• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | Discussions 2024

Status
Not open for further replies.
Are DPRK troops is Ukraine, likely not as yet in any serious numbers. There is no proof of course and no reason to expect there would be unequivocal proof yet. It is certainly possible DPRK observers might be in Ukraine or on the front in Kursk.

The west has been vocal that there is a DPRK presence in Russia near the Kursk region.
Interestingly it should be noted that a Tass article from 10/30/24 spoke around these claims made by western nations. It is interesting, if not notable, that the article did not dispute the claims of DPRK troops in Russia.
It only spoke profusely about Russian DPRK’s close ties and recent talks which only made them closer.

The article is not proof but it is however telling it isn’t disputed. So call it 60/40 chance they are in Russia, time will tell.


Snarky post denying it, and meme’s used as a rebuttal add nothing to an adult conversation.

It took five minutes to look up what actual proof their might be as well as back story.
Thankyou as you said proof their might be. MIGHT BE. isn't proof. Zelinski will provide proof with dead and captured to parade to nato and the world. Until such footage is available it is disputable obviously.
 
Thankyou as you said proof their might be. MIGHT BE. isn't proof. Zelinski will provide proof with dead and captured to parade to nato and the world. Until such footage is available it is disputable obviously.
No I don’t see that as only possible proof. But as such as it is. It would not be a surprise DPRK troops. It’s a valid development to follow and treat with a degree of seriousness
 
Well so much for the abject doom and gloom of Trumps Ukraine Russia policies.
No it doesn’t detail anything. It was also not a funeral pyre for Ukraine or Zelinski.
And that take away was not from Trump but Zelinski.
But of course say it’s all a lie. And I suppose if you’re supporting a back door policy of bankrupting Russia it probably is.
But it is still not an abandonment of Ukraine and I suspect Russia will reject the peace talks outright. Because they will include Ukraines admittance in to NATO at its conclusion. That however I freely admit is just a personal opinion.

 
Russian propagandists mock the future US first lady. Skabeyeva smirks.Disgusting creatures. Such cheap methods usually signify a lack of optimism in other areas.Or do they think it will help them during negotiations? I highly doubt it.

Even if some Russians might talk seriously to other americans (Trump, Musk, Defense Sec, other diplomatic connections, etc..), it's clear that they want to keep presenting the picture of the US as a morally bankrupt and "anti-Russian values" society.
 
Even if some Russians might talk seriously to other americans (Trump, Musk, Defense Sec, other diplomatic connections, etc..), it's clear that they want to keep presenting the picture of the US as a morally bankrupt and "anti-Russian values" society.
Well with wokeness there is truth to that. Of course though Russian media would claim all of the country is woke which just isn't the case. There is at least 70,992,229 woke people however which is a large and deep crisis.
 
Even if some Russians might talk seriously to other americans (Trump, Musk, Defense Sec, other diplomatic connections, etc..), it's clear that they want to keep presenting the picture of the US as a morally bankrupt and "anti-Russian values" society.
How stupid i havn't seen a shred of Evidence to back those claims. Anti-russian 🤭🤣😂😂
Where the hell did they get that idea. Morally or even literally bankrupt i mean c-mon in all seriousness i think someone is just taking the piss. I wouldn't take any of those claims as gospel. Sounds to outrageous to even consider for a second. 🙄
You said yourself said the info comes from a propagandist and they exist globally. I wouldn't be concerned or take it to heart.
 
How stupid i havn't seen a shred of Evidence to back those claims. Anti-russian 🤭🤣😂😂
Where the hell did they get that idea. Morally or even literally bankrupt i mean c-mon in all seriousness i think someone is just taking the piss. I wouldn't take any of those claims as gospel. Sounds to outrageous to even consider for a second. 🙄
You said yourself said the info comes from a propagandist and they exist globally. I wouldn't be concerned or take it to heart.
I don't know where they got the idea, but it is what they are presenting to the Russian domestic audience. Just look at clips from their public access shows and see what they say when they are talking about the US and the west. Recently they showed Melania's risqué modeling pictures.
 
Well with wokeness there is truth to that. Of course though Russian media would claim all of the country is woke which just isn't the case. There is at least 70,992,229 woke people however which is a large and deep crisis.
Would you consider it woke that Melania has been a model before? It's not just woke.
 
Would you consider it woke that Melania has been a model before? It's not just woke.
These people are delusional and present 0 argument based in fact. Only the regurgitated eastern propaganda that the US is a failing society. If thats true, why on Earth would everything absolutely falter if the US was removed from the equation? Not a great sign of a weak society. Sure we might have our differences here in the states but it would be remarkably stupid to base your opinions only on what you see online. The US is still the strongest and most robust democracy in the world. Why not talk about the actual social decadency being sought in Russia in China, like Ethnocide in Xinjiang, and Ukraine? Throwing thousands of your civilians to their death in a pointless war that THEY started? Give me a break. The west helped build the majority of your countries, and you all think the Chinese would be any better at helping you rebuild when we are gone? HA.
 
These people are delusional and present 0 argument based in fact. Only the regurgitated eastern propaganda that the US is a failing society. If thats true, why on Earth would everything absolutely falter if the US was removed from the equation? Not a great sign of a weak society. Sure we might have our differences here in the states but it would be remarkably stupid to base your opinions only on what you see online. The US is still the strongest and most robust democracy in the world. Why not talk about the actual social decadency being sought in Russia in China, like Ethnocide in Xinjiang, and Ukraine? Throwing thousands of your civilians to their death in a pointless war that THEY started? Give me a break. The west helped build the majority of your countries, and you all think the Chinese would be any better at helping you rebuild when we are gone? HA.
It’s just propaganda from all sides and to be expected.
 
And that take away was not from Trump but Zelinski.
Yea Zelinski has no other choice but to kiss the ring in whatever small hopes Trump doesn't capitulate to Putin. Zelensky can't afford to muddy waters.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yea Zelinski has no other choice but to kiss the ring in whatever small hopes Trump doesn't capitulate to Putin. Zelensky can't afford to muddy waters.
Of course he would, why is it you cannot simply take the wait and see approach. There have been no outward statements by Trump that Ukraine is going to be kicked to the curb.
If Rubio is selected as SOS then that is not necessarily a bad thing for Ukraine.
The only statement from trump has been Putin should not try any efforts to make new advance.
The Ukrainians population is stretched pretty thin. That is not to say that are wavering. Simply the war has taken a toll on them.
We had an opportunity after Russias two front advances collapsed. We missed it. Opting for a trickle feeding weapons to Ukraine. Hoping that Russia would grow tired.
Should have struck with nato forces at that time and we didn’t.
So 6 months or 2 more years -Ukraines going to be partitioned or have new boarders.
If Russia doesn’t negotiate in good faith then expect a greater US and NATO push to force Russia to negotiate.
Trump hasn’t said anything about Ukraine entering nato after war is settled. I believe that now that will be essential to their stability. But we’ll see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Torch
Of course he would, why is it you cannot simply take the wait and see approach. There have been no outward statements by Trump that Ukraine is going to be kicked to the curb.
If Rubio is selected as SOS then that is not necessarily a bad thing for Ukraine.
The only statement from trump has been Putin should not try any efforts to make new advance.
The Ukrainians population is stretched pretty thin. That is not to say that are wavering. Simply the war has taken a toll on them.
We had an opportunity after Russias two front advances collapsed. We missed it. Opting for a trickle feeding weapons to Ukraine. Hoping that Russia would grow tired.
Should have struck with nato forces at that time and we didn’t.
So 6 months or 2 more years -Ukraines going to be partitioned or have new boarders.
If Russia doesn’t negotiate in good faith then expect a greater US and NATO push to force Russia to negotiate.
Trump hasn’t said anything about Ukraine entering nato after war is settled. I believe that now that will be essential to their stability. But we’ll see.
I agree with your observations however deviate from your conclusions. NATO has done an excellent job of prolonging the conflict. Trickling in aid only as needed.

Our (NATO) mission is not to win in the UA but to drag out killing Russians (check) and destroying their huge stocks of weapons (Check)

As long as the Russians want to play, we will cheerfully help slaughter them (Check, Double Check)

It doesn’t matter that the Ukraine has suffered devastating casualties since its all for a good cause:a stronger NATO and maybe, just mayber a free Ukraine at the very end, maybe…

Don’t take this as a negative personal opinion of the war, as I am all for it. I’m just saying.
 
If Rubio is selected as SOS then that is not necessarily a bad thing for Ukraine.
I agree, it's not necessarily a bad thing but It seems like Rubio might continue the equipment trickle strategy that Biden has used so far. Just enough for them to stay in the fight but not enough to actually achieve their goals. If Trump want's to have any kind of successful outcome with his foreign policy, he will need to stick to a plan and not be greased down by the hawks in Washington. Biden could have approved and expedited the sale and transfer of Himars/ATACMS, and other tactical weapons faster than he did. Instead he let Ukraine grovel in the mud and lose staggering amounts of manpower due to loosely drawn redlines in the sand set by Russia. All the while Russia has blown past every single redline with no end in sight to their belligerence. Our entire effort of strengthening will prove useless if the Russians are allowed to dig in anymore than they already have. If Rubio and Trump and smart, they would stop this ridiculous idea that Russia and Ukraine will come to terms peacefully in any near term. This isn't on the scale of something like Korea, as in both sides still think they can win. I hope Trump realizes that arming Ukraine with a proper airforce of modernized F-16s, etc, would in the long run help end this conflict and give Ukraine proper assured leverage. It would also allow them to get rid of some of the attrition that is affecting the southern front for both sides tremendously.
 
Understand both of your points.

The trickle flow tactic make sense in a way. However in the long run I believe it is going to become a negative for nato. It can only work if absolute political will is maintained with in nato.
And this cannot be guaranteed.

When engaged in a war don’t fuck around with grand schemes of this or that. Fight to win or don’t fight.
Because the longer it is prolonged the greater the chance the will to support it will evaporate.
That is the basis of my logic.

Also to be quite honest, do we want a Russia that is bled out so bad that they collapse further. Are we ready to navigate and properly engage in the many separate states that will spring up. Or considered the influence and spread of Islamist ideology in those separate states.
What happens if Islamist take control of Kazakhstan and their nuclear weapons?
That is a quagmire worse than the Middle East
 
It can only work if absolute political will is maintained with in nato.
And this cannot be guaranteed.
Yea when the US president says "country's that don't pay, have em" insinuating letting Russia invade NATO members who don't pay enough. Or many, many, other destabilizing statements about the alliance or US part in it. Sure maintains political will. 🙄
 
Yea when the US president says "country's that don't pay, have em" insinuating letting Russia invade NATO members who don't pay enough. Or many, many, other destabilizing statements about the alliance or US part in it. Sure maintains political will. 🙄
I am not a fan of Trump's approach on this, and I do believe that if an adversary thinks a NATO member will be left to wither on the vine, it might embolden that adversary to at least consider attacking that withering NATO country.

However, to quote Hamlet, there is a method to Trump's madness. If NATO should consist of member nations that collectively share in treaty organization's security and finances, then Trump's bluster is a way to send a message to member nations to kick in an appropriate share.

Is NATO an organization of shared, collective security, or is it a shield for vassal nations to be protected by the US alone?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom