• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7 Feb - 28 Feb 23

  • Thread starter Thread starter Totality 🇺🇦 🇮🇱
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It could be true same old story anon source. Won’t be surprised either way.
I’ll see if I can find it. Another anon source says the German government was aware and I assume gave tacit approval.
Couple of tidbits
Germany announced they were not going to certify nord 2 because of Russias official recognition of the separatist gov in east Ukraine 2/22. Before Biden claimed the pipeline would never flow gas.
https://thehill.com/policy/equilibr...-things-to-know-about-nord-stream-2-shutdown/
So it sounds like the pipeline and flow of gas in the current environment was a already decided upon Germany as well.

Did we blow it up my guess is probably.
Do I really care? No.
Sounds like multiple NATO nations were involved and likely Germany was aware of it as well.
It didn’t stop the flow of gas to Germany, Germany had yet to certify it for use.
We speak of the risk of asymmetric warfare from China or Russia towards the US frequently.
It sounds like nato resorted to it as well against Russia.
Should this really be a surprise?
No.
But it’s an act of open warfare against Russia by nato and will lead to an escalation.
Well that’s the thing about asymmetric warfare. Attribution is difficult to sell.
It’s been four months were it the initiation of direct hostilities between nato and Russia?
There isn’t any because Russia doesn’t have a dog to put in that fight. And there not going to go nuclear of a as yet unused pipeline.
 
I have been wondering what the peace plan is from China.
IMO
It seems it will be a plea for Europe to recognize who the real aggressor in the world is and designate it as the United States. A plan for world peace by giving all nations security by removing the US hegemony. The alternative is a total economic split along with the devastation that will follow. Why should Europe suffer for the US sins.

They will try to split our allies.
 
I have been wondering what the peace plan is from China.
IMO
It seems it will be a plea for Europe to recognize who the real aggressor in the world is and designate it as the United States. A plan for world peace by giving all nations security by removing the US hegemony. The alternative is a total economic split along with the devastation that will follow. Why should Europe suffer for the US sins.

They will try to split our allies.
Well that’s a predictable alternative plan. Color me gobsmacked with the novelty of it
Wait Ive heard this before.
Hegemony, multi-polar world, Russia and China setting the world right again.

We just have to get our thinking correct.
 
As has been noted by others, we may never have certainty as to the truth of these allegations, however although I was sceptical at first I have done some reading, and unfortunately I now feel it does seem somewhat plausible.

Pretty terrible decision IMO, if it’s true, due to essentially being an illegal act against Russia and Europe, and with the potential to cause all sorts of distrust within NATO. The cost/risks vs benefits don’t add up to me.
 

Putin Able to Declare Victory in Ukraine Anytime: Former Russian Commander​

"Officially, we don't have a war, do we?" Girkin said. "Officially, we have not formulated the goals of a special military operation, so that it would be convenient to say at any moment that we achieved them and to end the war."

Gerashchenko wrote in the caption of his Twitter post: "Terrorist Girkin-Strelkov says the goals of the 'special military operation' were deliberately left vague so it can be declared victorious at any moment."

He's wrong. Or, to put it more accurately, he was right for a while, but that ship sailed when Putin formally annexed Ukraine's southern regions. That was his "throw the steering wheel out the window" moment. Now war is all there's left.
 
As has been noted by others, we may never have certainty as to the truth of these allegations, however although I was sceptical at first I have done some reading, and unfortunately I now feel it does seem somewhat plausible.

Pretty terrible decision IMO, if it’s true, due to essentially being an illegal act against Russia and Europe, and with the potential to cause all sorts of distrust within NATO. The cost/risks vs benefits don’t add up to me.
I agree but as I’ve read some this pipeline never actuality flowed gas supplies. Russia cut supplies thru nord stream 1 in retaliation it would appear. But this was the only limiting effect on current gas flows. Germany had been slow walking certification for NORD 2 for 1/2 a year leading up to the invasion.
I could be wrong I haven’t dug much deeper for verification. But did it’s destruction actually cut gas flows to to Germany this winter? Only in respect to Russia cutting supplies likely in retaliation.

In Feb last year the US and Germany were on the same page regarding the nord stream.

So I don’t think it is nearly as much an affront to Germany and Europe as even I had worried it might have been.

So then it’s just a question of the destruction of Russian and Swiss companies property.
The Swiss will play along because of the long game. Chalking it up as cost of doing business with Russia.

The Russians? Deniability in a asymmetric war, we are at war after all.
It does not have to be Blood and Treasure. It can be treasure alone.

So what we’re seeing now regarding any western outrage over the US potentially blowing it up. Is in fact disinformation or repeating or jumping to conclusions with insufficient information.

I do still have issues that congressional leadership should have been briefed on it before hand. It actually seems in this light a fairly easy sale.
All parties involved might very well have agreed to take the Israeli path of deny deny deny.
Simply for the purpose of not give any traction to Russian maneuvers at the UN.
This is all speculation on my part but it does seem how it might have transpired. Time will tell
 
Seymour Hersh has reported on this ( A highly regarded reporter from the US ) Germany and France are either swallowing a big chill pill, or they got something in return from the US to keep it calm.
 
First thought: This would be highly classified if it were really true and I find it very doubtful that he would have that kind of detailed information.
Second thought: How the hell did he get that much text in a single Tweet?????

Weatherman is Twitter blogging.
 
Last edited:
Seymour Hersh has reported on this ( A highly regarded reporter from the US ) Germany and France are either swallowing a big chill pill, or they got something in return from the US to keep it calm.
Your ignoring the fact Germany had refused to certify the pipeline in the months leading up to the war.
And what does France care their principal energy supply is nuclear.

It is just as possible, especially how quiet they both have been that is was a useful tactical decision.

I can only speculate just as you are.
The silence and continued support of NATO’s mission for Ukraine tends to support they might just as well been in agreement.
 
First thought: This would be highly classified if it were really true and I find it very doubtful that he would have that kind of detailed information.
Second thought: How the hell did he get that much text in a single Tweet?????
If you pay you can do long tweets. Something new Musk did. I forget how many words but it's quite allot.
 
Your ignoring the fact Germany had refused to certify the pipeline in the months leading up to the war.
And what does France care their principal energy supply is nuclear.

It is just as possible, especially how quiet they both have been that is was a useful tactical decision.

I can only speculate just as you are.
The silence and continued support of NATO’s mission for Ukraine tends to support they might just as well been in agreement.
Germany choose not to certify it 2 days before the invasion - and Russia closed nord stream 1 the 18th september ( sighted leaks 26-27 sep ) French could redirect their gas supply from Algeria instead but as you point out also more nuclear oriented.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom