• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | Discussions 2024

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi, I wondered if you'd seen this report from sky News about the UK govt under Liz Truss holding crisis talks regarding the possibility of Putin using nuclear weapons in Ukraine?

 
Hi, I wondered if you'd seen this report from sky News about the UK govt under Liz Truss holding crisis talks regarding the possibility of Putin using nuclear weapons in Ukraine?

I read that. From what I recall, we had the DEFCON level at Green at that time. Either something was going on behind the scenes that we weren't privy to or someone was overreacting.
 
Great article from the former secretary general of NATO discussing the need for Europe to step up. At the end of the day NATO is an alliance that should protect all members but there really does need to be a question of how to get countries that don’t want to spend on defense to do so. At the end of the day an alliance can exist for eternity but if only a couple of its members are willing to spend an agreed upon percentage of GDP on their defense then it’s either a paper tiger if one of them drops out or has a massive free rider problem.
 
Not sure how I missed that. Off day.

But I hope they do!
Opinion

It would be the end of the Ukraine, with the exceptions of the Crimea and Odessa. Russia would rain “Atomic Fire” upon her if simply to validate their deterrent threat to the rest of the world.

Any nuclear power that relies upon MAD would have to deliver serious retribution in kind following a nuclear attack. That includes the US responding to a WMD attack.
 
I am not a fan of Trump's approach on this, and I do believe that if an adversary thinks a NATO member will be left to wither on the vine, it might embolden that adversary to at least consider attacking that withering NATO country.

However, to quote Hamlet, there is a method to Trump's madness. If NATO should consist of member nations that collectively share in treaty organization's security and finances, then Trump's bluster is a way to send a message to member nations to kick in an appropriate share.

Is NATO an organization of shared, collective security, or is it a shield for vassal nations to be protected by the US alone?
It should be noted all of Trumps statements and threats regarding NATO were all made with the ambition not to get the US out of NATO. Rather to get the NATO members who where not meeting the defense expenditure requirements of the organization.

“Why should we go to the defence of a nation who is not meeting the expenditure requirements of the organization”.

Is not “the US is not going to honor our treaty commitments to NATO”.
 
Opinion

It would be the end of the Ukraine, with the exceptions of the Crimea and Odessa. Russia would rain “Atomic Fire” upon her if simply to validate their deterrent threat to the rest of the world.

Any nuclear power that relies upon MAD would have to deliver serious retribution in kind following a nuclear attack. That includes the US responding to a WMD attack.
Then Ukrain is fucked again all over.
Either they get NATO membership, nukes, or Russia consumes them.
That’s your choices
 
Then Ukrain is fucked again all over.
Either they get NATO membership, nukes, or Russia consumes them.
That’s your choices
Not really my problem. Give them all the weapons we can without restrictions and stand back.

They need to come to grips that they are very lucky (skilled and ferocious really) to have defeated the Russians attempt, twice to take Kiev and pushed them back to the present lines. Mostly. The eastern most want to be Russia and was settled by Russians during USSR days. That doesn’t make it right, it just makes it the way it is.

Most importantly I see zero chance of the Ukraine getting the Crimean back. Ever. I believe Russia would fight to the very last North Korean and Chechen to keep it.

IMO we (NATO) have already broken several agreements with Russia over Eastern expansion, and have little interest in living up to our accord to protect the Ukraine.

Now both of those examples were not treaties so we have no legal obligation to live up to our promises. We should have, IMO, discarded the first promise to Russia as it is the height of hubris to speak for all the peoples of Eastern Europe (esp Poland). The second promise to defend the Ukraine we absolutely should have honored.

So here we are….killing Russian invaders. Kinda give me a warm fuzzy feeling.
 
Ceasefire in Ukraine would be merely an illusion of peace. We experienced this in 2014 and look where that got us.
 
Ceasefire in Ukraine would be merely an illusion of peace. We experienced this in 2014 and look where that got us.
Ha that wasn’t a ceasefire that was a capitulation.
One which Obama even after congress voted to send military weapons to Ukraine Obama refused.
Do better
 

Trump threatens to be good for Ukraine, actually​

There’s secret relief in some European quarters — and even Kyiv — that Donald Trump might bring the war to a close. And he’s far more likely to get a better deal from Moscow.

Interesting, well worth a read.
 

Interesting, well worth a read.
I don’t agree with everything the article says but the one truth that everyone has to agree on is as of now the west has no plans on how to win the war nor do I ever think they did. Will Trump get a “good” deal for Ukraine? Depends who you ask because the deal will probably involve Ukraine giving up land. One thing is for certain though is even at the higher rate of weapons being sent to Ukraine the west has put so many restrictions in place they’d never be able to actually win, which means eventually the west is going to have to negotiate.
 
I don’t agree with everything the article says but the one truth that everyone has to agree on is as of now the west has no plans on how to win the war nor do I ever think they did. Will Trump get a “good” deal for Ukraine? Depends who you ask because the deal will probably involve Ukraine giving up land. One thing is for certain though is even at the higher rate of weapons being sent to Ukraine the west has put so many restrictions in place they’d never be able to actually win, which means eventually the west is going to have to negotiate.
And that has been the problem in Ukraine for 4 years, no plan, not even a fucking goal!
Russia bad Ukraines good. Well in principle in this instance I agree with that. But platitudes and “commitment” without a plan other than, “well I guess we’re going to have to send F/A jets to Ukraine after all” is always a losing war strategy.
And if we don’t care enough about ending the war expediently and favorably for Ukraine, then we have no moral justification for supporting them against Russia. We just doing the same thing Russias done to Ukrainians for 100 yrs.

As far as bleeding Russian resources as a strategic end, how did that work out with the Taliban?
 
And that has been the problem in Ukraine for 4 years, no plan, not even a fucking goal!
Russia bad Ukraines good. Well in principle in this instance I agree with that. But platitudes and “commitment” without a plan other than, “well I guess we’re going to have to send F/A jets to Ukraine after all” is always a losing war strategy.
And if we don’t care enough about ending the war expediently and favorably for Ukraine, then we have no moral justification for supporting them against Russia. We just doing the same thing Russias done to Ukrainians for 100 yrs.

As far as bleeding Russian resources as a strategic end, how did that work out with the Taliban?
I think the biggest problem was they truly believed Ukraine wouldn’t last more than a few days and never even thought it was possible this would still be going almost 3 years later. Their moral justification is still always going to be they are helping Ukraine survive but is it really surviving if all they’re doing is fighting for territory they realistically have no chance of fully reclaiming? As for the point about bleeding Russia it will work way better with Russia than it did with the Taliban purely because the people in Ukraine are willing to fight even without our aid. The people in Afghanistan had no will to fight against the Taliban and their military basically just let them take over.
I have always been on board and will continue to be on board with helping Ukraine but even I am getting tired of sending billions in equipment in a war without a means to an end either get serious and actually help them win or shut it down.
 
realistically have no chance of fully reclaiming?
Yea they could. But Trump won't want to go against his best buddy Putin & Rocket Man, then of course Biden didn't give them what was really need either.

Let's not pretend these self limitations we put on ourselves is "no chance" as there is. Only if the West truly wants it. But I guess not, from either side.

Let's just give Putin half of Eastern Europe now and skip the slow spiral and the inevitable test on NATO by Putin with this weak ass sauce by the West and both DEMs and GOP/Trump pulling now with Ukraine.
 
Yea they could. But Trump won't want to go against his best buddy Putin & Rocket Man, then of course Biden didn't give them what was really need either.

Let's not pretend these self limitations we put on ourselves is "no chance" as there is. Only if the West truly wants it. But I guess not, from either side.

Let's just give Putin half of Eastern Europe now and skip the slow spiral and the inevitable test on NATO by Putin with this weak ass sauce by the West and both DEMs and GOP/Trump pulling now with Ukraine.
We could have secured it and possibly still could. But we have not had a winning war plan from the beginning.
Everything we’ve done has been reactionary. From nato leaders telling Zelinski in the opening hours of the invasion he could flee to Western Europe. Where nato leaders thinking about victory then, I doubt it! To then dragging our feet at sending armor, then artillery, to F/A planes.
It’s all been reactionary the entire war effort.

So the hair on fire Trump is going to ruin everything isn’t really contextually comparable or accurate.

Will trump do things better? I can’t guarantee it of course. Given his past willingness to supply lethal aid to Ukraine from the beginning as well as his statements if Putin fails to negotiate in good faith then the game changes.

Now if you can produce an actual spoken plan to win the fight to drive Russia kilometer by kilometer to the 2014 boarders. Besides we’ll send more arms when we have too, I suppose, maybe, we’ll have to talk about it. Then fine
 
Yea they could. But Trump won't want to go against his best buddy Putin & Rocket Man, then of course Biden didn't give them what was really need either.

Let's not pretend these self limitations we put on ourselves is "no chance" as there is. Only if the West truly wants it. But I guess not, from either side.

Let's just give Putin half of Eastern Europe now and skip the slow spiral and the inevitable test on NATO by Putin with this weak ass sauce by the West and both DEMs and GOP/Trump pulling now with Ukraine.
But it’s not Trump doing it. The Biden administration has imposed restriction after restriction, Europe hasn’t stepped up in nearly the capacity it should, and quite frankly Ukraine needs to up their conscription requirements. I don’t want Ukraine to lose but I’m tired of the west not developing any sort of plan whatsoever, or one that they actually plan on following through with, so they either need to put up or shut up at this point. Because all of this delay in reaction looks just as weak as negotiating a ceasefire would anyway, especially one that would involve a European patrolled DMZ.
As for your last point there’s a big reason Russia wanted to keep from fighting NATO in Ukraine it’s not the action of someone who wants to fight them. I get people are scared he’d attack Eastern Europe but the west had little obligation to help Ukraine defend itself in the first place compared to the obligation it has to defend the Baltics. On the other hand what they will continue is their shadow influence operations because we are 100% back in a Cold War with Russia.
 
But it’s not Trump doing it.
What I meant is he isn't going to do the right thing and step up where Biden didn't. Their both wrong. Both sides have wrong approach. One is to capitulate to Putin which will lead to much worse things and the other side is setting Ukraine up failure....

So fed up with DEMs and GOP. The two party system has failed America.
 
What I meant is he isn't going to do the right thing and step up where Biden didn't. Their both wrong. Both sides have wrong approach. One is to capitulate to Putin which will lead to much worse things and the other side is setting Ukraine up failure....

So fed up with DEMs and GOP. The two party system has failed America.
yeah that’s pretty much it and unfortunately nothings gonna change and we all know Europe will back down and not do squat until they have a relations reset and go back to buying Russian oil in 3-4 years.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom