• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | Discussions 2024

Status
Not open for further replies.
It seems like a lot of people are waiting anxiously to see what Pres. Trump is going to do in regards to this whole situation.

Me? I'm more concerned about what Pres. Biden is going to do next.
After all, he still has @581/2 days left!

And has been shown, what a difference a day makes.
I think the Biden administration has pretty much maxed out what they can provide Ukraine. Putin has been pretty patient so I imagine he’ll wait out a couple months knowing they’ll probably be able to keep what territory they have with little danger of Ukraine retaking it in the meantime.
 
It seems like a lot of people are waiting anxiously to see what Pres. Trump is going to do in regards to this whole situation.

Me? I'm more concerned about what Pres. Biden is going to do next.
After all, he still has @581/2 days left!

And has been shown, what a difference a day makes.
Sadly, you're absolutely right. If that "man" continues to push it with his irrationality, even when and if Trump will try to cool down the situation, it could already be too late.
 
I honestly still hold the belief of turning this into a Cold War but requiring the occupied territories be labeled as their own sovereign republics under CIS instead of being a part of Russia proper. Or Ukraine pull a Cold War era Finland (the most unlikely scenario) and reap the benefits of the Western and Russian funding. With the latter Zelenskiy can be neutral but still receive money and equipment from both sides at a cost of waiting for another implosion to happen which might cause the occupied territory to have a referendum.
 
That is true, I am relying on history for some framework to preserve the sovereignty of Ukraine while staying neutral and getting aid from both sides as an off-ramp political strategy. The likelihood of this working is not feasible, neither is the reality of them ceding the occupied territory and setting up a DMZ.
 
Well, until now, sending weapons to Ukraine just escalated the situation and continuing to do so would be like wanting to put off a wildfire with a dropper. So, I hope that Trump's administration will put an end to this madness, withdraw all military help, UA will give Donbass and Crimea to Russia and the rest of Ukraine would concentrate on rebuilding. That would be the logical approach.
I may be wrong but don’t expect that to be his default opening position.
He campaigned on honest negotiations from both sides not cut all aid.
He also has signaled if Putin doesn’t play ball we’re going to do more. On the flip if Zelinski doesn’t play ball aid will be cut.
 
I may be wrong but don’t expect that to be his default opening position.
He campaigned on honest negotiations from both sides not cut all aid.
He also has signaled if Putin doesn’t play ball we’re going to do more. On the flip if Zelinski doesn’t play ball aid will be cut.
Well, then let's hope Zelensky will be Zelensky, as irrational and arrogant as he was until now and help will be cut completely, forcing a complete surrender or facing complete destruction. Then maybe he'll begin to be reasonable.
 
That is true, I am relying on history for some framework to preserve the sovereignty of Ukraine while staying neutral and getting aid from both sides as an off-ramp political strategy. The likelihood of this working is not feasible, neither is the reality of them ceding the occupied territory and setting up a DMZ.
Well this was pretty much the agreement out of the Minsk accord.
So your right about it not likely being feasible
 
I think Trump is taking a very straightforward and practical approach to this conflict without as much concern for who is the victim or the aggressor and more just "How do I minimize loss of life" - whereas Biden is being both somewhat ideological in his pro Ukraine stance and I think hoping to play a long game of weakening Russia at the same time at least as a benefit.
It does appear this is having the opposite effect in several ways (forcing Russia to strengthen it's alliances, beef up its weapons production, become more self reliant internally, forcing them to check and account for equipment that has been sold off or sabotaged behind the scenes that would've previously been unknown going into any potential broader conflict in a situation where it was not critical to their survival at the start of the war)
I have a bad feeling he is going to push too far and we will see where the red line is now that he is desperately giving everything within his power and relaxing the rules in order to maximize chances of victory before Trump takes power and potentially changes the approach. Hoping Putin is a patient enough man.
(and I can't believe I'm saying this really - there are only very few issues where I generally agree with at least the public facing stance of DJT, this is one of them)
 
Well, then let's hope Zelensky will be Zelensky, as irrational and arrogant as he was until now and help will be cut completely, forcing a complete surrender or facing complete destruction. Then maybe he'll begin to be reasonable.
You do know the same thing can be said of Putin as well. Putin’s terms for negotiations till now have not exactly been reasonable. He wants Zelinski gone and power structure back to where he can select the leader of Ukraine. Zelinski IS desperate. Churchill was also sometimes testy about US military support before we joined the war.

Like I said both sides are going to have to be agreeable. Personally I think it’s going to be Putin who is the roadblock to peace at first.
So don’t get your hopes up that Trump will kill all aid.
But as always I could be wrong, I’m only going on trumps past record and campaign interviews he’s given.
 
You do know the same thing can be said of Putin as well. Putin’s terms for negotiations till now have not exactly been reasonable. He wants Zelinski gone and power structure back to where he can select the leader of Ukraine. Zelinski IS desperate. Churchill was also sometimes testy about US military support before we joined the war.

Like I said both sides are going to have to be agreeable. Personally I think it’s going to be Putin who is the roadblock to peace at first.
So don’t get your hopes up that Trump will kill all aid.
But as always I could be wrong, I’m only going on trumps past record and campaign interviews he’s given.
What angers me is that Zelensky tried, since the beginning of the war (and let's remember that a big part of the Donbass population identifies itself as Russian and would like to be a part of Russia), to drag everybody into a spiral of escalation (no-fly zone, remember?) by not even asking, but demanding help from the West without even thinking about negotiating with Putin. And the West obliged.

However, let's also remember that historically, if we look at WWII, the highest price was paid by European countries, while the US fought a proxy war with minimal to no civilian casualties. It's easy to escalate when you know that probably your country won't be affected, while potentially Europe could become a wasteland.

Also, Ukraine was not part of the EU and us Europeans had no obligation whatsover to military help UA. Why help UA and not other countries at war? Of course, I'm all for humanitarian help and giving asylum to refugees, but IMO this conflict is a matter between Russia and UA, and both have their share of responsibility. NATO shouldn't have absolutely get involved in this. So I personally hope it'll return this way and EU countries can return to its internal affairs. I surely don't want to fight a war for a country I don't remotely care about.
 
However, let's also remember that historically, if we look at WWII, the highest price was paid by European countries, while the US fought a proxy war
Are we calling over a million casualties a proxy war now? Just because minimal civilians were injured doesn’t mean the U.S. didn’t pay a large price for Europe’s freedom.
 
Are we calling over a million casualties a proxy war now? Just because minimal civilians were injured doesn’t mean the U.S. didn’t pay a large price for Europe’s freedom.
The US also predominantly fought the Pacific war with major help from Australia and excellent support from Britain’s navy.

The number two loses were suffered by the Chinese. The Asian war was brutal. Far more so than the ETO. Everyday the Japanese exceeded the SS in brutality.
Chemical and biological weapons were used multiple times by the Japanese. So much so that the US had had enough and planned to use Chemical weapons on Japanese points of resistance during the beach landings on X day.
 
The US also predominantly fought the Pacific war with major help from Australia and excellent support from Britain’s navy.

The number two loses were suffered by the Chinese. The Asian war was brutal. Far more so than the ETO. Everyday the Japanese exceeded the SS in brutality.
Chemical and biological weapons were used multiple times by the Japanese. So much so that the US had had enough and planned to use Chemical weapons on Japanese points of resistance during the beach landings on X day.
There was approximately 500,000 American casualties attributed to Europe still though.
 
The US also predominantly fought the Pacific war with major help from Australia and excellent support from Britain’s navy.

The number two loses were suffered by the Chinese. The Asian war was brutal. Far more so than the ETO. Everyday the Japanese exceeded the SS in brutality.
Chemical and biological weapons were used multiple times by the Japanese. So much so that the US had had enough and planned to use Chemical weapons on Japanese points of resistance during the beach landings on X day.
Exactly right. It seems that Asians have always been far more brutal. Look at the Japanese actions in WW2, Pol Pot, the brutality of the Viet Cong and now the actions of China. I am sure there are more.
 
This is a good reminder that a lot of the things Putin says are not for our consumption in the west.
And a good Twitter thread on it as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom