• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | Discussions 2024

Status
Not open for further replies.
The numbers that are circulating online over the size of the Ukrainian contingent sent to Kurk region and their lossess, coming from the Russian side are vastly exaggerated imho (1000, with 300 losses).
Possibly to try to justify the evident failure of their border control.

Someone is getting some polonium flavoured coffee in Moscow.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Torch
The numbers that are circulating online over the size of the Ukrainian contingent sent to Kurk region and their lossess, coming from the Russian side are vastly exaggerated imho (1000, with 300 losses).
Possibly to try to justify the evident failure of their border control.

Someone is getting some polonium flavoured coffee in Moscow.
Gerasimov even said during the filmed parts of the security council conference that the incursion has been halted and promised Putin that he'd push them back to the border. The first part sounds a lot like.... vranyo - Wiktionary, the free dictionary , and the second... well, if he fails, his job will be on the chopping block unless he manages to deflect the blame on someone else. If things turn as bad as they did during the Wagner Mutiny, Putin himself might sit somewhat shakily.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Torch
To hold what they got now, would require about 1 division 10k+ ( depth and width ) to move futher in, it would require alot more if they want to keep their flanks safe. ( if you use old doctrines ) I dont think they will move futher in, unless they move more manpower and material into Russia.
 
Russian mainland is a bit like a new war theater.
One difference had become evident today - it is harder for Ukraine to organize proper communication on Russian land. There's no comm towers that used to be theirs, no Starlink network, nothing they own. They have to improvise on the go and it's a struggle, not even mentioning logistical complication and lack of local civilian support.

They taken the fight out of their comfort zone without clear objectives.
Due to that there's a lot of critical going on around Ukrainian social media about this.
 
I think the objectives are clear:

1. Getting land to trade for own land.
2. Showing Putins and the Russian military weakness.
3. Disrupting Russian operations in the Donbas or Khakiv oblasts, if they have to pull troops from there.

Other objectives could be raiding, and converting Russian troops (prisoners) to enlist into Russian volunter corp.
Taking control of the key gas pipeline to certain contries.
A suicide raid ( 30 man, loaded with explosives ) to capture Nuclear infrastructure, and trade it for Zaporisjzja Powerplant?
Oh I forgot the F-16s - maybe its going to be good practise for them. ( and opening for more drones? ) also more saboteurs could infiltrate Russia.

There is also a double edged sword, Putin could use this to call upon more troops, I dont think there is large enough troop concentration to use tactical nukes.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Torch
I think the objectives are clear:

1. Getting land to trade for own land.
2. Showing Putins and the Russian military weakness.
3. Disrupting Russian operations in the Donbas or Khakiv oblasts, if they have to pull troops from there.

Other objectives could be raiding, and converting Russian troops (prisoners) to enlist into Russian volunter corp.
Taking control of the key gas pipeline to certain contries.
A suicide raid ( 30 man, loaded with explosives ) to capture Nuclear infrastructure, and trade it for Zaporisjzja Powerplant?
Oh I forgot the F-16s - maybe its going to be good practise for them. ( and opening for more drones? ) also more saboteurs could infiltrate Russia.

There is also a double edged sword, Putin could use this to call upon more troops, I dont think there is large enough troop concentration to use tactical nukes.
Getting land to trade, looks impossible. There's not enough manpower to hold a significant area in mainland Russia to trade. Especially now that the surprise effect is over.
Point 2 is plausible same as point 3, it actually shows that they have poor control over that big border.

Regarding converting russian POWs into ukranian troops...well it's not going to happen without a brainwash.
Gas pipelines? Media has been highlithing this thing, ignoring that:
1) Only Austria and Hungary are still buying gas from Russia in the EU.
2) That same gas flows via Ukraine...so they could just close the valves in the Ukraine's soil instead of aiming to conquer a metering station in Russia. Thing that if the deal between Ukraine and the EU is not renovated, it's going to happen anyway at the end of the year.

Same thing about the NPP which is 60 Km far...lot of medias pointing out to this and depicting as it is somehow close.
Moving 60 km further into Russia would require an army, not 1000 (if they really are) men.
Then it would expose Ukraine to the same accusation of nuclear terrorism, plus Ukraine doesn't need to benefit from Zaporizhia's NPP at this moment...so...

The use of F16s is what Putin I think is fearing could happen in the region.

The risk use of nukes being used after this incursion is the same as it was before.
 
Could the incursion open up for additional atacsm strikes? ( an attack to bleed the Russians even dryer? ) The Ukrainians have been good at attacking convoys and staging areas, Russia would need new staging areas to take back the incursion area. And from what I gather the force that is gonna try, is a ragtag force of different Russian troops.

Yes but a raiding group, could perhaps manage it. ( thats why its a suicide mission, because they have to surrender later if succesful or die trying ) 60km would take up 4 stretched divisions. ( some analyst have pointed out that the force might be that large like the khakiv operation ) Some media are also reporting ( Ukraine intel spy master ) that it might even open up for bigger events.

We will see what this brings, its at least a morale boost for Ukraine ( although some units might have wanted the manpower in their districts ) And there is movement, which is always exciting
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Torch
I dunno, for sure this will have a morale boost and cause political issues in Moscow.

In the meanwhile I am reading a ton of crap on Twitter...
Profiles like NOELREPORTS (who's far at least from being neutral and know for posting unverified news which turned out to be fakes), are building a whole story about this event, entirely based on the same russian Telegram's account that have always notoriusly been considered to be sources of fuds.

You cannot use a bad source only because it's now fueling your narrative...it's still a bad source which can have its own interests in misreporting.

Pick everything you read about this story on Twitter as a fake unless confirmed by at least geolocation.
 
Last edited:
Yeah you might be right on the gas/pipeline, got it from "Ukraine matters" he mentioned it yesterday. ( didnt think more of it ) I wonder if there is a rute from the previous pipeline into Ukraine, connecting to the Belarus pipeline. ( in the area )
 
The quickest way to end the war in Ukraine now is amass a bunch of soldiers on Finland's southeastern border(or one of the other Baltic countries) as a bluff. Just enough to force Russian to pull troops from Ukraine so they are forced to cover their western border with those countries.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Torch
The quickest way to end the war in Ukraine now is amass a bunch of soldiers on Finland's southeastern border(or one of the other Baltic countries) as a bluff. Just enough to force Russian to pull troops from Ukraine so they are forced to cover their western border with those countries.
You are saying that NATO should mass troops on the largest nuclear weapons power on earth?

Just checking.
 
To be honest I’m not even following it.
There is no sustainable effort Ukraine can execute to seize Russian territory.

That said, war fought well is not just about men and taking or holding land.

It’s also about misdirection and swaying civilian perceptions on both sides.
So we can analytically make judgments on this incursion and its military results and if it successful.
Was it successful regarding the overall effort by Ukraine, who knows in the long run.
They made or allowed an effort of a small group to fighters in an effort of subterfuge. History will decide if it was successful.
 
To be honest I’m not even following it.
There is no sustainable effort Ukraine can execute to seize Russian territory.

That said, war fought well is not just about men and taking or holding land.

It’s also about misdirection and swaying civilian perceptions on both sides.
So we can analytically make judgments on this incursion and its military results and if it successful.
Was it successful regarding the overall effort by Ukraine, who knows in the long run.
They made or allowed an effort of a small group to fighters in an effort of subterfuge. History will decide if it was successful.
I think the bigger goal is just to make Russia look incompetent. People in Russia are eventually going to ask themselves can the government actually protect us? I mean Pregozhin made it almost to Moscow and now Ukraine has been able to advance and hold Russian territory for 48 hours at this point on top of numerous other raids into the country.
 
I think the bigger goal is just to make Russia look incompetent. People in Russia are eventually going to ask themselves can the government actually protect us? I mean Pregozhin made it almost to Moscow and now Ukraine has been able to advance and hold Russian territory for 48 hours at this point on top of numerous other raids into the country.
Exactly. Even if not much more territory is gained and even if they are forced to retreat back to their border, people are still going to have serious questions in Russia.
 
IMO: Russia will have to fight offensively, hopefully incurring tremendous casualties from regular Russian army troops. Nobody gives a shit if the mercs or convicts get whacked. But start killing the boy next door….
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom