• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7th Jan - 4th June '24

Status
Not open for further replies.
German politicians suggests NATO shoot down Russian drones over Ukraine:




@DEFCON Warning System @RiffRaff @Irag8er @krzepice1976
It's worth keeping an eye on this to see if the idea ever gets implemented, my money is on this idea getting shelved.
 
It's quite clear that it is non-sense: how NATO is supposed to shoot down a drone flying somewhere in Est Ukraine? A missile, launched from Poland or Romania should fly over all the Ukraine in order to shoot down a drone?
NATO has the capability to intercept drones in Western Ukraine, if they wanted to. The article doesn't mention anything about shooting down drones in Eastern Ukraine.
However I highly doubt they will go ahead with this.
 
It's quite clear that it is non-sense: how NATO is supposed to shoot down a drone flying somewhere in Est Ukraine? A missile, launched from Poland or Romania should fly over all the Ukraine in order to shoot down a drone?
Natomiast cam send fijgters from Poland or Romamia.
From practical poiintbof view I can undstand interceptin Rusdia missile/ drone few kilometers from Nato border.
Interception over Lviv or other coties might be posdible only if war will go wrong
 
Even though we should be doing that.
Although if NATO started shooting down drones in Ukraine who's to say Russia wouldn't start shooting down Western drones in Syria and throughout the Middle East?

As much as I think we should be shooting down Russian drones in Ukraine this thought that just came across my mind about opening the door for Russia to shoot down our drones in the Middle East makes me now slightly hesitant of the idea.
 
Although if NATO started shooting down drones in Ukraine who's to say Russia wouldn't start shooting down Western drones in Syria and throughout the Middle East?

As much as I think we should be shooting down Russian drones in Ukraine this thought that just came across my mind about opening the door for Russia to shoot down our drones in the Middle East makes me now slightly hesitant of the idea.
That would be a massive escalation. Not even in regards to Israel, however true that may be. That would just open the door to Putin screaming NATO’s entrance into the war, and that, in my opinion, would mark the crossing of a very big red Russian line.
 
That would be a massive escalation. Not even in regards to Israel, however true that may be. That would just open the door to Putin screaming NATO’s entrance into the war, and that, in my opinion, would mark the crossing of a very big red Russian line.
Hopefully this provides enough precedent to avoid an escalation in such case
 
Hopefully this provides enough precedent to avoid an escalation in such case
It may be looked upon by Russia as apples to oranges, but in any case, I hope you’re right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Torch
It's quite clear that it is non-sense: how NATO is supposed to shoot down a drone flying somewhere in Est Ukraine? A missile, launched from Poland or Romania should fly over all the Ukraine in order to shoot down a drone?
No but nato aircraft over western and central Ukraine could cover a lot of territory. It’s simply a matter of choice.
“To be or not to be”
Nato will go back and forth on this for couple of months, then vote to do it and take another couple of months to get it implemented. To Little to late
 
It's quite clear that it is non-sense: how NATO is supposed to shoot down a drone flying somewhere in Est Ukraine? A missile, launched from Poland or Romania should fly over all the Ukraine in order to shoot down a drone?
I guess they could just place new anti air units under NATO command ( instructors, or peace keeping ) in West/NW/SW Ukraine, so those Ukrainian regular units can be moved deeper ( perhaps even to the frontlines )
 
Could very well be. At the very least, it will draw away manpower from the other fronts .
Ukraine certainly can't afford a further drawdown .
IMHO a very serious Threat to the Front. When the Russians can establish a Offensive in this Area and when they just follow the Road, four important Cities are endangered. Kharkiv, Dnipro, Zaporishja and Melitopol. Plus the Front is just cut off. Hope the Ukrainians can handle this
 
That would be a massive escalation. Not even in regards to Israel, however true that may be. That would just open the door to Putin screaming NATO’s entrance into the war, and that, in my opinion, would mark the crossing of a very big red Russian line.
Yeah but don’t you all realize this is all one giant pissing contest.
One where people are dying and outcomes will have significant impacts.
I don’t like it either.
Call it a chamberlain moment I don’t know. We have citizens desperately crying out in Georgia and Ukrainian cities being flattened and re-flattened.

Either commit to win this fight or end it and let Russia have Ukraine.
It’s as simple as that, somebodies bluff is being called.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom