• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7th Jan - 4th June '24

Status
Not open for further replies.
The real question is, will 96 f-16s plus whatever 150 some odd soviet era jets be enough to establish air dominance? Probably not sadly. I mean do we want this war to end, or do we not? You would think our government would understand what it takes to win in offensive motion after culminating our tactics after so many conflicts. Air power = ground power and combine that with their uav tactics, you have something that could protect the infantry. Ukraine needs at LEAST 250 F-16s/modern fighters to establish worthwhile air superiority along the front. Without this anything else is worthless in an offensive manner.
 
The real question is, will 96 f-16s plus whatever 150 some odd soviet era jets be enough to establish air dominance? Probably not sadly. I mean do we want this war to end, or do we not? You would think our government would understand what it takes to win in offensive motion after culminating our tactics after so many conflicts. Air power = ground power and combine that with their uav tactics, you have something that could protect the infantry. Ukraine needs at LEAST 250 F-16s/modern fighters to establish worthwhile air superiority along the front. Without this anything else is worthless in an offensive manner.
They might not achieve air dominance but I guarantee it will affect the Russians ability to fly over Ukraine in the current matter effectively unopposed.
 
They might not achieve air dominance but I guarantee it will affect the Russians ability to fly over Ukraine in the current matter effectively unopposed.
If our NATO nations would step up and send them the proper variants, I think air dominance in the way of Ukraine tactically targeting Russian airfields with ATACMS and other means such as drones, could be possible. Not with their current stocks of air defense would this be feasible to maintain, but hopefully another military package comes soon with some actual balls from our gov to finish this war.
 
They don't have air superiority, the A-10s would be very ineffective.
This is pretty much mute currently, but if they sent A-10’s in there would also be a pretty well established Air CAP. That’s the thing there are no real magic bullet weapon systems. It’s always about coordination and adaptability.
Just like the vaunted Russia armor, throw in javelin systems and everything changes.
 
This is pretty much mute currently, but if they sent A-10’s in there would also be a pretty well established Air CAP. That’s the thing there are no real magic bullet weapon systems. It’s always about coordination and adaptability.
Just like the vaunted Russia armor, throw in javelin systems and everything changes.
Exactly. 👍👍👍
 
See things from Putin's perspective.
This is a man who grew up in a land where paranoia reigned supreme, to survive you must be suspicious.
The growing list of people who have fell out of windows is evidence of this.

Putin has killed or exiled most of the people who disagreed with him, he has surrounded himself with yes men. He is cut off from the facts on the ground, living in his own little bubble inside the walls of the Kremlin.
He's essentially a conspiracy theorist, he believes the CIA backed a coup in Ukraine to remove a Russia-friendly president, he believes that once Zelensky and his government are gone, the both Ukrainians and Russians shall live in harmony, a bulwark against the decadent West.

Anyone who disagrees or contradicts him gets woven into a complex web of conspiracy and paranoia, and ultimately ends up falling from 20 stories. This is the man Ukraine is dealing with. Reasoning with him is akin to convincing a flat Earther that the world is a sphere, no matter what evidence you provide, they just weave you into the conspiracy, you become 'one of them'.
When you wield the reins of power you stop being a conspiracy theorist and are now a conspiracy maker.
To be fair, think it’s safe to say there was US and others help to ferment the Maiden revolution.
Just as it’s likely accurate to say there was Russian security services influencers also in Ukraine during the 24 years that led up to the Maiden revolution.

Everyone likes to believe the phrase “might makes right” is somehow morally repugnant means of doing business. That’s like arguing that using an electric powered meat grinder. Rather than a hand crank one somehow taints the sausage you’re making.

It’s not that I reject CIA involvement and influence regarding the maiden revolution as false.
I simply maintain well so what!
This is what nations and spy agencies do.
And contrary to popular belief or idealistic naïveté. The morality and wisdom of those actions are more times than not determined by successful outcome.

Or the trope that the US has persecuted the Castro regime for decades vs. what? Doing nothing and letting them spread authoritarian soviet aligned governments throughout Latin america unopposed?
It’s a no brainer unless of course you supported the spread or soviet influence and power in Latin America.
 
Last edited:
This is a man who grew up in a land where paranoia reigned supreme, to survive you must be suspicious.
... or you have to be a bully to survive.
Reflecting upon the podcast I listened to about Putin's background (About a Boy: The Story of Vladimir Putin), he grew up in the courtyards of crowded Soviet style apartment blocks, called dvor, with competition for scarce resources within the apartment block and between apartment blocks. It's the bullies that rose to the top in these courtyards, and I have no doubt that has influenced his leadership style and his approach to dealing with adversaries, regardless of who they are or why they are an adversary. Putin may keep going until he runs into something more powerful than him. (Maybe that more powerful force will be the ground rushing up on his body quickly after he finds himself the victim of defenestration.)

More on that podcast I am referring to:
 
Last edited:
They're just tourists...🥸
And again I say so what?
I would be surprised and disappointed that we embroiled ourselves this much in a foreign conflict and didn’t have SOF in country monitoring and when possible tipping the scales.
 
I think this has no sense. Russia has no reasons to continue a war without an objective.
I think the Russian objective is, at the very least, to keep the west out of Ukraine, or to keep Ukraine from falling under western influence. (I think @DEFCON Warning System has stated this previously.) There may be a larger, more long term objective to create a "greater Russia" as well.

It seems Putin and his military leaders are willing to pay a high price in terms of manpower and equipment (by western standards) to achieve this objective.
 
And again I say so what?
I would be surprised and disappointed that we embroiled ourselves this much in a foreign conflict and didn’t have SOF in country monitoring and when possible tipping the scales.
I think the Russian objective is, at the very least, to keep the west out of Ukraine, or to keep Ukraine from falling under western influence. (I think @DEFCON Warning System has stated this previously.) There may be a larger, more long term objective to create a "greater Russia" as well.

It seems Putin and his military leaders are willing to pay a high price in terms of manpower and equipment (by western standards) to achieve this objective.
I think Ukraine is extremely far removed from ever being pro-russian in the foreseeable future, maybe Putin doesn't have a direct goal at this point, other than to do anything to stay in power.
 
I think Ukraine is extremely far removed from ever being pro-russian in the foreseeable future, maybe Putin doesn't have a direct goal at this point, other than to do anything to stay in power.
That is a fair assessment. Perhaps they went into Ukraine to keep the west out, and then failed miserably by nearly uniting the west against Russia. Perhaps Russia thinks it can still win... or at least wait the West out...
 
That is a fair assessment. Perhaps they went into Ukraine to keep the west out, and then failed miserably by nearly uniting the west against Russia. Perhaps Russia thinks it can still win... or at least wait the West out...
Waiting the west out and hoping that Orban-esque politicians will get elected so the support for Ukraine ends. Potentially with the help or hybrid warfare with refugees and propaganda. Keep influencing Hungary to sow dissent between NATO members in order to cause a split, ideally attacking a Baltic country when Trump are a couple of years in his term. Putin is playing the long game with Ukraine even though at this point most of it is just to make himself stay in power and potentially gain some sympathy from Eastern European countries to move into Russia's "sphere". He'll likely use targets in Russia being hit as an excuse to move the population to the totalitarian direction faster. I'd even imagine that as long as they can keep a foothold in Ukraine not that many things will change with Russian targets being hit; as long as Russia can be in War-economy mode I bet Putin thinks he can just make the West run out of equipment and will make further moves on Ukraine in the windows where equipment is lacking. The only thing that would give him pause would be a major military defeat or an upheaval of the population.
 
potentially gain some sympathy from Eastern European countries
They are all running to NATO in fear of Putins full scale invasion in Eastern Europe. You know Finland & Sweeden recently joining. Now Moldova, Georgia, and many others begging to join NATO out of fear they are next on Putins list.

Putin, best NATO salemen ever to live.
 
They are all running to NATO in fear of Putins full scale invasion in Eastern Europe. You know Finland & Sweeden recently joining. Now Moldova, Georgia, and many others begging to join NATO out of fear they are next on Putins list.

Putin, best NATO salemen ever to live.
Georgia won't as long as Georgian Dream stays in power, and Hungary is a perfect wildcard for Russia to use to sow chaos within NATO. Some nations might not be very pro-Russian right now, but it's likely within Putin's long term goals to try to influence at least some of the ones that haven't joined NATO or are still fairly pro-Russian even though they technically are part of them.
 
They are all running to NATO in fear of Putins full scale invasion in Eastern Europe. You know Finland & Sweeden recently joining. Now Moldova, Georgia, and many others begging to join NATO out of fear they are next on Putins list.

Putin, best NATO salemen ever to live.
The risk is not with Eastern European members. But with the Western ones having a change of position.
 
The risk is not with Eastern European members. But with the Western ones having a change of position.
I was deferring to another member's comment. He said somthing along the lines of Putin trying to bring Eastern Europe into Russian fold. When in reality all of Eastern Europe is running for the hills twords NATO in fear of Russia. This is no opinion but the fact on the ground and Finland/Sweeden joining is just the cherry ontop for proof in my statement.

But I agree with you on your notion with Ukraine & Western Support or continued support.
 
I do think Putin's strategy will either fail or amount to a status quo that bites him in the ass eventually. What's bad is that he is smart, but due to his increasingly quasi-mystical and conspiratorial mindset he can't see outside of his own bubble.
 
The can't see outside of his own bubble.
Here lies in the risk of miscalculations and mistakes leading to military confrontation with NATO. Not that Putin or NATO want a war with each other.

I don't think World War 3 will happen on purpose or intentionally but the opposite though miscommunication, miscalculations, and mistakes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom