• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7th Jan - 4th June '24

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nicely written. As this is your expectation of an answer that fits your narrative. I'll explain later I'm busy now. But I will be back unless voted out before that.
So I take it there is no point of compromise. You talk about community and compromise but when pressed on the issue you deflect and withdraw.

If you cannot answer then the point you’re trying to make is meaningless.
 
So I take it there is no point of compromise. You talk about community and compromise but when pressed on the issue you deflect and withdraw.

If you cannot answer then the point you’re trying to make is meaningless.
You
So I take it there is no point of compromise. You talk about community and compromise but when pressed on the issue you deflect and withdraw.

If you cannot answer then the point you’re trying to make is meaningless.
Ok so your previous reply is great example of the issue at hand. I never stated nato should do anything you referred too.
And I like your claim of what Russia should compromise on. Of which neither apply simply because compromise and negotiation is a two way street. NOT ONE WAY
NOT MY WAY.
BOTH SIDES MUST NOT ONLY BE SATISFIED AND AGREE BUT SHOULD FUTURE ISSUES ARISE THEN DISCUSSION SHOULD TAKE PLACE AGAIN TO RECTIFY ISSUES. NOT YES WE WILL THEN DON'T. Of which i believe both sides are guilty of.
When I get home and my partner or child is aggressive towards me my first response is why? and or what ? I don't just yell or strike them because I feel threatened. Putin didn't just attack Ukraine for no reason either. He felt threatened by nato advances slowly over years. He announced his concerns about it and Ukraine in 2007-08 / 2014 and unknown to us more than likely many other times.No one cared. In the 90s no one cared because Russia was exactly how the west liked it. Under Putin Russia has come along way since. This madman has nuclear weapons and cannot be trusted. How many yrs old now is that claim. He is the most patient, tolerable and predictable madman in history. ,Obviously. Just like China the west agreed to one China policy. Well believe it or not Taiwan is part of that. Yet here we are picking and choosing who we will support in regions that isn't our concern. Ukraine wasn't a nato issue full stop.Nato offered when there was no need or reason. We don't hate Germany or Japan, I guess that is because what the power trip of defeat opens the door? And until such time as defeat in war the threat actually exists because Russia and or China are attacking nato countries? Both these countries supported the west . Why would they suddenly decide we are their enemy as much as we view them as enemies now. I see it as Russia and China have regional disputes that they have addressed non violently to begin with , and with those parties involved. Western intervention into regional issues not of our own creates alot of unnecessary issues all because others must follow. The west cannot deal with their own backyards so next best thing is tell their populations how lucky they are and distract them from issues at home with we must fix others issues. You and those like you will always justify these actions. Fine knock yourselves out. Should China attack Australia i won't be crying save us like 90% of Aussies. Simply because 1.it is solely our responsibility to defend ourselves of which we have no chance. It is what it is.just another failed government who will more than likely cry like Ukraine boo hoo. 2. America and England don't have a chance in hell of changing the outcome militarily. Obviously we will not agree on many things. I'm fine with that. Unfortunately for some who share your thoughts it is funny to see how they deal with opposition.
At worst I may reference warmongers.
But I don't actually reference directly at individuals.
Personally you wouldn't believe the accusations, name calling and people assuming stuff simply because they don't agree or understand where I'm coming from. Attack what you don't know or understand is a false sense of security. A sign of fear, confusion and or weakness. Perfect summary of this discussion. You and few others find some of my posts meaningless . More in military discussions than emergency readiness for example. Yet as you may refer what I spew is still supported by others. Some do some don't. Some will and some won't. Good chat 😉👍🤝
 
Those Russians sure respect all the treaties we’ve made with them, tell me again how’d the Budapest memorandum hold up? How’d Minsk 2 hold up? We get it you like Russia and China but tell me what actual compromises has Russia tried to make?
You get nothing. Feel free to say anything you can. After all it is obvious i intrigue you . If I'm wrong well obviously you're wasting your own time reading my posts. Your choice. Enjoy 😉👍🤝 as to not answering your questions well Enjoy that aswell. There are plenty of examples both sides of breaking agreements etc so really just tit for tat crap trying to justify your opinions. You have yours i have mine. 🤝👍
 
You
Ok so your previous reply is great example of the issue at hand. I never stated nato should do anything you referred too.
And I like your claim of what Russia should compromise on. Of which neither apply simply because compromise and negotiation is a two way street. NOT ONE WAY
NOT MY WAY.
BOTH SIDES MUST NOT ONLY BE SATISFIED AND AGREE BUT SHOULD FUTURE ISSUES ARISE THEN DISCUSSION SHOULD TAKE PLACE AGAIN TO RECTIFY ISSUES. NOT YES WE WILL THEN DON'T. Of which i believe both sides are guilty of.
When I get home and my partner or child is aggressive towards me my first response is why? and or what ? I don't just yell or strike them because I feel threatened. Putin didn't just attack Ukraine for no reason either. He felt threatened by nato advances slowly over years. He announced his concerns about it and Ukraine in 2007-08 / 2014 and unknown to us more than likely many other times.No one cared. In the 90s no one cared because Russia was exactly how the west liked it. Under Putin Russia has come along way since. This madman has nuclear weapons and cannot be trusted. How many yrs old now is that claim. He is the most patient, tolerable and predictable madman in history. ,Obviously. Just like China the west agreed to one China policy. Well believe it or not Taiwan is part of that. Yet here we are picking and choosing who we will support in regions that isn't our concern. Ukraine wasn't a nato issue full stop.Nato offered when there was no need or reason. We don't hate Germany or Japan, I guess that is because what the power trip of defeat opens the door? And until such time as defeat in war the threat actually exists because Russia and or China are attacking nato countries? Both these countries supported the west . Why would they suddenly decide we are their enemy as much as we view them as enemies now. I see it as Russia and China have regional disputes that they have addressed non violently to begin with , and with those parties involved. Western intervention into regional issues not of our own creates alot of unnecessary issues all because others must follow. The west cannot deal with their own backyards so next best thing is tell their populations how lucky they are and distract them from issues at home with we must fix others issues. You and those like you will always justify these actions. Fine knock yourselves out. Should China attack Australia i won't be crying save us like 90% of Aussies. Simply because 1.it is solely our responsibility to defend ourselves of which we have no chance. It is what it is.just another failed government who will more than likely cry like Ukraine boo hoo. 2. America and England don't have a chance in hell of changing the outcome militarily. Obviously we will not agree on many things. I'm fine with that. Unfortunately for some who share your thoughts it is funny to see how they deal with opposition.
At worst I may reference warmongers.
But I don't actually reference directly at individuals.
Personally you wouldn't believe the accusations, name calling and people assuming stuff simply because they don't agree or understand where I'm coming from. Attack what you don't know or understand is a false sense of security. A sign of fear, confusion and or weakness. Perfect summary of this discussion. You and few others find some of my posts meaningless . More in military discussions than emergency readiness for example. Yet as you may refer what I spew is still supported by others. Some do some don't. Some will and some won't. Good chat 😉👍🤝
So again you roll everything back to your presupposition that the west is interfering and the only solution is for them to stop. Or their current actions are wrongheaded, destructive or disingenuous. And at its root the cause of all these problems the world faces.

No solution on how or what might be agreed upon to resolve the situation as it is. Treaties talks would be one option that you might have on occasion referred to. But as you point out talks and compromise goes both ways.
What I don’t understand is why post anything then. Your conclusions are fixed. Are you endeavoring to encourage debate to try and find a solution by suggesting actual doable measures to resolve the conflict.
Obviously none of us here are going to change anything. But I believe in vigorous give and take if only for the purpose I might learn something myself.

Or is it to just to post mockery or lament the hopelessness of the issue?
I’m leaning on that, given that your conclusions are fixed and biased themselves. A fault you readily point out of others here. Is it mockery or your own lack of introspection?

Additional you still ignore the issue of smaller nations who choose to achieve some form or independence of outward influence from other nations. It seems to be totally immaterial matter for you.

If you would like to rely on historical agreements we can go back to the Budapest Memorandum where the US was involved and one of the guarantors of Ukraines independence in light of their willingness to surrender nuclear weapons in a post soviet world.

Was the US meddling in Russias sphere of influence when they were part of that agreement?

Regarding China, yes there was an accepted one China policy. There was not however an agreement to redraw ocean sovereignty claims via the 9 line boundary China has tried to claim. Nor was there an agreement for them to build up artificial islands in the middle of fisheries. Or to direct their fishing fleets into other nations long established economic fisheries zones as well as international maritime parks.
As well as the disposition of Hong Kong. So I would argue that china is at much at fault for change of positions of so many nations regarding the one China policy. Given that all of Chinas maritime nations neighbors have take. A stand in one form or the other. They are not blameless for the hostility they now face.

Again it is clearly evident that you have angst with the west in general. But to believe you can post on a predominantly western populated forum with a myopic anti-western world view and not receive push back is what?

In your response it is also noted how it is that you choose to assign fault. It is a singularly one sided fault finding mission. You refuse to acknowledge or even respond to claims of faults regarding China or Russia.
If you’re unwilling to discuss the faults of Russia or China with something more than the US and Britian are bad. Then it only illustrates your own internal biases you bring to the conversation.
So you can conclude that you will continue to get called out when your post are biased in their own right.
 
So again you roll everything back to your presupposition that the west is interfering and the only solution is for them to stop. Or their current actions are wrongheaded, destructive or disingenuous. And at its root the cause of all these problems the world faces.

No solution on how or what might be agreed upon to resolve the situation as it is.
What I don’t understand is why post anything then. Your conclusions are fixed. Are you endeavoring to encourage debate to try and find a solution by suggesting actual doable measures to resolve the conflict.
Obviously none of us here are going to change anything. But I believe in vigorous give and take if only for the purpose I might learn something myself.

Or is it to just to post mockery or lament the hopelessness of the issue?
I’m leaning on that, given that your conclusions are fixed and biased themselves. A fault you readily point out of others here. Is it mockery or your own lack of introspection?

Additional you still ignore the issue of smaller nations who choose to achieve some form or independence of outward influence from other nations. It seems to be totally immaterial matter for you.

If you would like to rely on historical agreements we can go back to the Budapest Memorandum where the US was involved and one of the guarantors of Ukraines independence in light of their willingness to surrender nuclear weapons in a post soviet world.

Was the US meddling in Russias sphere of influence when they were part of that agreement?

Regarding China, yes there was an accepted one China policy. There was not however an agreement to redraw ocean sovereignty claims via the 9 line boundary China has tried to claim. Nor was there an agreement for them to build up artificial islands in the middle of fisheries. Or to direct their fishing fleets into other nations long established economic fisheries zones as well as international maritime parks.
As well as the disposition of Hong Kong. So I would argue that china is at much at fault for change of positions of so many nations regarding the one China policy. Given that all of Chinas maritime nations neighbors have take. A stand in one form or the other. They are not blameless for the hostility they now face.

Again it is clearly evident that you have angst with the west in general. But to believe you can post on a predominantly western populated forum with a myopic anti-western world view and not receive push back is what?

In your response it is also noted how it is that you choose to assign fault. It is a singularly one sided fault finding mission. You refuse to acknowledge or even respond to claims of faults regarding China or Russia.
If you’re unwilling to discuss the faults of Russia or China with something more than the US and Britian are bad. Then it only illustrates your own internal biases you bring to the conversation.
So you can conclude that you will continue to get called out when your post are biased in their own right.
Strange though hey. For some crazy reason I still receive support. Wtf 🤭🙄🤷🏻‍♂️
 
So again you roll everything back to your presupposition that the west is interfering and the only solution is for them to stop. Or their current actions are wrongheaded, destructive or disingenuous. And at its root the cause of all these problems the world faces.

No solution on how or what might be agreed upon to resolve the situation as it is. Treaties talks would be one option that you might have on occasion referred to. But as you point out talks and compromise goes both ways.
What I don’t understand is why post anything then. Your conclusions are fixed. Are you endeavoring to encourage debate to try and find a solution by suggesting actual doable measures to resolve the conflict.
Obviously none of us here are going to change anything. But I believe in vigorous give and take if only for the purpose I might learn something myself.

Or is it to just to post mockery or lament the hopelessness of the issue?
I’m leaning on that, given that your conclusions are fixed and biased themselves. A fault you readily point out of others here. Is it mockery or your own lack of introspection?

Additional you still ignore the issue of smaller nations who choose to achieve some form or independence of outward influence from other nations. It seems to be totally immaterial matter for you.

If you would like to rely on historical agreements we can go back to the Budapest Memorandum where the US was involved and one of the guarantors of Ukraines independence in light of their willingness to surrender nuclear weapons in a post soviet world.

Was the US meddling in Russias sphere of influence when they were part of that agreement?

Regarding China, yes there was an accepted one China policy. There was not however an agreement to redraw ocean sovereignty claims via the 9 line boundary China has tried to claim. Nor was there an agreement for them to build up artificial islands in the middle of fisheries. Or to direct their fishing fleets into other nations long established economic fisheries zones as well as international maritime parks.
As well as the disposition of Hong Kong. So I would argue that china is at much at fault for change of positions of so many nations regarding the one China policy. Given that all of Chinas maritime nations neighbors have take. A stand in one form or the other. They are not blameless for the hostility they now face.

Again it is clearly evident that you have angst with the west in general. But to believe you can post on a predominantly western populated forum with a myopic anti-western world view and not receive push back is what?

In your response it is also noted how it is that you choose to assign fault. It is a singularly one sided fault finding mission. You refuse to acknowledge or even respond to claims of faults regarding China or Russia.
If you’re unwilling to discuss the faults of Russia or China with something more than the US and Britian are bad. Then it only illustrates your own internal biases you bring to the conversation.
So you can conclude that you will continue to get called out when your post are biased in their own right.
Then again I guess our supporters makes sense aswell when you realise 90% + for your type are American. And similar % for me is the international community. And funny enough similar results at our returned services league . Vets previous and current. 🤔🤷🏻‍♂️
 
Yingyang & OReid...

You both have differing views, beliefs, and feelings. I can't debate. I have strong views, feelings, and beliefs and I sometimes post a long rant but I can't defend them or debate someone, I just shrivel up and want to hide.

Great job. I was really impressed with your arguments. I admire how you both kept your composure and presented your views :)(y)
 
Can't we kick them out of Nato?
A benefit of having Turkey in NATO is potential control of the Dardanelles and Istanbul. In the event of conflict with Russia, control of these straits could help limit the flow of Russian naval vessels out of the Black Sea. That's assuming there is a significant number of Russian naval vessels of any consequence operating in the Black Sea.....
 
A benefit of having Turkey in NATO is potential control of the Dardanelles and Istanbul. In the event of conflict with Russia, control of these straits could help limit the flow of Russian naval vessels out of the Black Sea. That's assuming there is a significant number of Russian naval vessels of any consequence operating in the Black Sea.....
I agree with you. Just laughing at very last part! 😂
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Can't we kick them out of Nato?
I mean Hungary I wouldn't see a huge problem with letting go. But Turkey as @teekay99 said could potentially still be useful... as much as I dislike Turkish leadership currently.

A benefit of having Turkey in NATO is potential control of the Dardanelles and Istanbul. In the event of conflict with Russia, control of these straits could help limit the flow of Russian naval vessels out of the Black Sea. That's assuming there is a significant number of Russian naval vessels of any consequence operating in the Black Sea.....
What is your anylisis of kicking Hungary out of NATO for becoming a electoral autocracy and becoming rather great friends with Putin.

I don't think kicking Hungary out of NATO would change too much on the battlefield so to speak.
 
I mean Hungary I wouldn't see a huge problem with letting go. But Turkey as @teekay99 said could potentially still be useful... as much as I dislike Turkish leadership currently.


What is your anylisis of kicking Hungary out of NATO for becoming a electoral autocracy and becoming rather great friends with Putin.

I don't think kicking Hungary out of NATO would change too much on the battlefield so to speak.
After looking into it Nato members can not be removed. They can only leave willingly. That really is pretty stupid. Also my main problem with Turkey is their treatment of NE Syrian civilians aka Kurds
 
After looking into it Nato members can not be removed. They can only leave willingly. That really is pretty stupid. Also my main problem with Turkey is their treatment of NE Syrian civilians aka Kurds
That's what I was wondering - how hard is it to remove members. So you've answered that.
Ultimately, the juice from pushing out Hungary (however that may be achieved) may not be worth the squeeze and would certainly be a crack in the armor that Russia could capitalize on. In the event of a conflict, a Russian-sympathetic Hungary not aligned with NATO could be a base for sabotage or other clandestine activities for any bordering country that is in NATO. Also, whatever secrets or information Hungary has as a result of being a former NATO member could be shared with Russia, such as how weapons systems are to be used, communication protocols, order of battle, etc.
 
Last edited:
After looking into it Nato members can not be removed. They can only leave willingly.
Yes but that could change if NATO wanted to change that. I cannot recall but do all members have to agree on changing rules or articles in the alliance framework? @anyone? If they don't need a unanimous decision to change the rules within the alliance then I still think it would be possible.

That really is pretty stupid. Also my main problem with Turkey is their treatment of NE Syrian civilians aka Kurds
Yeah well there where only 12 Nations I believe in NATO when it was first created so... don't think the founders of NATO or at least the leaders of the time that founded NATO would have never guessed it would have expanded all the way into Eastern Europe and the potential for them to succumb to authoritarian regimes.
 
After looking into it Nato members can not be removed. They can only leave willingly. That really is pretty stupid. Also my main problem with Turkey is their treatment of NE Syrian civilians aka Kurds
I know there is no spelled out way to remove a member. But almost nothing is can’t be done.
A practical reality is when it comes time to respond to an article. If a member against all other members choices refuses to go along. That doesn’t mean the others are prohibited from going to their aid.
Just as any member might respond when maj won’t, a loan wolf member is simply removing themselves by default.
It’s grey but grey because in all reality anyway there has never been a legally binding enforcement mech to force any nation to honor any treaty.

It’s a higher standard to get in. And by the nature of all foreign treaties support of a claim is always voluntary.

“Oh you want to be difficult and not play cooperatively? Well then we will just quit inviting you to parties, sharing gossip, or listening to your complaints.
NATO isn’t a HOA.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom