• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

Armistice Ukraine ???

Ya but....that NATO thing.
Didn't this whole cluster fudge start because Putin said Nyet to Ukraine NATO membership?
How would this play in the motherland?
 
Ya but....that NATO thing.
Didn't this whole cluster fudge start because Putin said Nyet to Ukraine NATO membership?
How would this play in the motherland?
Wonder if it is possible for Ukraine to be a member of NATO without any NATO troops or bases in its territory?
I don't know why russia needs any more territory anyway. What is there like 57 time zones there! You can take off on one side and land the day before on the other side! :ROFLMAO:
 
i would never trust ukraine to be in NATO nor have nukes thats insane. if they ever did get nukes they would most definitely use them on russia and humanity is over.
 
I’m just thinking out loud here, but with these negotiations, I fear that if (or when) they are inevitably rejected, it’ll give Moscow a pretext to attack NATO. Considering they’re just restating their 2021 demands with added fluff, the rejection of which lead Putin to attack Ukraine, I can easily see the rejection of these conditions leading to a similar attack on NATO under similar conditions.
 
I’m just thinking out loud here, but with these negotiations, I fear that if (or when) they are inevitably rejected, it’ll give Moscow a pretext to attack NATO. Considering they’re just restating their 2021 demands with added fluff, the rejection of which lead Putin to attack Ukraine, I can easily see the rejection of these conditions leading to a similar attack on NATO under similar conditions.
I can understand in broad brush strokes where this concern comes from.
One essential thing to remember, Ukraine was never a member of NATO. The only documented agreements made with Ukraine was the Budapest Memorandum. Where Ukraines sovereignty was guaranteed by Russia and the US.
That the US didn’t act when Eastern Ukraine and Crimea in 2014 is when the failure began
I
Everyone keeps talking about Ukraine joining NATO, which I’m not necessarily opposed to. But that also requires unanimous consent of all NATO members.
They were not even sure they would get unanimous consent for Finland and Sweden.
 
I’m just thinking out loud here, but with these negotiations, I fear that if (or when) they are inevitably rejected, it’ll give Moscow a pretext to attack NATO.
Failed negotiations doesn't remove the problem of all of NATO jumping on Russia if Russia attacks. That's why Russia hasn't been (overtly) attacking NATO supply points for Ukraine.

The smackdown would come hard.

You remember the joke from a few years ago?

Putin: How are we doing in Ukraine?

General: We've lost hundreds of thousands of men and equipment.

Putin: At least NATO is being bloodied.

General: NATO hasn't even got there yet.
 
I’m just thinking out loud here, but with these negotiations, I fear that if (or when) they are inevitably rejected, it’ll give Moscow a pretext to attack NATO. Considering they’re just restating their 2021 demands with added fluff, the rejection of which lead Putin to attack Ukraine, I can easily see the rejection of these conditions leading to a similar attack on NATO under similar conditions.
The reason Putin made these demands is so he can deflect the blame to Europe for being the reason there’s not peace on Ukraine. It gives him justification for continuing the war to his people. That and he thinks Trump will listen to them.
 
i would never trust ukraine to be in NATO nor have nukes thats insane. if they ever did get nukes they would most definitely use them on russia and humanity is over.
Entry into NATO does not automatically give you nuclear weapons on your soil. There are only a few NATO countries with nukes and even fewer NATO countries that can actually launch them.
 
Entry into NATO does not automatically give you nuclear weapons on your soil. There are only a few NATO countries with nukes and even fewer NATO countries that can actually launch them.
again its about trust. if ukraine is using flamingo missiles against russia. if ukraine was apart of nato the probability of them having/getting a nuke is very high.
 
again its about trust. if ukraine is using flamingo missiles against russia. if ukraine was apart of nato the probability of them having/getting a nuke is very high.
Honestly I don’t even worry about this scenario because the odds of Ukraine ever joining NATO are slim to none. Russia will never accept a settlement that leaves that possibility open. Also, the odds NATO would even approve them are effectively zero. Look at how much opposition they have faced entering the EU, it would be considerably worse when trying to enter NATO.
 
Sweden and Finland.

Canada had previously received some, but handed them over to the USA in the early 2000s.
It should be noted that NATO member countries such as Belgium, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, and Turkey host American nuclear warheads as part of the Alliance’s nuclear sharing arrangement.
 
Name a single NATO country that didn't have nukes before joining and got them afterwards.

We're waiting...
Actually Britain and France developed nuclear weapons after they joined NATO. But I understand what your implying
 
This is a very difficult situation, Ukraine needs and deserves some kind of real defense assurances. They can’t come from Russia nor the US.

As far as foreign troops being deployed in Ukraine it’s also likely a necessary component.
Russias is demanding a restoration of pre Maiden revolution gov.

So the question remains what are the NATO nations willing to commit to corporately or individually.
That question has never truly been answered definitively throughout the war.

Coupled with that does anyone really think Russias going to back down absent some kind of escalation or push from NATO.

Is that a risk calculation we’re willing run?
 
Back
Top Bottom