• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | Discussions 2024

Status
Not open for further replies.
All true, but just because opinions are shared by others does not mean they offer the best course of action.
Diverse or conflicting opinions. And the effort to spread them is just as much a part of the struggle for both sides to influence the outcome. The old Russian disinformation adage. The influence of Russian disinformation has been over blown in the west. But it does not mean it’s not a significant influence in the choices western society end up marking and supporting.
Just because your paranoid doesn’t mean people aren’t out to get you.

Just because western politicians have overplayed the Russia Russia Russia narrative. In no way disproves Russia has ambitions to reclaim some of they’re soviet colonial territories.

One can ignore that or claim it’s not real. But it is still a real thing.
So that brings everyone back to the best way to respond.
Does Europe and the Slavic nations want a EU form of regional organization. Or do they want a Russia view of the old European Russian contest and dividing up of the Slavic states.
Hungary is an interesting example they are very moderate in addressing this issue with the nations that boarder Russia. Yet they are still part of the EU. Where they are allowed to voice and reject decisions made by the EU commission and Parliament.
Would a nation in the Russian umbrella be allowed to vocally and materially reject some decisions from Putin?
I seriously doubt it.
The EU has done a lot of things I think are stupid. Compared however to the previous four centuries of regional warfare amongst European monarchies and governments.
It is reasonable to conclude the current model and effort of the EU and NATO is exponentially better than their recent historical past.

Support for a course of actions does not mean it’s the correct way to proceed.
And in any free society there will be vocal dissent on all matters of importance. It’s a process and we are witnessing it and participating in it as it happens.
Why do you suspect Russia wants the same borders as the USSR? Ukraine definitely isn't proof of this. I find it hard to believe PUTIN or the Russian people are interested in such territories. If I were PUTIN with goal of turning the whole of Ukraine into Russian land for no other reason than simply as you believe, than I would have simply destroyed its government completely with long range missiles yrs ago. Or taken the western approach so you get the control and benefits without the attention. European politics spouts PUTIN wants more than just old USSR borders meaning all of Europe. Obviously you don't believe that much ? PUTIN isn't interested in that rubbish he doesn't want to govern that either. Ukraine he only wanted Ukraine government to remain neutral as in not nato. His interest was only Russian influence in Ukrainian government to stop nato interest, allowing Ukraine to govern itself but with a few Russian players in it to secure it as non nato. That was the intent when tried to intervene in the Ukrainian government using military as yrs of talking about the issue failed due to western intervention finding nato friendly players for Ukraine government.
It does suit western narrative and goals to claim he tried using military to occupy Ukraine but those who believe that are just sheep Obviously. Why? Simple for such a move and goal as claimed not even PUTIN would be stupid enough to think a military force the size he used was going to be big enough to achieve that bs. Ukraine is the largest European country if Russia isn't included. Only people with no idea of size and issues to achieve such would believe that to be true simply through lack of knowledge and or common sense . Not to mention the willingness to believe such due to propaganda
designed to keep the west in the mentality of USSR and Russia are no different and evil enemies of western societies.
What's Macron going to do for Zelinski when he arrives in Normandy for D-Day remembrance. Run around all the sites and museums removing Russian flags and Russian history so no ones feelings get hurt. Please. I appreciate your input and opinions and I'm always open to discussion where I may learn something interesting to keep me open minded. But as far as this particular topic is concerned we know why we believe what we do and think how we do. And I'm under the impression expansion of understanding each other's views, values , thought processes so on so forth are looking rather exhausted at this stage. You is you me is me on said subject. Look forward to other subjects to learn more about you. 🙂👍🤝
 
Last edited:
Why do you suspect Russia wants the same borders as the USSR? Ukraine definitely isn't proof of this. I find it hard to believe PUTIN or the Russian people are interested in such territories. If I were PUTIN with goal of turning the whole of Ukraine into Russian land for no other reason than simply as you believe, than I would have simply destroyed its government completely with long range missiles yrs ago. Or taken the western approach so you get the control and benefits without the attention. European politics spouts PUTIN wants more than just old USSR borders meaning all of Europe. Obviously you don't believe that much ? PUTIN isn't interested in that rubbish he doesn't want to govern that either. Ukraine he only wanted Ukraine government to remain neutral as in not nato. His interest was only Russian influence in Ukrainian government to stop nato interest, allowing Ukraine to govern itself but with a few Russian players in it to secure it as non nato. That was the intent when tried to intervene in the Ukrainian government using military as yrs of talking about the issue failed due to western intervention finding nato friendly players for Ukraine government.
It does suit western narrative and goals to claim he tried using military to occupy Ukraine but those who believe that are just sheep Obviously. Why? Simple for such a move and goal as claimed not even PUTIN would be stupid enough to think a military force the size he used was going to be big enough to achieve that bs. Ukraine is the largest European country if Russia isn't included. Only people with no idea of size and issues to achieve such would believe that to be true simply through lack of knowledge and or common sense . Not to mention the willingness to believe such due to propaganda
designed to keep the west in the mentality of USSR and Russia are no different and evil enemies of western societies.
What's Macron going to do for Zelinski when he arrives in Normandy for D-Day remembrance. Run around all the sites and museums removing Russian flags and Russian history so no ones feelings get hurt. Please. I appreciate your input and opinions and I'm always open to discussion where I may learn something interesting to keep me open minded. But as far as this particular topic is concerned we know why we believe what we do and think how we do. And I'm under the impression expansion of understanding each other's views, values , thought processes so on so forth are looking rather exhausted at this stage. You is you me is me on said subject. Look forward to other subjects to learn more about you. 🙂👍🤝
Oh I don’t know there actions there statements. Do they want exactly what they had before maybe not, Georgia Chechnya, Dagestan Transisteria crimea Ukraine,
 
Oh I don’t know there actions there statements. Do they want exactly what they had before maybe not, Georgia Chechnya, Dagestan Transisteria crimea Ukraine,
I don’t think Putin wants the same border as the USSR cause he knows the ship has sailed on some states, Poland Baltics etc, but he’ll take whatever he can get away with.
 
As expected...Macron's speech is empty, besides the announcement over the Mirage jets.

PS: While I still believe that sending trainers is something that will eventuallty happen, as Russia has already downplayed it and moved the red line (as usual), I think that it will take some time.
Possibly someone made Macron notice that in the last 2 months he managed to lose 6 points in the upcoming (this weekend) europeran elections.
Far right (pro russia) leads with a 18 points margin depending on the polls.

If this trend consolidates, he will hand his country to the far right.

Unfortunately or luckily depending on each one's sensibility over the topic, people in countries in the west of europe while are ready to guarantee some sort of support for Ukraine, will never accept the risk of having their country involved in an all out war with Russia.
Can understand somehow.

This is not a popular argument, but many people outside Europe don't understand this because their families, while have experienced the stress to have to send their own beloved to the warfront, do not have the memory of their own country bombed and flattened down by the war.

 
Last edited:
Some news from a corner of the "free world", which are rarely discussed.



This report has been flagged as a "false statement coming from Russian propaganda", until a gruesome video of a killed man with a destroyed foot lying on the shore of Tisa river being discovered by Ukraine border guards, has been uploaded on the internet .
In one of the interviews, Ukrainian military officials also proposed to "fill the river with crocodiles".

As the manhunt, conducted by Ukrainian regime getting more brutal due to exhaustion of disposable manpower at war, people are getting more desperate to get out from the country, that has nothing else to offer but death on the frontlines either by the hands of their enemy or by a bullet from blocking detachments formed by units, loyal to Ukrainian regime. With borders and checkpoints being controlled strictly, one of the few possible options available to escape more apparent death is to cross Tisa river positioned along the border to Romanian territory. More and more people getting desperate enough, taking a risk of crossing by themselves, despite regular border guard patrols and drone surveillance, as well as apparent danger of doing this. On top of that, we now see that Ukraine military has filled the shoreline with anti-personnel mines targeted against their own civilian population.

Current number of Ukrainian civilian victims, who died while attempting to cross Tisa river to Romanian border is stated to be 45 people.

View attachment 5738
picture of a man drown in Tisa river, taken by Ukraine border guard

Tisa river has already earned a nickname "Styx" or "Sanzu" river, from Greek and Japanese mythologies, as the rivers who serve as a border between the worlds of dead and living . Alas, many unfortunate souls had failed their swim through Ukrainian Styx, never making their cross to the side of the living...
@Citizen-21 - I have challenged a couple posts and asked for the sources behind the posts. It's not necessarily because I am looking to discredit your message or outright argue "Russia bad, West good" (though, full disclosure, I have gone in that direction in previous posts). Identifying the source lends credibility to the post and strengthens an argument, though I recognize the ability to do so may be constrained by censorship mechanisms that may exists outside of the US or western nations.

In this case, I am asking, in part, to support my own independent curiosity on this. Since there is open conflict occurring between Russia and Ukraine, it is reasonable to assume there are atrocious acts occurring on both sides, and that it is possible that a western media bias of some kind is "filtering" unflattering reports on Ukrainian behavior (I am willing to concede this). So as an independent thinker, I'd like to dig a little deeper and understand this for myself.
 
As expected...Macron's speech is empty, besides the announcement over the Mirage jets.

PS: While I still believe that sending trainers is something that will eventuallty happen, as Russia has already downplayed it and moved the red line (as usual), I think that it will take some time.
Possibly someone made Macron notice that in the last 2 months he managed to lose 6 points in the upcoming (this weekend) europeran elections.
Far right (pro russia) leads with a 18 points margin depending on the polls.

If this trend consolidates, he will hand his country to the far right.

Unfortunately or luckily depending on each one's sensibility over the topic, people in countries in the west of europe while are ready to guarantee some sort of support for Ukraine, will never accept the risk of having their country involved in an all out war with Russia.
Can understand somehow.

This is not a popular argument, but many people outside Europe don't understand this because their families, while have experienced the stress to have to send their own beloved to the warfront, do not have the memory of their own country bombed and flattened down by the war.

Two things;
European citizens are not alone in hesitating to send their young to fight in Ukraine. Many many Americans feel the same way. Even if their staunch supports of Ukraine. And it is understandable and if decided upon needs a through debate in each country.

Regarding a right winger being elected in France. Maybe LePen will surprise everyone like Meloni has.
Many right wingers when they get past the national political fight even though they criticized the previous left wing government. Still do not take kindly and act accordingly regarding Russias actions in Ukraine.
If trumps elected military aid is not suddenly going to dry up for Ukraine.
As he has said if Russia does not meet his conditions, he will send even more weaponry to Ukraine.
 
Yeah of course mine was not criticism. But I think that there’s a big difference about the risks involved when you’re talking to someone who had their grandparents (ie.) who suffered famine during one of the world wars which occurred in Europe.
Not saying that the feelings are different, I am saying that the bases on which they are founded unfortunately are different.

Trump is unpredictable, therefore I cannot really provide a credible forecast about what I think it could happen or what he would do or not do.

Regarding MLP and Meloni…careful.
The weight that Italy has when it comes to foreign politics is null, compared to the one that France and therefore MLP would have.
Geopolitically speaking Italy is nearly 100% dependent on the US.
France is not and this has been proved in various occasions in the past.
Think about the relationship between NATO and France and what happened in the past decades.

MLP is a shithead and what Macron has been doing until now is utterly stupid because he’s letting her build solid bases for a win in 2027.
Until March Macron was criticized for his policies regarding the economy and the immigration.
Macron saw an opportunity to play the role of the military leader in the EU.
This has evidently backfired, and put himself in a condition where he has to struggle to keep balance between losing ever more consent by pursuing a direction that the vast majority of the French believe is completely wrong, and contradicting himself and allowing MLP to prove that he’s not fit for the role.
Since March the foreign policy has adsorbed most of the debate…in a very favorable way for MLP’s FN party.
 
Some news from a corner of the "free world", which are rarely discussed.



This report has been flagged as a "false statement coming from Russian propaganda", until a gruesome video of a killed man with a destroyed foot lying on the shore of Tisa river being discovered by Ukraine border guards, has been uploaded on the internet .
In one of the interviews, Ukrainian military officials also proposed to "fill the river with crocodiles".

As the manhunt, conducted by Ukrainian regime getting more brutal due to exhaustion of disposable manpower at war, people are getting more desperate to get out from the country, that has nothing else to offer but death on the frontlines either by the hands of their enemy or by a bullet from blocking detachments formed by units, loyal to Ukrainian regime. With borders and checkpoints being controlled strictly, one of the few possible options available to escape more apparent death is to cross Tisa river positioned along the border to Romanian territory. More and more people getting desperate enough, taking a risk of crossing by themselves, despite regular border guard patrols and drone surveillance, as well as apparent danger of doing this. On top of that, we now see that Ukraine military has filled the shoreline with anti-personnel mines targeted against their own civilian population.

Current number of Ukrainian civilian victims, who died while attempting to cross Tisa river to Romanian border is stated to be 45 people.

View attachment 5738
picture of a man drown in Tisa river, taken by Ukraine border guard

Tisa river has already earned a nickname "Styx" or "Sanzu" river, from Greek and Japanese mythologies, as the rivers who serve as a border between the worlds of dead and living . Alas, many unfortunate souls had failed their swim through Ukrainian Styx, never making their cross to the side of the living...
War sucks. When faced with such conditions on whether to conscript or to allow the invaders to take your homes, Hard decisions are made, Ukraine is facing an existential threat, that much is clear. I am not supporting these actions but I do see the conditions the Ukrainians have found themselves, and the lack of men. Russia would do the exact same thing if they were suddenly losing kilometers of sovereign land in a fight for their survival. Ukraine faces internal issues and restrictions from allies along with this shortage of manpower. It is unpopular but a frontline requires men. If Ukrainian men want to live in Ukraine after the war, they have a responsibility to defend their homeland. I would say that for any nation state fighting for it's freedom. I understand why some would not be willing to risk their lives, but if they won't risk their life for their people how can they come back and not feel utterly shamed?
 
. It is unpopular but a frontline requires men. If Ukrainian men want to live in Ukraine after the war, they have a responsibility to defend their homeland. I would say that for any nation state fighting for it's freedom. I understand why some would not be willing to risk their lives, but if they won't risk their life for their people how can they come back and not feel utterly shamed?
See this is an another point on the Western Europe criticism against more explicit military support in Ukraine.
Spain, France and Italy are literally flooded with Ukrainian cars (Ukrainian car plate) drove by men fit for service.
This was before the war an absolute rarity and the phenomenon is so big that the countries had to introduce rules to manage the situation (foreign cars in Europe are not allowed to stay more than 1 year without changing the plate with one of the country where they’re staying).
This results in people asking themselves why the unrealistic question of sending western troops in Ukraine to replenish the front lines is even going to be considered.
As often happens people with spending capabilities (or people with relatives abroad) flee their country, this is even more visible in the modern world.
 
Just as a refresher can anyone post a video of Putin naming the redlines not to be crossed? As I remember it BIDEN stated redlines like no tanks,planes,long-range missiles etcetc. I don't recall Putin filmed stating such?
 
Just as a refresher can anyone post a video of Putin naming the redlines not to be crossed? As I remember it BIDEN stated redlines like no tanks,planes,long-range missiles etcetc. I don't recall Putin filmed stating such?
Here’s long range missiles https://www.reuters.com/world/europ...if-longer-range-missiles-supplied-2022-06-05/
Here’s arms supplies in general
Here’s arm supplies again and one of the first mentions of “disastrous consequences” if western missiles are fired into Russia
Here’s Russia accusing Germany of crossing a red line
Here’s a red line for ATACMs
Here’s tanks
There’s a lot more but a lot of them are kind of repetitive or much more vague.
 
Here’s long range missiles https://www.reuters.com/world/europ...if-longer-range-missiles-supplied-2022-06-05/
Here’s arms supplies in general
Here’s arm supplies again and one of the first mentions of “disastrous consequences” if western missiles are fired into Russia
Here’s Russia accusing Germany of crossing a red line
Here’s a red line for ATACMs
Here’s tanks
There’s a lot more but a lot of them are kind of repetitive or much more vague.
Representatives only.
Couldn't find what I requested?
 
Just as a refresher can anyone post a video of Putin naming the redlines not to be crossed? As I remember it BIDEN stated redlines like no tanks,planes,long-range missiles etcetc. I don't recall Putin filmed stating such?
American news channels rarely broadcast Putin's speeches. I watch Putin's speeches on African channels and have never heard the red lines set by Putin. He often uses the word asymmetrical. On the other hand, Western propagators set red lines. These videos do not exist, in my opinion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom