• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7 Feb - 28 Feb 23

  • Thread starter Thread starter Totality 🇺🇦 🇮🇱
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I listened to Putin's speech along with the formal letter of protest to the US embassy. The letter ordered the US to remove troops and equipment from Ukraine. Dutch intel that Russia has been mapping the offshore pipelines also Putin put all Nuclear forces on combat alert. Seems we are being dovish on the warning level.

The speech certainly wasn’t a turn around in terms of trying to make friends with the west, but from what I’ve seen there was nothing there that would warrant an immediate raise in alert level of this site.

Likewise this stuff about Dutch energy infrastructure. If it’s true, it certainly warrants close monitoring, but it’s most likely to be reconnaissance and/or intended to intimidate at the current time. That could change, of course.

I have not heard anything about a change in Russian nuclear posture. I would be interested in further info.
 
The speech certainly wasn’t a turn around in terms of trying to make friends with the west, but from what I’ve seen there was nothing there that would warrant an immediate raise in alert level of this site.
Which is exactly what the staff has emphasized over and over. To move the Alert level one way or another is not something done in haste, based on rumors , false reports etc.
In this case it was wait for the speech, listen to it, analyze it, analyze it some more, discuss it, then make their decision.
 
Which is exactly what the staff has emphasized over and over. To move the Alert level one way or another is not something done in haste, based on rumors , false reports etc.
In this case it was wait for the speech, listen to it, analyze it, analyze it some more, discuss it, then make their decision.
To be fair I didn't watch it. Didn't have the time tonight... but intend to sometime today. Though again not like it will effect the level. Putin has said and threaten everything in the book already. So just all hot air.

Until he decides one day to make good on his threats or starts mobilizing strategic assets (which can't be hidden)... I'm certainly not batting a eye anymore on what Putin particularly has to say ever anymore. Almost all of it now is meant for local consumption. Mindless garbage meant for the mindless masses in Russia.
 
Thanks. That’s helpful.

The one thing in the speech I did draw some nuclear meaning from were the references to nuclear testing. Not to say I think they’re going to suddenly start doing tests, and he said that Russia only would if the US does first, but he sort of opened the door a bit to future tests. Seemed like sort of laying the groundwork to keep options open for the future, as they have done many times before (for example, that’s how I saw the dirty bomb allegations against Ukraine - laying groundwork for something on the menu, but not necessarily an indication they really intend to go through with it).
 
Though again not like it will effect the level.
To be 'frank' if Putin where to threaten to nuke NYC or London 'out right' I wouldn't even bat a eye at this point. I'd just roll my eyes and continue with my day.

People fail to realize WE WILL KNOW if Putin is thinking or preparing to use nukes. Since the war began Civilian Satellites & Military Satellites routinely pass over most if not all of Russian nuclear sites. There all operating the same as they have for decades and no unusual activity at any Russian nuclear sites. Until that changes Putin can threaten to nuke whoever whatever as much as he wants but it's a bluff.

UNTIL Russia changes its nuclear posture which again cannot be hidden from the public and especially not the Western intelligence satellites it's all garbage/bluff/bullshit and will generally never effect the alert level.
 
I could not disagree more strongly. Yes, he's funny (in a perverted sense), but not ha-ha funny. A great many people - in the West and otherwise - will be listening attentively.
Unless your used to his style and the history of the region and conflicts its all rather technical or like a lecture.

People will wait for their preferred analysis source to tell them what is important. Not necessarily the wise choice but just the way it is.
I’m mean seriously we’re all geeks for this stuff. Average person could care less and would never make the effort.

I haven’t read it yet just woke up.

What I’m looking for is signs of him being even more insular or shrinking peripheral vision. Is he obsessing on singular points or incidents that are just part of the whole. Or fallen back to professor mode delineating the historic wrongs against Russia and their deprived destiny.

Myopic vision is a sign of a world closing in on you with fewer and fewer perceived choices.
 
To be 'frank' if Putin where to threaten to nuke NYC or London 'out right' I wouldn't even bat a eye at this point. I'd just roll my eyes and continue with my day.

People fail to realize WE WILL KNOW if Putin is thinking or preparing to use nukes. Since the war began Civilian Satellites & Military Satellites routinely pass over most if not all of Russian nuclear sites. There all operating the same as they have for decades and no unusual activity at any Russian nuclear sites. Until that changes Putin can threaten to nuke whoever whatever as much as he wants but it's a bluff.

UNTIL Russia changes its nuclear posture which again cannot be hidden from the public and especially not the Western intelligence satellites it's all garbage/bluff/bullshit and will generally never effect the alert level.
How do you know the forces are not on high alert?

 
How do you know the forces are not on high alert?

You did not understand anything I said.

We will see the activity at nuclear sites via commercial/civilian satellites and Western Intelligence satellites will most certainly pick it up quick.

Also Putin never changed his nuclear posture. He said he was going to but never did earlier on in the war. Civilian and Western Organizations/Agencies said there was no change in Russia nuclear posture weeks after he said so.
 
We will see the activity at nuclear sites via commercial/civilian satellites
This occurred last year as a clear cut case why we will know. Civilian sat imagery showed some activity at a Russian nuclear site thought to be housing tactical nuclear weapons. Turns out it was just maintenance or somthing insignificant.

We will know when he is serious. We will see strategic sites or nuclear sites hustling and bustling which they simply cannot hide in this day an age.

The very movement any unusual activity is noticed via sat images of any Russian nuclear site it's going to be made know everywhere very quickly. Just like it did last time last year... again even though it turned out to be nothing should show everyone Russia simply will not be able to hide the fact of them getting ready to use nuclear weapons short of shooting off what they currently have positioned ready to go which we already know opening wide nuclear first strike scenarios are pretty much impractical now a days.
 
He’s just as insular maybe more so.
It was not written just for domestic audiences. Either the translation anglicized it or someone with exposer to English wrote it.
There are sound bites in there to be copy pasted all over the internet.

There is istina and there is pravda,
This was just more pravda.

The histrionics were just a prevalent going all the way back to the medieval period to fault the west.

He more myopic than ever.

There objective truth in this whole thing is this.
Russia is just and right in reestablishing the boarders of the USSR. Bit by bit but make no mistake that is what this about.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Six
Well, one thing's for sure - I certainly can't picture Hitler giving a speech on social cushions and landfill utilization.

Perhaps we'll miss him yet... :unsure:
That’s the appealing to the western audience. Sound bites for a kinder conscientious.
See if we win we’ll make the world a better place just trust us.
It sells well in the west right now.
 
He’s just as insular maybe more so.
It was not written just for domestic audiences. Either the translation anglicized it or someone with exposer to English wrote it.
There are sound bites in there to be copy pasted all over the internet.

There is istina and there is pravda,
This was just more pravda.

The histrionics were just a prevalent going all the way back to the medieval period to fault the west.

He more myopic than ever.

There objective truth in this whole thing is this.
Russia is just and right in reestablishing the boarders of the USSR. Bit by bit but make no mistake that is what this about.

Thank you (y)
 
That’s the appealing to the western audience. Sound bites for a kinder conscientious.
See if we win we’ll make the world a better place just trust us.
It sells well in the west right now.
I disagree. It was, on its face, a "state of the nation" speech. Obviously he couldn't make it 100% about war. Still, there's nothing in there that would appeal to the western audience - or, indeed, to the Russian audience, at least judging by the faces of people listening: they seemed anxious at first, then bored, then outright sleepy, then suddenly shaken awake when he started talking about nukes. At no point did they seem satisfied (applause notwithstanding).

Oh by the way, I hereby concede my pre-speech alert level assessment and am moving back to the green camp.
 
I disagree. It was, on its face, a "state of the nation" speech. Obviously he couldn't make it 100% about war. Still, there's nothing in there that would appeal to the western audience - or, indeed, to the Russian audience, at least judging by the faces of people listening: they seemed anxious at first, then bored, then outright sleepy, then suddenly shaken awake when he started talking about nukes. At no point did they seem satisfied (applause notwithstanding).

Oh by the way, I hereby concede my pre-speech alert level assessment and am moving back to the green camp.
You might be correct, I am after all looking purely looking at it as a foreigner.

There is still something about the flow and language. It could be the translation. I say it was for western sound bites as much as domestic.
But of course I could be overthinking it.
By and large he’s just as dogmatically obsessed and committed to salvaging
The motherlands reputation.

At least in public proclamations, pravda, Putin’s truth.
 
That's not at all contradictory.
Might be a case of "Do what we say don't say what we do".
Withdrawing from the treaty means they don't have to let inspectors in, but they can still claim compliance in the hope that the Americans don't put more warheads on their missiles.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom