• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

New Russia/Ukraine/NATO Thread - Reports & Analysis Combined

Question: Are troops training at a foreign training ground to attack your country or troops a legitimate military target?
No, of course not. Every single exercise NATO or the Warsaw Pact conducted were to train to fight each other. Every single military exercise conducted is intended to practice to fight someone. That doesn't mean people get to bomb whoever they want. These troops are not training to attack Russia, they are training to defend NATO territory from an attack BY Russia.

Take a breather. The only way to put a stop to Russian provocations is to reciprocate in kind. Pretending Putin wants to negotiate to end the war is a fool's errand. Excusing such actions as "little mistakes" only erodes deterrence and emboldens Putin & Xi. Until that is done and weak NATO leadership that can't stop fighting its own members doesn't get a grip over itself, this will continue.
 
And... like clockwork:

TRUMP SAYS PUTIN IS READY TO END UKRAINE WAR, URGES EUROPE TO MAKE A DEAL

President Donald Trump told European leaders and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy that Vladimir Putin is ready to end the war, according to five European officials briefed on Thursday's discussions.

Trump reportedly urged European governments to reach a peace agreement with Russia, arguing they could redirect spending from Ukraine toward their own countries.

No peace agreement has been announced, and Putin's willingness to end the conflict remains Trump's assessment.

 
No, of course not. Every single exercise NATO or the Warsaw Pact conducted were to train to fight each other. Every single military exercise conducted is intended to practice to fight someone. That doesn't mean people get to bomb whoever they want. There is a difference between peacetime training and hot war traininng These troops are not training to attack Russia, they are training to defend NATO territory from an attack BY Russia. BS! That's funny!

Take a breather. The only way to put a stop to Russian provocations is to reciprocate in kind. Like I said, the third times the charm! Pretending Putin wants to negotiate to end the war is a fool's errand. Excusing such actions as "little mistakes" only erodes deterrence and emboldens Putin & Xi. Until that is done and weak NATO leadership that can't stop fighting its own members doesn't get a grip over itself, this will continue.
So you are claiming there are no Nato troops or military equipment going into Ukraine to kill russians from neighboring countries!
What would India do if Pakistan did this?
 
So you are claiming there are no Nato troops or military equipment going into Ukraine to kill russians from neighboring countries!
What would India do if Pakistan did this?
NATO military equipment is going into Ukraine to help them defend themselves from an invading bloodthirsty Russian military. NATO troops themselves are not involved in combat operations and are not directly involved in pushing back Russian invaders.

That exercise that Russia was targeting was being held in Poland to train in drone warfare. I think you're forgetting Russia is the aggressor, Russia is the one who started a war.

On one end of the spectrum, you want Europe to rearm and to become less reliant on America. When they conduct exercises to train their militaries, you seem to have a problem with that too. This is not a coherent position. With all due respect, NATO is being remarkably tolerant of Russian provocations. The onus of ending this war and seeking peace lies on Russia, not on the invaded party. If Russia does not want peace, nobody can prevent "WW3".

How about we ask Russia to stay within their borders and not shoot at their neighbors to prevent WW3?
 
Jared Kushner just dropped a bombshell at the Berlin “Coalition of the Willing” press conference:“We’ve been making a lot of progress on a post-war prosperity plan, and we’ve been working with the World Bank and BlackRock and Zelensky’s team, and the EU has really been excellent at spearheading that effort.”
BlackRock (the world’s largest asset manager) + the World Bank are already deep in the room designing Ukraine’s reconstruction before the war even ends. Financing, repayment structures, and investor returns are being locked in while the fighting continues.The shift is clear:From endless war funding → to shaping Ukraine’s post-war economy and ownership of its future.EU leading the charge. Zelensky’s team at the table. Private capital at the centre.The post-war Ukraine is already being written.
What does this mean for who actually rebuilds (and profits from) Ukraine?
I don't really give a shit as long as the war is brought to a conclusion and Ukraine is rebuilt! I'm sure there will be subpoenas issued and investigations over this. Hevan forbid the Trump organization make any money! After all building is what they do!
 
Addressing the example, China is already doing this with India (sending equipment to Pakistan to attack India). You don't see us starting a war with China.
No, but when Pakistan uses that equipment to kill Indians you don't send a few missiles or drones that don't hit anything as a warning to back off!
 
No, but when Pakistan uses that equipment to kill Indians you don't send a few missiles or drones that don't hit anything as a warning to back off!
For an apples to apples comparison, this scenario would require India to be at war with Pakistan. India has never struck China because they arm Pakistan. Even during last year's skirmish where the Chinese were providing clear intelligence and logistical support, India never directly even touched China for it.
 
NATO military equipment is going into Ukraine to help them defend themselves from an invading bloodthirsty Russian military. NATO troops themselves are not involved in combat operations and are not directly involved in pushing back Russian invaders. This is true. They slap a Ukrainian flag on their uniform or no flag at all. Very well-equipped mercenaries or volunteers right!

That exercise that Russia was targeting was being held in Poland to train in drone warfare. And those drones are not going deep into russia, strictly defensive! :ROFLMAO: I think you're forgetting Russia is the aggressor, Russia is the one who started a war.

On one end of the spectrum, you want Europe to rearm and to become less reliant on America. When they conduct exercises to train their militaries, you seem to have a problem with that too. This is not a coherent position. Both things can't be true? I would just like to avoid a nuclear exchange if we can. With all due respect, NATO is being remarkably tolerant of Russian provocations. The onus of ending this war and seeking peace lies on Russia, not on the invaded party. If Russia does not want peace, nobody can prevent "WW3".

How about we ask Russia to stay within their borders and not shoot at their neighbors to prevent WW3?
If russia stopped today, do you think Ukraine would?
 
For an apples to apples comparison, this scenario would require India to be at war with Pakistan. India has never struck China because they arm Pakistan. Even during last year's skirmish where the Chinese were providing clear intelligence and logistical support, India never directly even touched China for it.
That's because china is now a superpower. They just got a seat at the big boy table! :cool:
 
Radio ZET has established that more objects may have violated Polish airspace. The services tasked with searching for them estimate that there could be "as many as 10 objects."

The military is seriously considering the hypothesis that the Russian objects that entered Polish airspace between Thursday night and Friday morning could have targeted the military exercises involving approximately 5,000 soldiers from 11 nations at Nowa Dęba.

The article says that electronic warfare at the training site may have brought them down.

 
... Of course? Zelensky has repeatedly stated he is ready to do so. It's Putin who refuses to negotiate seriously.
So Z is willing to give up 20% of Ukraine proper plus Crimea if russia froze the front lines right where they are? I thought their goal was to completely expel russia from all Ukrainian territory?
 
So Z is willing to give up 20% of Ukraine proper plus Crimea if russia froze the front lines right where they are? I thought their goal was to completely expel russia from all Ukrainian territory?
Zelensky: The quickest way to end Russia’s war is to hold the positions and move to discussions. What is very important here is that we decided: stop where we are, it’s a ceasefire, and we go to the diplomatic track. It can last one month, two months, or one year. Or it can last longer than we expect today. But we end the hot stage and people stop dying.

 
NATO military equipment is going into Ukraine to help them defend themselves from an invading bloodthirsty Russian military. NATO troops themselves are not involved in combat operations and are not directly involved in pushing back Russian invaders.

That exercise that Russia was targeting was being held in Poland to train in drone warfare. I think you're forgetting Russia is the aggressor, Russia is the one who started a war.

On one end of the spectrum, you want Europe to rearm and to become less reliant on America. When they conduct exercises to train their militaries, you seem to have a problem with that too. This is not a coherent position. With all due respect, NATO is being remarkably tolerant of Russian provocations. The onus of ending this war and seeking peace lies on Russia, not on the invaded party. If Russia does not want peace, nobody can prevent "WW3".

How about we ask Russia to stay within their borders and not shoot at their neighbors to prevent WW3?
These missiles crashed they did not detonate. The closest reported crash site was 100km from the training area.

Is this unacceptable FFS yes!
Is it a premeditated incursion, that an opinion.

Either way I do not disagree these mistakes or convenient mishaps are not acceptable. Russia would not accept NATO accidentally losing cruise missiles over Russian territory.

Dont ask me how this can be remedied.
Does this mean nato send overt troops to Ukraine? Is say overt because I’m fairly confident nato has already sent “advisors” to Ukraine. Big deal!, Russia sent little green men into eastern Ukraine and Crimea.
But none of that answers who is willing to send troops or start flying air cap over Ukraine.
Has any NATO nation proposed anything remotely like this? Any kind of direct intervention.
So the next reality is without that all NATO has are bitching rights.

So what to do after the war. If there is a near term after the war.
There is the coalition of the willing British, France and Germany are pushing for a binding security agreement with Ukraine post war.
Frankly this is a positive step other nations committing to troops in a defensive capacity.

I understand the frustration, I myself am frustrated. But beyond pursuing negotiations weapons, training, and security guarantees what can be done beyond talk.

On another note I have asked this before is the war of attrition working against Russia? Some say it might be. There debt is not high compared to other nations. But the cost for them to borrow is several points above other nations.
It appears their GDP growth for 26 is one percent and forecast at .5 % in 27.
And given that Putin is threatening their largest mobilization of the war next year.
It can cause one to wonder if the Russians have decided to learn to play poker instead of chess.

I don’t know, there is currently not enough open source information on how strained the Russian economy and war machine are actually strained.
 
🇫🇮 ❗️Finnish broadcaster Yle, citing Estonian police, has identified the Russian cargo ship attacked by two drones in the Gulf of Finland today as SPARTA II.This is no ordinary Russian cargo ship.SPARTA II operates within the Russian Ministry of Defence’s military infrastructure and responsible for transporting troops, weapons and military equipment:
 
Back
Top Bottom