• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

Haiti Unrest - Canadian Special Forces On Ground

I wonder what the Dominican Republic is going to do, seeing as how they are more immediately affected by this crisis.

Haiti has been firmly in "failed state" territory for decades, so I'm, sadly, not surprised by this turn of events...
You know it’s an interesting phenomenon and I’ve often
Wondered why it has not spilled over already.
I traveled to Coasta Rica several decades ago. It was well after the removal of Noreaga and the Nicaraguan revolution and its communist lite government.
And here is Coasta Rica sandwiched between them both. It suffered all of the liabilities and risk of a small Central America nation.
Yet through it all it has remained a stable constitutional government. I believe it actually is the second oldest constitutional government in the world after the US and possibly Britian depending on how you define a constitutional government.

They had a viable tropical agriculture suffered no military coups, and a very lite national military presence. A catholic nation where gambling and prostitution was legal and lightly regulate.
I watched primary age boys and girls walk home right through the city center of its capital San Juan unattended, unmolested and unconcerned.
Firearms were not illegal. I asked is there anyplace in San Juan foreigners should not go. The general advice was there are a few parts of San Juan where women might not want to visit alone, and that was only after dark.
pretty remarkable situation for any nation any where in the world today.

So of course I ask why? How did a small Latin American nation successfully maintained constitution government that has successfully limited the control and corruption in the government. And still also escape or be immune to sectarian violence and corruption while it existed for decades on it boarders.

The predominant answer was their population was almost completely European in heritage. Regrettably when it was settled the settlers had pretty much driven out or exterminated the totality of the indigenous population.
Of course this is not an acceptable solution or method for any nation to follow.
But I mention it because it is what many reported was one of the influencing factors in their stability. They maintained a shared Vision of the nation they wanted, expected and would work for.
They were a homogeneous population by and large committed to the same cultural and government influences and expectations.
The point being it was the will of the citizenry that sustained and molded its society and government. The revolution and corruption of its two larger neighbors were simply rejected en-mass and neither gained a foothold.

I’m not saying it’s perfect or free of faults. Simply that It was the populations overwhelming commitment to a shared vision and expectation for their nation that sustained them.

I say all that to illustrate why rapid and forced social change due to either new and untested social policies or large and unassimilated immigration, legal or otherwise. Will always lead to national divisions and internal conflicts.

Rapid, often times radical, changes to any nations legal, cultural, or economic stability almost always will result in internal weakness division and instability.

A ship that has a crew that is competent in manning and sufficiently educated. One which also actually agrees on what the hell their doing at sea amd where their going will always have a better chance of success and survival when they hit a storm.

It’s not a panacea for all nations struggles. But it’s a good foundation upon which build and sustain it one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Torch
So of course I ask why? How did a small Latin American nation successfully maintained constitution government that has successfully limited the control and corruption in the government. And still also escape or be immune to sectarian violence and corruption while it existed for decades on it boarders.
Well it also helps that Costa Rica doesn't have a military at all. Just a 5,000 strong police force.

They entirely depends on the United States for defense. Again zero military they have to maintain or pay for. Zero.

Because they don't have to worry about a military they were able to focus on more things like education, hospitals, safty nets, and more programs to help grow the people which tends to reduce poverty & crime. Which poverty & crime also tend to go hand in hand with statistics.


Edit Clarification:
Not everyone who is poor is a criminal of course, just that poverty presents challenges and might make one more willing to commit crimes to get ahead. Which is why you find criminal gangs in poor neighborhoods.
 
Last edited:
They entirely depends on the United States for defense. Again zero military they have to maintain or pay for. Zero.
RIO TREATY:
A treaty signed which provides that an armed attack against any American State shall be considered as an attack against all the American States and each one undertakes to assist in meeting the attack.

PARTIES: United States, Costa Rica, ect...

Costa Rica doesn't have a military at all.
"Costa Rica is one of the few countries without armed forces and, alongside Panama, one of the few that is not a microstate."

So from my perspective, the reason why Coasta Rica has done alright for themselves is because they where smart and depened enitrly on the world's largest super power to protect them while they took the money they would of spent on for military into social services instead like education, hospitals, safty nets, and other programs for their people.
 
Last edited:
Well it also helps that Costa Rica doesn't really have a military and almost entirely depends on the United States for defense. Because they don't have to worry about a military they were able to focus on more things like education, hospitals, safty nets, and more programs to help grow the people.
You miss my point. Sure they benifit from aligning themselves with the US.
But that is because the nation by and large has chosen to do so.

Thus the presence and activities of US military in Costa Rica DO NOT actually become a disruptive force.

It is not about US economic benefits or financing social “safety nets”.

There are lots of nations which have received direct or indirect financial assistance or benifit.
And of them their are many which are failed states or suffered with serious national disruptions.

Aid and investment can absolutely help, but it is not a determining factor alone.

It is the will, vision and actions of the citizenry that Make it happen and self sustaining.

Money can’t buy happiness’s nor can it guarantee success.
Panama over that same time period undoubtedly received exponetiinally more aid and investment than Coasta rica has.

I’m only illustrating that a nation which has a shared vision, system and expectations for the actions and direction of their nation in the public realm makes for a stabler nation.
One which can successfully minimize or navigate change without weakening it so much it is susceptible to the failings of neighboring nations or purposed disruptive foreign influence.

Why has all the aid that has been sent to Haiti over the decades not resulted in a nation like Costa Rica?
 
Why has all the aid that has been sent to Haiti over the decades not resulted in a nation like Costa Rica?
Well I never mentioned aid to Coasta Rica. Just that they have no military at all what so ever. Because of this they have more money to spend on other things to help with stability like free schools/education, hospitals, and other safty nets.

I am not sure if they get aid from us to be honest. Only pointing out that maintaining a military is expensive. They don't have that expense. Therefore can funnel more money into their nation and people which imo has greatly helped them succeed.

Your not wrong either, it does take the will of the people. But not having to spend large portions of your GDP on maintaining a military helps too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Torch
US pledges further $100 million to Haiti security mission
US Secretary Of State Antony Blinken on Monday said the United States would contribute an additional $100 million to a UN-backed multinational security force intended to help Haitian police fight gangs, as well as $33 million in humanitarian aid.
This brings the United States' proposed contribution to the force to $300 million. As of Monday, less than $11 million had been deposited into the UN's dedicated trust fund.
 
I think they get aid in the form of tourism and expat’s. Back in the 80s and 90s I owned a small farm in Costa Rica in Limon near Guacimo.

My Second Best Friend* is extraordinarily wealthy and splits his time between His Ranch in West Texas and Costa Rica. There is a huge influx of cash for the country for many peoples doing the same!

(*Wife is Number #1)
 
Haiti PM resigns. New PM promises to do everything in their power to do something. New PM has no power. Government has no power. Haiti is in anarchy. PM might as well be a news anchor because the government has the power of a radio station. Government pledges to fully scold those responsible for unrest and tell them to go to their room.

Nothing changes. Haiti remains a shithole. Nobody wants the refugees. If it had a nuke it would nuke itself off the face of the Earth because the only way for Haiti to recover is for there no longer to be a Haiti.

I'm just talking a lil smack. Just every time I see news about Haiti it sounds pretty much like "Somolia confirms once again its in anarchy. Please stay tuned for another confirmation of anarchy."
 
Failed state whose population is incapable or unwilling to change and grow.
They’re like a child who refuses to grow up and behave like an adult.
There is nothing to be done but let them crash headlong into oblivion.
🦠 /LVC/ - LesVilainsComplotistes ✡️👽👁🛸
 
Haiti update: On Sunday, US was able to evacuate a small group of American citizens from Haiti on a US govt organized charter flight, White House's John Kirby says. Today, a US-organized helicopter flew about 15 Americans from Port-Au-Prince to Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic.
 
Back
Top Bottom