• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7th Jan - 4th June '24

Status
Not open for further replies.
... Russia has to tell the IAEA its actions and motives before committing them....
LOL...no.
If you think that IAEA has limited or biased access to the information, without complaining about this...well it's your fantasy, i can't help here.
But can we be realistic and analytical for once and keep the propaganda shit aside?
I trust more scientists than journalists or politicians over this situation.

IAEA:
They were able to confirm the physical impact of the drone detonations, including at one of the site’s six reactor buildings where surveillance and communication equipment appeared to have been targeted.
While they were at the roof of the reactor, unit 6, Russian troops engaged what appeared to be an approaching drone. This was followed by an explosion near the reactor building.

The experts reported hearing explosions and rifle fire on the site throughout the day. Additionally, the IAEA team heard several rounds of outgoing artillery fire from near the plant.


So it's Russia which is staging all of this....ok...makes perfect sense...to do what?

BTW...the damage is negligible.
They reported observing minor superficial scorching to the top of the reactor dome roof of Unit 6 and scoring of a concrete slab supporting the primary make-up water storage tanks.
 
Mmmh...Russia keeps going on with his efforts to hit their own controlled NPP.
That's a lot of effort, including the attempts to also down the drones, and then to blame Ukraine...with no apparent reason or gain from doing that.
 
So this was Ukraine launching a limited strike against Russian defenses at the plant? All that I’ve heard is that what ever ballistics that were used were not even marginally callable of doing critical damage to the reactor buildings.
So Ukraine did it, so what, it’s their power plant. This whole morality or culpability question of involving a nuclear generation plant in armed conflict pretty much went out the window when Russia shelled it and its facilities at the start of the war. Or when the damn was blown.

Russia and Ukraine both agreed to the Geneva convention additional protocols of 1977 article 56 first sentence.
Works or installations containing dangerous forces, namely dams, dykes and nuclear electrical generating stations, shall not be made the object of attack, even where these objects are military objectives, if such attack may cause the release of dangerous forces and consequent severe losses among the civilian population.

So at this point who did it is pretty much irrelevant, is it not? As far as I can tell who is committing “war crimes” in this war is kinda of a mute question.

I would point out that by and large the preponderance of Ukraines drone attacks inside Russia have mostly been against Russian infrastructure, oil production/refineries, military, and transportations.
The same cannot be said for Russias targeting in and around Ukrainian cities.
 
So this was Ukraine launching a limited strike against Russian defenses at the plant? All that I’ve heard is that what ever ballistics that were used were not even marginally callable of doing critical damage to the reactor buildings.
So Ukraine did it, so what, it’s their power plant. This whole morality or culpability question of involving a nuclear generation plant in armed conflict pretty much went out the window when Russia shelled it and its facilities at the start of the war. Or when the damn was blown.

Russia and Ukraine both agreed to the Geneva convention additional protocols of 1977 article 56 first sentence.
Works or installations containing dangerous forces, namely dams, dykes and nuclear electrical generating stations, shall not be made the object of attack, even where these objects are military objectives, if such attack may cause the release of dangerous forces and consequent severe losses among the civilian population.

So at this point who did it is pretty much irrelevant, is it not? As far as I can tell who is committing “war crimes” in this war is kinda of a mute question.

I would point out that by and large the preponderance of Ukraines drone attacks inside Russia have mostly been against Russian infrastructure, oil production/refineries, military, and transportations.
The same cannot be said for Russias targeting in and around Ukrainian cities.
There’s no proof about who did It.
We can only make logical assumptions (still no reason has ever been provided about why Russia would have to hit a NPP that is controlling especially at this current stage of the war).

But surely I don’t get and I will never understand the 2 speeds when it comes to accountability and justifiability.

The fact that Russia is a war criminal and shelled the plant back in 2022, and this is pretty obvious, by no means should ever authorize or justify deplorable acts done by the Ukrainians.

This is generally speaking. Not necessarily related to ZNPP drone question as there’s no proof.

The scope of the Russian and Ukrainian attacks here has nothing to do with this story.
Assuming that we have both seen both the parties hiding military assets in civilian residential areas…so…
 
There’s no proof about who did It.
We can only make logical assumptions (still no reason has ever been provided about why Russia would have to hit a NPP that is controlling especially at this current stage of the war).

But surely I don’t get and I will never understand the 2 speeds when it comes to accountability and justifiability.

The fact that Russia is a war criminal and shelled the plant back in 2022, and this is pretty obvious, by no means should ever authorize or justify deplorable acts done by the Ukrainians.

This is generally speaking. Not necessarily related to ZNPP drone question as there’s no proof.

The scope of the Russian and Ukrainian attacks here has nothing to do with this story.
Assuming that we have both seen both the parties hiding military assets in civilian residential areas…so…
There’s no proof about who did It.
We can only make logical assumptions (still no reason has ever been provided about why Russia would have to hit a NPP that is controlling especially at this current stage of the war).

But surely I don’t get and I will never understand the 2 speeds when it comes to accountability and justifiability.

The fact that Russia is a war criminal and shelled the plant back in 2022, and this is pretty obvious, by no means should ever authorize or justify deplorable acts done by the Ukrainians.

This is generally speaking. Not necessarily related to ZNPP drone question as there’s no proof.

The scope of the Russian and Ukrainian attacks here has nothing to do with this story.
Assuming that we have both seen both the parties hiding military assets in civilian residential areas…so…
I don’t disagree and I’m not saying either side is innocent of doing terrible things. Only pointing out that once the fur is flying, blood is flowing, and things are burning. Questions of treaties, accords and memorandums are irrelevant to the parties engaged. We’re all looking in from the outside evaluating -passing judgement. None of us have skin in the game as they say.

War always kindles the reaction to do horrible things. I can think of no more horrible thing than two men struggling in face to face combat and one having to sink a knife into the flesh of another to extinguish his life up close in person. Seeing his eyes gloss over.
And we debate the morality of actions in war. Men and nations do what they think they have to, to survive, to win.

As I think we both agree both sides likely have committed “war crimes”.
In the end the winner will declare who was guilty of war crimes. With a post script in small print that both sides were likely guilty of doing whatever.
 
War is war and in it whether we like it or not, sometimes the end justifies the means and that will not change until humanity changes and leaves wars aside.
It’s interesting I just read a narrative where someone replies to this question in a matter of fact way.

“The ends always justify the means”

Adding that one word and it completely shifted the altered the intention.
 
They reported observing minor superficial scorching to the top of the reactor dome roof of Unit 6 and scoring of a concrete slab supporting the primary make-up water storage tanks.
“Although the damage at unit 6 has not compromised nuclear safety, this was a serious incident that had the potential to undermine the integrity of the reactor’s containment system,” Director General Grossi said.
Oh come on, they barely scratched the paint.
It's made of hardened steel and reinforced concrete.
 
One thing to know about nuclear engineers is they're really pedantic when it comes to safety (a good thing in nuclear engineering). I usually joke that when someone designs a system with a backup for a backup for a backup, they're probably a nuclear engineer.
 
👀 👇

Was going to post it here. But thought it deserved its own thread.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So this was Ukraine launching a limited strike against Russian defenses at the plant? All that I’ve heard is that what ever ballistics that were used were not even marginally callable of doing critical damage to the reactor buildings.
So Ukraine did it, so what, it’s their power plant. This whole morality or culpability question of involving a nuclear generation plant in armed conflict pretty much went out the window when Russia shelled it and its facilities at the start of the war. Or when the damn was blown.

Russia and Ukraine both agreed to the Geneva convention additional protocols of 1977 article 56 first sentence.
Works or installations containing dangerous forces, namely dams, dykes and nuclear electrical generating stations, shall not be made the object of attack, even where these objects are military objectives, if such attack may cause the release of dangerous forces and consequent severe losses among the civilian population.

So at this point who did it is pretty much irrelevant, is it not? As far as I can tell who is committing “war crimes” in this war is kinda of a mute question.

I would point out that by and large the preponderance of Ukraines drone attacks inside Russia have mostly been against Russian infrastructure, oil production/refineries, military, and transportations.
The same cannot be said for Russias targeting in and around Ukrainian cities.
Right on point, and drones do not pose a threat to the plant - even if small explosive load should set off a bigger cashe of ammo mines or explosives, why did the Russian place it there in the first place? This is just trying to give the nuclear waste fear new life, or trolling after attacking Ukraines energy infrastructure. It was much worse in 2022 when they actually shelled and penetrated some of the buildings there. Russian troops shouldnt have any places to rest in occupied Ukraine.
 
Right on point, and drones do not pose a threat to the plant - even if small explosive load should set off a bigger cashe of ammo mines or explosives, why did the Russian place it there in the first place? This is just trying to give the nuclear waste fear new life, or trolling after attacking Ukraines energy infrastructure. It was much worse in 2022 when they actually shelled and penetrated some of the buildings there. Russian troops shouldnt have any places to rest in occupied Ukraine.
In the fog and obfuscation of war everyone sees what they want to see.
At least Until the fleet is sunk and the infantry is spent.
so Russia will spin this one way and Ukraine another.

I don’t know who did it and really don’t see much point in worrying who bombed the plant. There is a war going on what were we expecting. There are no officials on the field throwing penalty flags. The penalties will be arbitrated latter
 
IMF says Russia is leading economically ahead of European countries and USA. UK helping by continuing oil purchases from Russia aswell.
Amazing effort considering sanctions failure. Sources easily found, sorry for lack of ability to show. But I did find it easily and very interesting. My source bbc.com
 
IMF says Russia is leading economically ahead of European countries and USA. UK helping by continuing oil purchases from Russia aswell.
Amazing effort considering sanctions failure. Sources easily found, sorry for lack of ability to show. But I did find it easily and very interesting. My source bbc.com
Perhaps this article?
 
IMF says Russia is leading economically ahead of European countries and USA. UK helping by continuing oil purchases from Russia aswell.
Amazing effort considering sanctions failure. Sources easily found, sorry for lack of ability to show. But I did find it easily and very interesting. My source bbc.com
Meh just means growth is higher for the year than the other 2, which after a contraction the previous 2 years should really be expected as they find ways to bypass sanctions.
 
Makes you kinda wonder what the motives and sub Rosa alliance some of these western leaders are actually involved with.
 
You can always count on the Americans to do the right thing after they have tried everything else.
- Churchill

The situation remains dire. However, this is a welcome development. I regard Johnson as someone who's out of his depth, but - credit where it's due - like Mike Pence before him, he did put his political future on the line in order to do the right thing. And this is how you make America great again.
 
You can always count on the Americans to do the right thing after they have tried everything else.
- Churchill

The situation remains dire. However, this is a welcome development. I regard Johnson as someone who's out of his depth, but - credit where it's due - like Mike Pence before him, he did put his political future on the line in order to do the right thing. And this is how you make America great again.
Can you explain to me exactly what makes America great? Are you not the greatest military power, still the greatest economic power? What do you want more?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom