• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7th Jan - 4th June '24

Status
Not open for further replies.
Then Russia should end its full scale Invasion that it started unjustly and unprovoked. Oh sorry I meant "3 day operation". 🙄

I for one can't wait until everyone approves it, should have a long time ago. So far who have approved are:
- Finland
- UK
- the Netherlands
- France
- Poland
- Czech Republic
- Estonia
- Latvia
- Lithuania
- Sweden
- Denmark
- Canada


No Russian response. Their threats are as empty as space. Just like the tanks, just like the fighter jets, everyone is slowly coming around to it clearly. 😍
n this list, well, the countries, including Canada, did not send any offensive weapons, the offensive weapons are minimal. The USA is slow. And, it’s voluntary!
 
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken signaled that the U.S. is weighing the idea of allowing Kyiv to strike Russian territory with American-provided weapons. (WSJ)

They need to hurry their asses up and say yes! Absolutely crazy we haven't said yes yet. Our government's inaction is preventing Ukrainian lives from being saved.
 
I have maintained from virtually the beginning that it is absurd and indefensible to maintain Ukraine cannot or should not strike at military logistics and select infrastructure in Russia. While hoping they were to ever prevail in forcing Russia back. There is I suppose a limit to how hard they could push this. But off hand it was just a laughable position to take.
Along that same track prohibiting effective and accurate weaponry to from NATO nations is just as nonsensical. Limits, maybe prohibitions? Then Ukraine should just surrender now. It is virtually impossible for them to prevail with out them doing so.
It also sends an interesting message to Russias civilians. Yes nato will help Ukraine drive Russia from Ukraine. But the distinction should always be towards striking targets supporting Russias invasion into Ukraine. Not invading Russia or targeting its civilians.
Western ballistic weapons are going to be much more accurate which actually helps to achieve this goal. In theory of course.

As far as this back and forth about Nukes and who’s targeting who, who’s at risk of being invaded.
One question. Whom is it that is regularly mentioning the specter of nuclear war.
Even the US response to a potential tactical nuke being used by Russian was a massive “conventional” response.

This is not 1950 at check point Charley anymore.
Whom ever commented of India and Chinas message to Russia regarding this I believe is correct. IF this were to happen I think a limited exchange is still unlikely. Unless a NATO nation or military base was hit. Then it’s a situationally dependent event.
Even if the west only responded with conventional weaponry. It would spark almost certainly a proliferation of nuclear nations.
 
CNN also has a report which Ukraine complains about Abram's tanks being useless in the war due to bad armourment and drones use by Russia. Stating what may have worked in middle east doesn't in Ukraine. Sorry can't provide link though someone was kind enough to find my last claim and provide link. I do not lie. I just find Ukraine is being very sooky and lots of complaining about US military weapons supply. And that isn't very grateful for much to do with military support let alone all the cash received that they constantly need more and more and more. 🙄🤦‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️🤣😂🤣 thankyou @Ben Dhyani 👍🤝
 
Last edited:
CNN also has a report which Ukraine complains about Abram's tanks being useless in the war due to bad armourment and drones use by Russia. Stating what may have worked in middle east doesn't in Ukraine. Sorry can't provide link though someone was kind enough to find my last claim and provide link. I do not lie. I just find Ukraine is being very sooky and lots of complaining about US military weapons supply. And that isn't very grateful for much to do with military support let alone all the cash received that they constantly need more and more and more. 🙄🤦‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️🤣😂🤣 thankyou @Ben Dhyani 👍🤝
The problem with Abrams in Ukraine isn't the tank itself, it's the doctrine that is supposed to be used in tandem with other combat vehicles/service vehicles, and infantry trained in NATO tactics. Ukraine just does not have that on the scale neccessary to achieve their goals. That's why limited Abrams use, and even Limited Bradley use to some extent, is not as near as valuable as a truly NATO trained armored division/brigade/etc. Abrams in a support role just don't seem useful in my mind. The tank itself is easily the best tank in the world, and I feel like the russians know that. That's why our military equipment is seen as such a trophy to collect.
 
The problem with Abrams in Ukraine isn't the tank itself, it's the doctrine that is supposed to be used in tandem with other combat vehicles/service vehicles, and infantry trained in NATO tactics. Ukraine just does not have that on the scale neccessary to achieve their goals. That's why limited Abrams use, and even Limited Bradley use to some extent, is not as near as valuable as a truly NATO trained armored division/brigade/etc. Abrams in a support role just don't seem useful in my mind. The tank itself is easily the best tank in the world, and I feel like the russians know that. That's why our military equipment is seen as such a trophy to collect.
Exactly. The tanks work, the tanks are just fine. It's how they are used or more so used with. Ukraine didn't have the support units and aircraft to back up its tanks. Military tactics 101.
 
:) CNN chief international security correspondent Nick Paton Walsh talks to Ukrainians on the frontlines of the war against Russia, whose use of US-supplied Abrams tanks isn’t going to plan.
NOW PLAYING
‘Not sufficient’: Ukrainian soldiers detail how US-supplied tank is faring in war
And thats when new tactics need to take place. Mobile EW systems moving in tandem or implemented into the Abrams itself. The rear side of the Abrams is weakest, so any infantry near by would need some number of machine guns ready to engage fpvs. Artillery wouldn't be an issue in this instance if they had an adequate airforce. Alot of these issues Ukraine faces with offensive actions could be easily solved with F-16s/f35s
 
CNN also has a report which Ukraine complains about Abram's tanks being useless in the war due to bad armourment and drones use by Russia. Stating what may have worked in middle east doesn't in Ukraine. Sorry can't provide link though someone was kind enough to find my last claim and provide link. I do not lie. I just find Ukraine is being very sooky and lots of complaining about US military weapons supply. And that isn't very grateful for much to do with military support let alone all the cash received that they constantly need more and more and more. 🙄🤦‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️🤣😂🤣 thankyou @Ben Dhyani 👍🤝
All opinion follows


We didn’t give them modern Abram’s. We have active defense system on ours that we have been, so far, unwilling to give to the UA. Mostly for a fear of Russia capturing them intact. We also removed the DU armor. Without these IMO It kinda makes the M-1 a very average tank. We will have to step up or withdraw them.

The Bradley’s we gave have some really good kit, but even those are not top shelf, but closer than the Abram’s. We are planing to retire them so I guess we are looser with them. The Brads have been a tremendous success in the UA and the Ukraines love them and wish they had more (who wouldn’t, they are super awesome IFV’s)
 
Well going on replies now as to how western weapons are affecting the war and why compared to previous claims when announcements made to send these weapons and their affectiveness is perplexing. But very refreshing to hear the reasoning now as to results compared to claims made previously. Lucky for Russia that the West is so well? 🤔supportive? I don't know how to explain the outcome so far but great to see so many here understand why and how it is taking so long and understand Ukrainian frustration and disappointment with what support, finance and weapons they have received. Obviously now it is easier to see what the west has actually achieved so far. Or atleast obviously the reasoning behind it as so many here understand it. Thankyou for your replies and reasoning behind Ukrainian complaints. Now understand better why you feel sorry for them. Seems to be a mix of Russian and western actions. And Ukraine is the innocent piggy in the middle suffering a slow destruction and loss of land as a result. Your opinions are very enlightening as to Ukrainian situation and opinions of western support. Thankyou. 🤝👍
 
Well going on replies now as to how western weapons are affecting the war and why compared to previous claims when announcements made to send these weapons and their affectiveness is perplexing. But very refreshing to hear the reasoning now as to results compared to claims made previously. Lucky for Russia that the West is so well? 🤔supportive? I don't know how to explain the outcome so far but great to see so many here understand why and how it is taking so long and understand Ukrainian frustration and disappointment with what support, finance and weapons they have received. Obviously now it is easier to see what the west has actually achieved so far. Or atleast obviously the reasoning behind it as so many here understand it. Thankyou for your replies and reasoning behind Ukrainian complaints. Now understand better why you feel sorry for them. Seems to be a mix of Russian and western actions. And Ukraine is the innocent piggy in the middle suffering a slow destruction and loss of land as a result. Your opinions are very enlightening as to Ukrainian situation and opinions of western support. Thankyou. 🤝👍
I would classify the Ukraine as the plucky Brit holding the line, alone against an evil expansionist regime and the USA as the USA….
 
Obviously now it is easier to see what the west has actually achieved so far.
West has done a lot for Ukrainians. It turned Putins "3 day operation" into a 3 year operation. 😂

Even if Ukraine doesn't take back all its land, still a big win for the West & Ukraine. It has been quite a long miserable humiliating embarrassment for Russia. Setting them back, hurting their oil production. Show they can't even win a war on their doorstep.

Has also proven how poor Russian weapons are. Would also explain why Russian arms exports have shrunk dramatically following the full scale Invasion & war.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
:) CNN chief international security correspondent Nick Paton Walsh talks to Ukrainians on the frontlines of the war against Russia, whose use of US-supplied Abrams tanks isn’t going to plan.
NOW PLAYING
‘Not sufficient’: Ukrainian soldiers detail how US-supplied tank is faring in war
Tank warfare is an intricate dance with boots on the ground air cover and coordination. I’m not surprised it’s not been a magic bullet. Just as the T-90 and 14 were not. Ukraine does not have the time to develop a doctrine to successfully employ them. Just as the Russians existing tank doctrine failed them. As far as being snarky, yeah kind of is.
it’s hard I supposes to be the Energizer Bunny of Cheerleaders. When your nations been invaded and your citizens have been being killed for 2+ years.
So I can personally overlook any snarkyness of Zelensky. It’s not helpful maybe, especially for Russia and PR points. Lord knows all of the quotes that would have came from Churchill DeGaulle.
Well going on replies now as to how western weapons are affecting the war and why compared to previous claims when announcements made to send these weapons and their affectiveness is perplexing. But very refreshing to hear the reasoning now as to results compared to claims made previously. Lucky for Russia that the West is so well? 🤔supportive? I don't know how to explain the outcome so far but great to see so many here understand why and how it is taking so long and understand Ukrainian frustration and disappointment with what support, finance and weapons they have received. Obviously now it is easier to see what the west has actually achieved so far. Or atleast obviously the reasoning behind it as so many here understand it. Thankyou for your replies and reasoning behind Ukrainian complaints. Now understand better why you feel sorry for them. Seems to be a mix of Russian and western actions. And Ukraine is the innocent piggy in the middle suffering a slow destruction and loss of land as a result. Your opinions are very enlightening as to Ukrainian situation and opinions of western support. Thankyou. 🤝👍
Well if we’re going to lament all the things that have gone wrong in this war. Let’s not forget and leave out the colonialist authoritarian who launched the war in the first place. And who contrary to common sense has refused to acknowledge the failure of Russias invasion ambitions. Who has subsequently entrenched their ambitions and authoritarian battlefield tactics disregarding the cost in human suffering of Ukrainian civilians and deaths of a solders on both sides well in excess of 100,000. Also let’s not forget routinely sending his acolytes to mumble some hyperbolic rant about risk of nuclear Armageddon
But sure let’s deflect the cause and continuation of this war on nebulous greed and pointless ambitions of greedy politicians in the. West and Ukraine.
While the simplest and clearest reason for why this war continues is right in our face.
Walter Durante would be so proud.
 
Tank warfare is an intricate dance with boots on the ground air cover and coordination. I’m not surprised it’s not been a magic bullet. Just as the T-90 and 14 were not. Ukraine does not have the time to develop a doctrine to successfully employ them. Just as the Russians existing tank doctrine failed them. As far as being snarky, yeah kind of is.
it’s hard I supposes to be the Energizer Bunny of Cheerleaders. When your nations been invaded and your citizens have been being killed for 2+ years.
So I can personally overlook any snarkyness of Zelensky. It’s not helpful maybe, especially for Russia and PR points. Lord knows all of the quotes that would have came from Churchill DeGaulle.

Well if we’re going to lament all the things that have gone wrong in this war. Let’s not forget and leave out the colonialist authoritarian who launched the war in the first place. And who contrary to common sense has refused to acknowledge the failure of Russias invasion ambitions. Who has subsequently entrenched their ambitions and authoritarian battlefield tactics disregarding the cost in human suffering of Ukrainian civilians and deaths of a solders on both sides well in excess of 100,000. Also let’s not forget routinely sending his acolytes to mumble some hyperbolic rant about risk of nuclear Armageddon
But sure let’s deflect the cause and continuation of this war on nebulous greed and pointless ambitions of greedy politicians in the. West and Ukraine.
While the simplest and clearest reason for why this war continues is right in our face.
Walter Durante would be so proud.
Summary sounds like your disappointed aswell. Either for same or different reasons.
 
Well all sides have had a change of opinion with this conflict and some have realised it is obviously not the outcome so far as to original opinions. The end result will remain the same i believe and is showing that hasn't changed at all. Only the timeline. I only bought such topic to attention as I haven't seen such reports being shown here. Probably for obvious reasons, none the less it is valid and important to show all sides of the issues , no matter your preferences. As these are Ukrainian opinions I figured it might be more appropriate-acceptable to announce backed with different sources of less conflicting accusations. Thankyou for your attention and opinions, I hope it is news to some here that they weren't aware of and find interesting. 😉👍🤝
 
More military aid, intelligence, and logistical relief will help the Ukrainians achieve victory. For whatever reason the current administration and the political tools of our government don't understand that Russia has bluffed so many times they have next to little credibility in their threats. Why do we continue the trickle and extended halt of military aid? We could easily give them the means to finish this war in way of an actual formidable defensive airforce, while not even touching our neccessary reserves. It's sad and fully to blame on the foreign and domestic actors that have run many different media campaigns to turn this into a political issue. It is simply a country fighting for it's freedom to exist at this point and Putin proved that with his initial advances at the beginning of the war. USA lacks momentum and it is showing disastrously.
 
Summary sounds like your disappointed aswell. Either for same or different reasons.
No I’m not disappointed in the sense that they are not all the rage. To think that Abrams were going to perform with Ukrainian soldiers vs success with US. Not particularly surprised by that. Instead of being tactically offensive weapons their squad level support and armored defense.
My disappointment is as I’ve said NATO has been reactionary and slow to adapt.
And Russia is still it seems quite comfortable with fighting a war of attrition resulting Ukraine being ravaged and 100000 to 200000 deaths simply to prop up some post-coital colonialist ambition.
Should nato have done things differently? Absolutely.
Would we have had to be asking ourselves these questions if Putin didn’t have such a hard on for Novo-Russia.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom