is a matter between Russia and UA, and both have their share of responsibility. NATO shouldn't have absolutely get involved in this. So I personally hope it'll return this way and EU countries can return to its internal affairs. I surely don't want to fight a war for a country I don't remotely care about.
With in the first month of the war you will remember Russian had that big drive to take Kiev the capita. So it’s not fair to imply Zelensky was pushing for a protracted conflict and rejecting negotiations just over Donbas region which was primarily ethnic Russian.
He had the Russian army pushing in from three sides trying to take the capital of Ukraine.
So no i would not negotiate either.

Again i am amazed at the argument that somehow Ukrainians are in the wrong because the refused to submit to a Russian land grab.
Now one can argue possibility regarding the chances or wisdom of resisting. But blame shifting just because they refused to negotiate there country away is just that. Blame shifting for the cause of the war.

Russia did not want just Donbas region. They wanted and possibly still do control over the entire gov of Ukraine.
 
Do you mean when NATO decided to gradually expand itself arriving to Russia's borders?
You mean when individual countries decided to join NATO because they felt threatened by Russia? Ask yourself this, if Russia is such a peaceful country why were the first ones that rushed to join an alliance to protect themselves from it the ones who just came from being ruled by it.
 
You mean when individual countries decided to join NATO because they felt threatened by Russia? Ask yourself this, if Russia is such a peaceful country why were the first ones that rushed to join an alliance to protect themselves from it the ones who just came from being ruled by it.
Just sayin...
https://www.eurasiareview.com/06012...most-sophisticated-means-of-warfare-analysis/

Color Revolutions: The Most Sophisticated Means Of Warfare – Analysis​

Color revolutions are an integral part of US foreign policy that seeks regime change in hostile countries.
In addition to the CIA, the State Department, the Pentagon and various US and domestic non-governmental organizations are most often engaged. In the last decade, a long list of countries with relatively stable political systems experienced colorful revolutions. Somewhere they were more and somewhere less successful: Egypt, Tunisia, Syria, Libya, Russia, Ukraine, Belarus, China, Iran, Venezuela. The regime change scenarios in all these countries show striking similarities.
 
With in the first month of the war you will remember Russian had that big drive to take Kiev the capita. So it’s not fair to imply Zelensky was pushing for a protracted conflict and rejecting negotiations just over Donbas region which was primarily ethnic Russian.
He had the Russian army pushing in from three sides trying to take the capital of Ukraine.
So no i would not negotiate either.

Again i am amazed at the argument that somehow Ukrainians are in the wrong because the refused to submit to a Russian land grab.
Now one can argue possibility regarding the chances or wisdom of resisting. But blame shifting just because they refused to negotiate there country away is just that. Blame shifting for the cause of the war.

Russia did not want just Donbas region. They wanted and possibly still do control over the entire gov of Ukraine.
I am not saying Ukranians are in the wrong. I'm blaming the UA government. Sadly, as in every war, civilians are just victims of the government which play Risk (the game). Russia has its share of guilt in this war, I'm not denying it, but Zelensky tried to drag a whole continent into a conflict with a nuclear superpower since the beginning, and never, ever had any intention of negotiating with Putin.
You mean when individual countries decided to join NATO because they felt threatened by Russia? Ask yourself this, if Russia is such a peaceful country why were the first ones that rushed to join an alliance to protect themselves from it the ones who just came from being ruled by it.
How threatened exactly? Just because I'm paranoid and feel threatened by my neighbor without a good reason I cannot put cannons in front of of my apartment door.
 
What country surrounding Russia has NATO invaded and forcibly seized its territory?
Of course, no country, being that NATO is an alliance which was born as a deterrent against a Soviet attack. (Come on, I know that's a rhetorical question and you are heaps more knowledgeable than me, but let's look past propaganda, both from the West and Russia, and see how things developed since 2014 in Donbass).
 
What angers me is that Zelensky tried, since the beginning of the war (and let's remember that a big part of the Donbass population identifies itself as Russian and would like to be a part of Russia), to drag everybody into a spiral of escalation (no-fly zone, remember?) by not even asking, but demanding help from the West without even thinking about negotiating with Putin. And the West obliged.

However, let's also remember that historically, if we look at WWII, the highest price was paid by European countries, while the US fought a proxy war with minimal to no civilian casualties. It's easy to escalate when you know that probably your country won't be affected, while potentially Europe could become a wasteland.

Also, Ukraine was not part of the EU and us Europeans had no obligation whatsover to military help UA. Why help UA and not other countries at war? Of course, I'm all for humanitarian help and giving asylum to refugees, but IMO this conflict is a matter between Russia and UA, and both have their share of responsibility. NATO shouldn't have absolutely get involved in this. So I personally hope it'll return this way and EU countries can return to its internal affairs. I surely don't want to fight a war for a country I don't remotely care about.
Most of what you have said is not historically accurate, nor is it relevant whether or not you remotely care about Ukraine. I don't know why I keep having to remind people of this, but here goes once again:

1: After the fall of the Soviet Union, Ukraine became the third most powerful nuclear-armed nation on the planet since they retained control over a large stockpile of Soviet nuclear weapons.
2: Ukraine agreed to voluntarily surrender those weapons to Russia based on an agreement reached by Ukraine, the US, the UK, and Russia, with China and France supporting the agreement as well.
3: This agreement was called the "Budapest Memorandum," and was signed by all of the countries I mentioned in 1994. A huge condition of Ukraine agreeing to surrender their nuclear weapons was the guarantee by the other countries - including Russia - that Ukraine's borders as they existed in 1994 would not be violated. GO BACK AND READ THAT LAST SENTENCE AGAIN.

So, yes, a couple of European countries had an obligation to defend Ukraine, both in 2014 and in 2022. When Russia took control of Crimea in 2014, they reneged on that agreement, and so did all of the other countries who signed the agreement by not coming to Ukraine's defense. That embarrassing failure of foreign policy is EXACTLY why we are where we are today. Russia gambled that the West would not live up to its word, and they were right. Ukraine was and is under zero obligation to "negotiate" with Putin. If you live in either the UK or France, you should be ashamed of yourself, just like Americans should be ashamed for their role in not honoring their word and abandoning Ukraine on two separate occasions now. If Ukraine had not signed that agreement and had kept those nuclear weapons, I can guarantee you Russia would not be occupying a single square inch of Ukrainian territory right now.

Do not come in here parroting Russian propaganda about certain regions of Ukraine "historically" being a part of Russia or "wanting" to be a part of Russia. Even if this was accurate - and it's not - the Budapest Memorandum was crystal clear on maintaining the existing borders of Ukraine, and that supersedes any possible excuse you could post here to justify Russia's actions.
 
Most of what you have said is not historically accurate, nor is it relevant whether or not you remotely care about Ukraine. I don't know why I keep having to remind people of this, but here goes once again:

1: After the fall of the Soviet Union, Ukraine became the third most powerful nuclear-armed nation on the planet since they retained control over a large stockpile of Soviet nuclear weapons.
2: Ukraine agreed to voluntarily surrender those weapons to Russia based on an agreement reached by Ukraine, the US, the UK, and Russia, with China and France supporting the agreement as well.
3: This agreement was called the "Budapest Memorandum," and was signed by all of the countries I mentioned in 1994. A huge condition of Ukraine agreeing to surrender their nuclear weapons was the guarantee by the other countries - including Russia - that Ukraine's borders as they existed in 1994 would not be violated. GO BACK AND READ THAT LAST SENTENCE AGAIN.

So, yes, a couple of European countries had an obligation to d.efend Ukraine, both in 2014 and in 2022. When Russia took control of Crimea in 2014, they reneged on that agreement, and so did all of the other countries who signed the agreement by not coming to Ukraine's defense. That embarrassing failure of foreign policy is EXACTLY why we are where we are today. Russia gambled that the West would not live up to its word, and they were right. Ukraine was and is under zero obligation to "negotiate" with Putin. If you live in either the UK or France, you should be ashamed of yourself, just like Americans should be ashamed for their role in not honoring their word and abandoning Ukraine on two separate occasions now. If Ukraine had not signed that agreement and had kept those nuclear weapons, I can guarantee you Russia would not be occupying a single square inch of Ukrainian territory right now.

Do not come in here parroting Russian propaganda about certain regions of Ukraine "historically" being a part of Russia or "wanting" to be a part of Russia. Even if this was accurate - and it's not - the Budapest Memorandum was crystal clear on maintaining the existing borders of Ukraine, and that supersedes any possible excuse you could post here to justify Russia's actions.
Now that's something I wasn't aware about (my ignorance on the matter). Thanks for clearing that up.
 
SK should really consider sending troops. It's an escalation, but battlefield experience is invaluable.
Wonderful idea. Really. Wouldn't be surprised if they did. South Korea has been very vocal about N.K joining the war and has said it is is going to support Ukraine more now militarily because of it.
 
I want to hurt the Russians and weaken them far beyond their ability to export violence and be a threat to the west.

We have a far bigger fish to fry so the trick will be to leave Russia a conventional force large enough to dissuade Chinese adventurism. While we mount up for the title fight with China.
I disagree with you here. Russia will always be a threat to the west so long as they have a single nuclear missile in their arsenal. Nuclear disarmament, a formal alliance treaty, induction into NATO would be the only way to stop that at this point.

With regards to China, Russia wouldn’t allow China to do that. Russia would sooner form an alliance with India than let that happen.
 
Wonderful idea. Really. Wouldn't be surprised if they did. South Korea has been very vocal about N.K joining the war and has said it is is going to support Ukraine more now militarily because of it.
How many countries have to be fighting each other before it's classified as a "world war?" Tossing more soldiers into the mix is going to make matters worse, not better.
 
I don’t particularly care about the Ukraine one way or the other. All I need to know is they are fighting and killing Russians by the tens of thousands. The fact that they have destroyed 25,000+ armored fighting vehicles/Tanks is just a super duper value added bonus. I want to hurt the Russians and weaken them far beyond their ability to export violence and be a threat to the west.

We have a far bigger fish to fry so the trick will be to leave Russia a conventional force large enough to dissuade Chinese adventurism. While we mount up for the title fight with China.
Why are Americans so obsessed with fighting China?
The only threat that China is to the USA is economic - going to war ain't going to help you with that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom