• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

New Russia/Ukraine/NATO Thread - Reports & Analysis Combined

Elon Musk, in an interview with the New York Times, said that "Americans staged a coup in 2014 to remove the democratically elected pro-Russian president of Ukraine", and that the war would not have happened without the "offensive actions of the US State Department"Musk then went on to say that painting Ukraine as good and Russia as bad is "cruel and absolutely unacceptable."

 
Elon Musk has become a Kremlin regurgitator.
I think he sounds quite lucid. There was absolutely nothing he said that was incorrect. We, the USA not NATO, helped execute a coup straight up. That doesn’t mean Russia is not an asshole or Putin is a evil sob. It just means two things can be true at the same time.

The USA was all over Ukraine prior to the coup. We have been training the UA forces for many many years prior to the war. Our Special Forces ran continuous schools on fighting as insurgents. We had THOUSANDS of weapons like stingers and javelins cached all over the country. If we, the USA, did not cause this was we certainly enabled one side.

Further it doesnt matter what you or I think. Russia is certain the USA is behind thigs whole mess. I dissagree but opinions vary and yours is certainly as valid as mine and you probably correct.
 
Last edited:
I think he sounds quite lucid. There was absolutely nothing he said that was incorrect. We, the USA not NATO, helped execute a coup straight up. That doesn’t mean Russia is not an asshole or Putin is a evil sob. It just means two things can be true at the same time.
Musk then went on to say that painting Ukraine as good and Russia as bad is "cruel and absolutely unacceptable."

This is the part I was referring to. I personally believe that Euromaidan wasn't an American coup but rather the Ukrainian people rejecting a Russian-installed government. These are usually Russian talking points that attempt to place blame on NATO & the USA for the war in Ukraine. If I had replaced "Elon Musk" with "Sergey Lavrov" here it wouldn't have been worth posting.

I'm interested to hear your perspective as to why you think it was an American coup though
 
Elon Musk has become a Kremlin regurgitator.
Well was it a cia coup? They’re the cia we will never prove it.

What is known that various politicians went to Ukraine “during” the protest to encourage the protesters. Or the legitimacy of Nuland’s phone call with US ambassador to Ukraine about who would be acceptable replacement leaders if the gov collapsed. One of which did take a roll.

All this transpired inside Ukraine with US officials while Yanukovych was “still” the legitimately elected leader of Ukraine.

So did the CIA subvert the Ukrainian elected government, that hasn’t been proven, and likely never will.

What has been proven is the Obama admin and State department were publicly encouraging the protesters and revolution publicly inside Ukraine. As well as planning behind the scenes for what the gov would look like after Yanukovych fled.
“Picking” acceptable new leaders for Ukraine, one of the very things things Russia was being accused of.

 
Musk then went on to say that painting Ukraine as good and Russia as bad is "cruel and absolutely unacceptable."

This is the part I was referring to. I personally believe that Euromaidan wasn't an American coup but rather the Ukrainian people rejecting a Russian-installed government. These are usually Russian talking points that attempt to place blame on NATO & the USA for the war in Ukraine. If I had replaced "Elon Musk" with "Sergey Lavrov" here it wouldn't have been worth posting.

I'm interested to hear your perspective as to why you think it was an American coup though
Particular regional forces inside Ukraine (especially the Azov brigade) and the pre war fighting on the border with Russia was not pretty and there were abuses by Ukrainians. Those abuses were real. It however does not mean all Ukrainians are bad, just as it does not mean all Russians are good.

That said I did not support the US when we began encouraging the maiden revolution. However as I watched the nation struggle to pull together and shake off decades of criminal governance especially with the second election I personal, and still do, believe Ukraine as a whole was trying to make significant changes. And that they deserved support from the west.
I still do believe that but only if it is planned and executed in manner that they can actually and definitively win.
We haven’t really seen that since early in the war.

There is no overt evil empire here, there are nations and leaders on both sides who made mistakes. Overreaches and miscalculations.
I don’t need the hyperbole of Putin’s a tyrant to defend Ukrainians. But I do expect and demand a functional war plan fleshed out and articulated and committed to actually seeing them win the damn thing.

If Europe and the US said let’s go get this done then fine let’s do it.
Instead we just keep throwing money and blood into a meat grinder with no clear war aims.
Some say Putin is an evil genocidal leader, Some say principle, some say bleed Russia, some sayRussias going to invade nato next.
Most all of those are true to one degree of another. But absent a plan and commitment to win it’s just platitudes and insanity.

My first strike would be to carpet bomb all transportation routes from Russia into Ukraine. Turn them into a moonscape Ukrainian side of course.
 
Back
Top Bottom