• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7 Feb - 28 Feb 23

  • Thread starter Thread starter Totality 🇺🇦 🇮🇱
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.

Totality 🇺🇦 🇮🇱

Guest
New topic!

Will Ukraine strike Russian territory, towns, or bases with the new longer range missiles & drones being supplied by the West?

Me personally sincerely doubt it. For many reason, one of the biggest being you don't bite the hand that feeds you. Doing so would risk losing any futher support from the West.
 
New topic!

Will Ukraine strike Russian territory, towns, or bases with the new longer range missiles & drones being supplied by the West?

Me personally sincerely doubt it. For many reason, one of the biggest being you don't bite the hand that feeds you. Doing so would risk losing any futher support from the West.
ofc, will we get the news if they did I doubt it.
 
ofc, will we get the news if they did I doubt it.
Oh hell yea. The moment a Russian military base or town (inside Russia) is hit by a western weapon fired by Ukraine it will be the biggest story and media would go into a absolute frenzy & fearmongers would go into overdrive.
 
fearmongers would go into overdrive.
Not that it wouldn't be alarming. But not world ending alarming. Ukraine attacking Russia directly at least initially wouldn't immediatly in anyway directly lead to nuclear war.

Though if repeated or the West continues to support Ukraine after the fact then yea we got problems likly.
 
Will Ukraine strike Russian territory, towns, or bases with the new longer range missiles & drones being supplied by the West?

Me personally sincerely doubt it. For many reason, one of the biggest being you don't bite the hand that feeds you. Doing so would risk losing any futher support from the West.
I think not hitting Russia will prolong the war. It needs to be taken home to them. Let's see how the Russian people react when their power stations are bombed and they are out of power for days/weeks.
 
I think not hitting Russia will prolong the war. It needs to be taken home to them. Let's see how the Russian people react when their power stations are bombed and they are out of power for days/weeks.
History time and again disproves the notion that terrorizing the general populace may cause it to turn on its government and thereby end an ongoing war.

Yet everyone seems to continue believing in it...
 
History time and again disproves the notion that terrorizing the general populace may cause it to turn on its government and thereby end an ongoing war.

Yet everyone seems to continue believing in it...
On the contrary. History shows it does work. The people of London were willing to surrender due to the German bombing in WWII.
 
On the contrary. History shows it does work. The people of London were willing to surrender due to the German bombing in WWII.
Your conviction flies in the face of solid historical research. This topic has been extensively studied; in my humble opinion the authoritative publication in this context is Robert A. Pape, Bombing to Win: Air Power and Coercion in War (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1996). I will quote the following summary (p. 68):

Over more than seventy-five years, the record of air power is replete with efforts to alter the behavior of states by attacking or threatening to attack large numbers of civilians. The incontrovertible conclusion from these campaigns is that air attack does not cause citizens to turn against their government. (...) In fact, in the more than thirty major strategic air campaigns that have thus far been waged, air power has never driven the masses into the streets to demand anything.

For a discussion of why punishment from the air usually fails, see also Stephen T. Hosmer, Psychological Effects of U.S. Air Operations in Four Wars, 1941–1991: Lessons for U.S. Commanders, RAND Report MR-576-AF (Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation, 1996); and Irving L. Janis, Air War and Emotional Stress: Psychological Studies of Bombing and Civilian Defense (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1951).
 
Last edited:
Pre.warning: Igor sushko, has put on twitter that the drone factory fire was russian sabotage. Scoured about it isn't even confirmed to be sabotage no matter how likely that may be. V.close to unfollowing as his misinfo can be dangerous

Edit: scratch the unfollowing he blocked me cause I called him out on it 🤣
 
Last edited:
I think not hitting Russia will prolong the war. It needs to be taken home to them. Let's see how the Russian people react when their power stations are bombed and they are out of power for days/weeks.
I understand the emotions behind this as I feel the same way. But if this where to happen could lead to very slippery slope and I think anyone would rather not find out where it leads.
 
I understand the emotions behind this as I feel the same way. But if this where to happen could lead to very slippery slope and I think anyone would rather not find out where it leads.
It will lead to both nations unrestricted war. (train crash in slowmotion) The western politicians are just hesitant and hopefull (dreamers) that this conflict can be stopped without the cost being to high, they have still not understood or unwilling to change their way of living. (culture war) or it is with open eyes they do it so the rest of the western public also understand this.
 
Your conviction flies in the face of solid historical research. This topic has been extensively studied; in my humble opinion the authoritative publication in this context is Robert A. Pape, Bombing to Win: Air Power and Coercion in War (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1996). I will quote the following summary (p. 68):

Over more than seventy-five years, the record of air power is replete with efforts to alter the behavior of states by attacking or threatening to attack large numbers of civilians. The incontrovertible conclusion from these campaigns is that air attack does not cause citizens to turn against their government. (...) In fact, in the more than thirty major strategic air campaigns that have thus far been waged, air power has never driven the masses into the streets to demand anything.

For a discussion of why punishment from the air usually fails, see also Stephen T. Hosmer, Psychological Effects of U.S. Air Operations in Four Wars, 1941–1991: Lessons for U.S. Commanders, RAND Report MR-576-AF (Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation, 1996); and Irving L. Janis, Air War and Emotional Stress: Psychological Studies of Bombing and Civilian Defense (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1951).
missile strikes inside Russia are not about punitive strikes against civilian centers with the aim of installing fear.
Not that I agree with your sources conclusions completely.

Targeted strikes on military relevant resources, Airfields rail lines supply depots. Degrade Russias ability to continue the war. It also breeds doubt and contempt for Russias ability to defend itself thoroughly with out having to terrorize the civilian population.

I would agree that carpet bombing whole swaths of an adversaries population and economic centers does not guarantee a demoralized population.
But like anything involved with war there is no cookie cutter manual proving this will always work and this will never work.

Regarding the legitimacy of Ukraine launching against conventional military targets inside Russia that aid in Russia prosecution of the war.
Well FFS yes.
The notion that Russia can invade a nation and extend or draw out the war to wear down Ukraine in a protracted stalemate. And exempt territorially Russian military launching points and staging areas is absolutely ludicrous.

It’s like saying two kids can fight
But only one can keep hitting if their both are on their feet. But the other cannot.
It’s nonsensical.

I’ll say it again we shouldn’t be here. But we are and it was Russia who invaded.
They have a proven history of military expansion with their neighbors.
And if you doubt the sentiments of some in Russia, it does not stop in Ukraine.
“Of course Poland is on the menu. As is the Baltic’s.


Want a scary thought, a really horrifying thought.
Kadyrov replaces Putin.
A Chechnyan over Russia never happen?
Stalin was a Georgian not Russian.
 
I understand the emotions behind this as I feel the same way. But if this where to happen could lead to very slippery slope and I think anyone would rather not find out where it leads.
Here is where not doing it will lead.

The west will grow tired of the war as it drags on interminably. This is exactly what Putin is banking on now.
And sentiment will grow to cut funding to Ukraine and Ukraine will be partitioned.

And in the end we will still have Russias unfulfilled check list of retaking the geography choke points in Poland Romania and Baltics.
 
It will lead to both nations unrestricted war. (train crash in slowmotion) The western politicians are just hesitant and hopefull (dreamers) that this conflict can be stopped without the cost being to high, they have still not understood or unwilling to change their way of living. (culture war) or it is with open eyes they do it so the rest of the western public also understand this.
Maybe but maybe not.
The default when standing up to military aggression is not always an escalation into unrestricted warfare.
Just as appeasement and patients is mot always an invitation to aggression.

unnecessarily prolonging a conflict without working to bring it to a definitive end only results in more lives lost.
 
<Snip: personal comments>

Broke most of the stories on US war crimes

Mỹ Lai Massacre​

On November 12, 1969, Hersh reported the story of the Mỹ Lai massacre, in which hundreds of unarmed Vietnamese civilians were murdered by US soldiers in March 1968.[13]

Documents declassified in 2017 show that Hersh was on the National Security Agency watchlist possibly because of hostility towards his journalism including his writings about the Mỹ Lai massacre.

Seymour Myron "Sy" Hersh (born April 8, 1937) is an American investigative journalist and political writer.

Hersh first gained recognition in 1969 for exposing the My Lai Massacre and its cover-up during the Vietnam War, for which he received the 1970 Pulitzer Prize for International Reporting.

During the 1970s, Hersh covered the Watergate scandal for The New York Times and revealed the clandestine bombing of Cambodia.

In 2004, he reported on the U.S. military's mistreatment of detainees at Abu Ghraib prison. He has also won two National Magazine Awards and five George Polk Awards. In 2004, he received the George Orwell Award.[6]


 
@Peace I have no problem articulating or pontificating the idea the US destroyed Nord-Stream pipelines. We could have very well did it maybe.

BUT TO pass it off as facts or share sources that wildly go off into the deep end with zero sources crediting their anylisis is unacceptable.

Now if you want to DEBATE the idea that the US was behind it great. I'll debate it. But don't act or pass it off as offcial, on the record, or credible. No one knows who really did it.

BUT by all means if you know more then the international worldly community please let us know with proof or solid sources.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom