• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7th Jan - 4th June '24

Status
Not open for further replies.
And Russia is still it seems quite comfortable with fighting a war of attrition resulting Ukraine being ravaged and 100000 to 200000 deaths simply to prop up some post-coital colonialist ambition.
Should nato have done things differently? Absolutely.
I agree - NATO should be looking to adapt to the situation as I do not see Russia changing its approach any time soon.
Russia's current casualty count is nothing compared to what they endured from WWII. Soviets lost 27 million people in the war, of which 8 million were military. Putin (born in 1952) grew up in the post-war era, and his early life was heavy influenced by the impact this had on Soviet society. But despite these losses, the USSR eventually became a significant world power to some degree.

I am speculating here. I bet the prevailing attitude at the top levels of the Russian military is that they honestly believe they can absorb their current losses given their past experiences. Additionally, since their current economy is much more market based than it was under the centrally planned Soviet command economy, it is potentially a bit more resilient and flexible then it was under the Soviet system. Russian leaders likely believe that, if they keep the conflict contained to Ukraine (i.e. no damage to Russian cities, manufacturing capability, or economic capacity), they can carry on much longer than NATO or the west is willing to. Also, if a US interest somewhere else in the world were to come under attack (say China moves on Taiwan, the DPRK stirs up trouble with ROK, or Iran fully engages Israel), US interest in Ukraine may be diverted, leaving NATO in a weaker position to support Ukraine.
 
Last edited:
I think this situation is taking a turn for the worse. Currently we have Russia in an existential war on its border not seen since both world wars. Second for the first time we have a western military block funding a proxy war on Russia's border. Third we have for the first time attacks against Russian strategic capabilities. Fourth and likely we will see for the first time ever American weapons being used to directly attack Russians in Russia.

That's a lot of firsts that we never did see in the cold war.

I think the situation is moving from bad to grave.
 
I think this situation is taking a turn for the worse. Currently we have Russia in an existential war on its border not seen since both world wars. Second for the first time we have a western military block funding a proxy war on Russia's border. Third we have for the first time attacks against Russian strategic capabilities. Fourth and likely we will see for the first time ever American weapons being used to directly attack Russians in Russia.

That's a lot of firsts that we never did see in the cold war.

I think the situation is moving from bad to grave.
Existential war? Please clarify on that. Who is pointing to its nuclear arsenal every 3rd day and makes the world ponder? Russia could stop this anytime, when Russia escalates it gets worse - so yes in some sense you are right it is getting worse. But it can still be reversed if the leaders take the necessary steps. It will take courage and pride swallowing.
 
Existential war? Please clarify on that. Who is pointing to its nuclear arsenal every 3rd day and makes the world ponder? Russia could stop this anytime, when Russia escalates it gets worse - so yes in some sense you are right it is getting worse. But it can still be reversed if the leaders take the necessary steps. It will take courage and pride swallowing.
Putin said it himself that it is an existential war. I wrote that not as my opinion however I do believe he has merit with such a statement.
 
Well its existential for Putin and his regime for sure, existential for Russia that has a larger surface area then the planet pluto not so much.
I disagree. People in Russia don't like Putin much, as well as me hating him outright. Escaping from Putin's propaganda was the reason I ended up around here.
But people in Russia do feel genuine existential threat from a Western block.

And people are terrified of what's going on in Western countries regarding to common people, they don't want to end up like that and ready to protect their freedoms even if it means cooperating with Putin's regime.

Especially, given "special" attitude of the Western people to Russians, when Nazis unleashed total war and a massive genocide of Soviet people, unlike they behaved to other Europeans.
But Hitler and his ideology didn't materialized out of thin air, such attitude towards Russian people in the West, was spanning for centuries before him and still is present, if not more profound. These ideas are always fed from above to below, to common people. Further demonization of those who get a finger pointed at and warmongering attitude of Western people doesn't help either.

History of Russia had shown that the West behaves well and fair only when it is held at gunpoint. Every time Russia gets a period of weakness or lowers it's guard - ends up awfully.
West cannot be trusted - this is the fact that is set within the roots of a Russian mindset so deep, that no Putin or other dictator can ever change.


I also suggest you to read through Russian Telegram channels quoting Putin's statements about "dear partners from the West", see other news about more strikes done by Western weapons and reconnaissance flights near Russian territory and you'll see public outrage blaming exactly Putin for all that. They don't even blame West that much, because Russian people understand that nobody can expect anything good from them, West being an enemy is only natural, they cannot be bargained with and the fact cannot be changed, but at least the Russian president must be responsible to protect against them - yet he sells Russian people the idea that we're not in a struggle alone against largest military block in history, but must behave well around them.
Russian public realizes that Putin's connection to the West are more important for him than the opinion and security of Russian people.

and your point about Russian land size is totally wrong as well - near all of this is a barren wilderness of low value, habitable area worth living by itself is pretty small, and all that ties this country as an entity is centered in a line of some cities that centered around Moscow, which is far more vulnerable than it seems. That's about it.
 
Last edited:
Putin said it himself that it is an existential war. I wrote that not as my opinion however I do believe he has merit with such a statement.
Wrong. Putin doesn't push an idea of existential war, because he seeks to keep Russian public as calm as possible, he wants them to be deceived and on lower guard.

Western media often puts their own words into his mouth and publish it. Power of Western media complex is so overwhelming you can just put blatant lies and it'll work.

In fact, you can check that himself, he doesn't put statements often.
 
I disagree. People in Russia don't like Putin much, as well as me hating him outright. Escaping from Putin's propaganda was the reason I ended up around here.
But people in Russia do feel genuine existential threat from a Western block.

And people are terrified of what's going on in Western countries regarding to common people, they don't want to end up like that and ready to protect their freedoms even if it means cooperating with Putin's regime.

Especially, given "special" attitude of the Western people to Russians, when Nazis unleashed total war and a massive genocide of Soviet people, unlike they behaved to other Europeans.
But Hitler and his ideology didn't materialized out of thin air, such attitude towards Russian people in the West, was spanning for centuries before him and still is present, if not more profound. These ideas are always fed from above to below, to common people. Further demonization of those who get a finger pointed at and warmongering attitude of Western people doesn't help either.

History of Russia had shown that the West behaves well and fair only when it is held at gunpoint. Every time Russia gets a period of weakness or lowers it's guard - ends up awfully.
West cannot be trusted - this is the fact that is set within the roots of a Russian mindset so deep, that no Putin or other dictator can ever change.


I also suggest you to read through Russian Telegram channels quoting Putin's statements about "dear partners from the West", see other news about more strikes done by Western weapons and reconnaissance flights near Russian territory and you'll see public outrage blaming exactly Putin for all that. They don't even blame West that much, because Russian people understand that nobody can expect anything good from them, West being an enemy is only natural, they cannot be bargained with and the fact cannot be changed, but at least the Russian president must be responsible to protect against them - yet he sells Russian people the idea that we're not in a struggle alone against largest military block in history, but must behave well around them.
Russian public realizes that Putin's connection to the West are more important for him than the opinion and security of Russian people.

and your point about Russian land size is totally wrong as well - near all of this is a barren wilderness of low value, habitable area worth living by itself is pretty small, and all that ties this country as an entity is centered in a line of some cities that centered around Moscow, which is far more vulnerable than it seems. That's about it.
Quite a change of tune you have here from previous posts. What gives? You once told me you thought Putin was a strong leader. Now you say you hate him. What are you playing at exactly?
 
Wrong. Putin doesn't push an idea of existential war, because he seeks to keep Russian public as calm as possible, he wants them to be deceived and on lower guard.

Western media often puts their own words into his mouth and publish it. Power of Western media complex is so overwhelming you can just put blatant lies and it'll work.

In fact, you can check that himself, he doesn't put statements often.
There are many quotes taken directly from his speaks that although do not state "existential" they can be taken to mean that. Such as this one "I do not even know if such an ethnic group as the Russian people will be able to survive in the form in which it exists today," Putin said. "They have one goal: to disband the former Soviet Union and its fundamental part - the Russian Federation," Putin told Rossiya 1 state television in an interview recorded on Wednesday but released on Sunday
 
I think this situation is taking a turn for the worse. Currently we have Russia in an existential war on its border not seen since both world wars. Second for the first time we have a western military block funding a proxy war on Russia's border. Third we have for the first time attacks against Russian strategic capabilities. Fourth and likely we will see for the first time ever American weapons being used to directly attack Russians in Russia.

That's a lot of firsts that we never did see in the cold war.

I think the situation is moving from bad to grave.
Proxy wars were literally the staple of the Cold War the fact it’s on Russias border is nobody’s fault but Russias. Also patriots have been shooting at targets over Russia for months at this point.
 
I agree - NATO should be looking to adapt to the situation as I do not see Russia changing its approach any time soon.
Russia's current casualty count is nothing compared to what they endured from WWII. Soviets lost 27 million people in the war, of which 8 million were military. Putin (born in 1952) grew up in the post-war era, and his early life was heavy influenced by the impact this had on Soviet society. But despite these losses, the USSR eventually became a significant world power to some degree.

I am speculating here. I bet the prevailing attitude at the top levels of the Russian military is that they honestly believe they can absorb their current losses given their past experiences. Additionally, since their current economy is much more market based than it was under the centrally planned Soviet command economy, it is potentially a bit more resilient and flexible then it was under the Soviet system. Russian leaders likely believe that, if they keep the conflict contained to Ukraine (i.e. no damage to Russian cities, manufacturing capability, or economic capacity), they can carry on much longer than NATO or the west is willing to. Also, if a US interest somewhere else in the world were to come under attack (say China moves on Taiwan, the DPRK stirs up trouble with ROK, or Iran fully engages Israel), US interest in Ukraine may be diverted, leaving NATO in a weaker position to support Ukraine.

I think this has no sense. Russia has no reasons to continue a war without an objective. If NATO (via Ukraine) begins to strike at Russian rears, for Russia will become simply impossible to continue its military operations into Ukraine. Macron told the true, when he said that for Ukraine is possible to defend itself, if it is forbidden to strike into Russia. So, why Russia should decide to do what you think: stay there, in an kind of strange "attrition mode", leaving NATO playing darts with it, without a strategy. NATO could stay an infinite time playing darts against Russian soil, if Russia stay there to take the darts as an idiot! To be big and muscled and then to decide to take slaps in the face, it's not an "attriton strategy": it is... to take slaps in the face. It has no sense.

I am convinced that we are on the verge of turning point. As soon as Ukraine will begins to strike at Russian rears (logistic lines, C2, weapons depots, industries, ... ), there will be only 2 option: or Russia retreats, or Russia escalates. If it decides to "beat around the bush", hoping in a kind of armistice, it will only postpone the time in which it will decide to retreat or to escalate, because is by now very clear that NATO-Ukraine will never accept any kind of "armistice" and they will keep to strike at Russia until Russia will retreat. NATO-Ukraine determination to do so is steel, parly because many Occidental politicians are very fanatic, parly because Russia has always prouved to not have red lines at all, thus encouraging, in the West, the war-party.

The problem for Russia is the following: the red lines do exists. Any red line crossing, is supposed to cause a reaction. When a further red lines is crossed, is supposed that the following reaction will be stronger than the previous one. Finally, we arrive at the potential last red line that, if crossed, cause a nuclear responce. Ok: but all this raisoning works if each time a red line is crossed, there is a reaction. If there is a reaction when a red line is crossed, then the ennemy knows that there will be a reaction if a further red line is crossed: this calms the hotheads. But if the red lines are crossed and you always do nothing, you can't wait the "last red line" to respond with nukes: you can't pass from NOTHING to ALL, from 0 to 100. Russia is pushing itself in condition in which any appropriate responce to a red line crossing becomes, little by little, not feasible. So, if should bet, I think that finally Russia will retreat (also from Crimea), after having tried to achieve a kind of armistice. Then we can discuss about "how". After all, even the Instambull draft treaty contemplated the return of Crimea into Ukraine in 15 years.
 
Last edited:
Proxy wars were literally the staple of the Cold War the fact it’s on Russias border is nobody’s fault but Russias.
Yep yep yep.

This could all end if Putin stops its unjust & unprovoked full scale war against Ukraine starting the largest war in Europe itself since World War Two.

Then Putin can turn around lie, tell it's people they won, and then Russia can move on to their next likly target Georgia or Moldova in a few years after licking their wounds. 🙄
 
Last edited by a moderator:
History of Russia had shown that the West behaves well and fair only when it is held at gunpoint. Every time Russia gets a period of weakness or lowers it's guard - ends up awfully.
@Citizen-21 is right about that. When the Soviet Union collapsed, the West took advantage of it. Now, don't let's pretend that Russia is innocent in all this. Putin misses the old empire, but in his own words he doesn't want it back. At least that was true a couple decades ago. The old boy has changed.

Right or wrong, though, Russia sees itself as defending against an enemy. And so Russia has transformed into a monster. We can complain about who is at fault all we want. But we have to deal with what we have, not what should be or what we want.

And so Russia has to be stopped. Or they will continue until more countries are swallowed up.

The problem is that the West is really bad at stopping monsters before it is too late. North Korea should have been stopped, but they weren't and so now we have to contend with their nuclear weapons. Iran should be stopped, but the West won't do it, and so we will soon have to deal with their nuclear weapons.

Russia already has them and has the paranoia to use them. So what do we do? Allow them to continue to invade and capture countries?
 
@Citizen-21 is right about that. When the Soviet Union collapsed, the West took advantage of it. Now, don't let's pretend that Russia is innocent in all this. Putin misses the old empire, but in his own words he doesn't want it back. At least that was true a couple decades ago. The old boy has changed.

Right or wrong, though, Russia sees itself as defending against an enemy. And so Russia has transformed into a monster. We can complain about who is at fault all we want. But we have to deal with what we have, not what should be or what we want.

And so Russia has to be stopped. Or they will continue until more countries are swallowed up.

The problem is that the West is really bad at stopping monsters before it is too late. North Korea should have been stopped, but they weren't and so now we have to contend with their nuclear weapons. Iran should be stopped, but the West won't do it, and so we will soon have to deal with their nuclear weapons.

Russia already has them and has the paranoia to use them. So what do we do? Allow them to continue to invade and capture countries?
The biggest foreign policy failure in the past 80 years was not pushing hard enough for the integration of Russia into the west after the collapse of the Soviet Union.
 
See things from Putin's perspective.
This is a man who grew up in a land where paranoia reigned supreme, to survive you must be suspicious.
The growing list of people who have fell out of windows is evidence of this.

Putin has killed or exiled most of the people who disagreed with him, he has surrounded himself with yes men. He is cut off from the facts on the ground, living in his own little bubble inside the walls of the Kremlin.
He's essentially a conspiracy theorist, he believes the CIA backed a coup in Ukraine to remove a Russia-friendly president, he believes that once Zelensky and his government are gone, the both Ukrainians and Russians shall live in harmony, a bulwark against the decadent West.

Anyone who disagrees or contradicts him gets woven into a complex web of conspiracy and paranoia, and ultimately ends up falling from 20 stories. This is the man Ukraine is dealing with. Reasoning with him is akin to convincing a flat Earther that the world is a sphere, no matter what evidence you provide, they just weave you into the conspiracy, you become 'one of them'.
 
See things from Putin's perspective.
This is a man who grew up in a land where paranoia reigned supreme, to survive you must be suspicious.
The growing list of people who have fell out of windows is evidence of this.

Putin has killed or exiled most of the people who disagreed with him, he has surrounded himself with yes men. He is cut off from the facts on the ground, living in his own little bubble inside the walls of the Kremlin.
He's essentially a conspiracy theorist, he believes the CIA backed a coup in Ukraine to remove a Russia-friendly president, he believes that once Zelensky and his government are gone, the both Ukrainians and Russians shall live in harmony, a bulwark against the decadent West.

Anyone who disagrees or contradicts him gets woven into a complex web of conspiracy and paranoia, and ultimately ends up falling from 20 stories. This is the man Ukraine is dealing with. Reasoning with him is akin to convincing a flat Earther that the world is a sphere, no matter what evidence you provide, they just weave you into the conspiracy, you become 'one of them'.
In some respects, Putin reminds me of Yuri Andropov.
 
Putin has killed or exiled most of the people who disagreed with him,
And... virtually has slaughtered his opposition by drafting the younger generation more outspoken against Putin & the minorities in Siberia less Pro-Kremlin by turning them into cannon fodder.

No denying Putin has used this war to send off what he considered undesirables into Ukraine to kill them off. Particularly the minorities in Siberia have been targeted aggressively by inscription.
 
I think this situation is taking a turn for the worse. Currently we have Russia in an existential war on its border not seen since both world wars. Second for the first time we have a western military block funding a proxy war on Russia's border. Third we have for the first time attacks against Russian strategic capabilities. Fourth and likely we will see for the first time ever American weapons being used to directly attack Russians in Russia.

That's a lot of firsts that we never did see in the cold war.

I think the situation is moving from bad to grave.
Maybe Putin should have thought about all of that before sending tanks over the border to kill Ukrainians.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom