• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7th Jan - 4th June '24

Status
Not open for further replies.
Russian expansionism plain and simple. Russia can’t scream about a so called buffer state when the Baltics and now Sweden and Finland are in NATO. That and their defacto take over of Belarus. Their was never a buffer state during the Cold War between the Warsaw pact and NATO and their has not been a buffer between Russia and NATO in decades.
Ukraine was part of the USSR at the time, there were vassal states of the USSR:
Representatives from eight Eastern European countries - Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR), Albania, Bulgaria, Hungary, Poland, German Democratic Republic (GDR), Romania, Czechoslovakia. These countries were all buffer zones.
 
Ukraine was part of the USSR at the time, there were vassal states of the USSR:
Representatives from eight Eastern European countries - Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR), Albania, Bulgaria, Hungary, Poland, German Democratic Republic (GDR), Romania, Czechoslovakia. These countries were all buffer zones.
I literally said there was no buffer zone between the Warsaw pact and NATO. All those countries were members of the Warsaw pact hence there was no buffer. Also the USSR was a union of countries hence once again there was no buffer.
 
I literally said there was no buffer zone between the Warsaw pact and NATO. All those countries were members of the Warsaw pact hence there was no buffer. Also the USSR was a union of countries hence once again there was no buffer.
Well, to answer your questions, Putin wants Ukraine as a buffer state, this is the reason for the invasion of Ukraine in my opinion. He could try taking another one.
 
Well, to answer your questions, Putin wants Ukraine as a buffer state, this is the reason for the invasion of Ukraine in my opinion. He could try taking another one.
So if that’s the case what’s the excuse for bringing Ukranian children to Russia? What’s the excuse for targeting Ukrainian cultural sites? What’s the excuse for saying Ukraine doesn’t exist as a state?
 
To make it a vassal state of Russia and also annexed it. Wars are always disgusting.
So it’s not a buffer state anymore then is it? Because now it’s a Russian state on the border with NATO and if it’s annexed then it’s part of the Russian federation which means Russia just moved their own border to NATO. Also war is hell but let’s not pretend that war and genocide are equal, there’s a big difference between accidental civilian casualties and deliberately deporting Ukrainian children to Russia.
 
So it’s not a buffer state anymore then is it? Because now it’s a Russian state on the border with NATO and if it’s annexed then it’s part of the Russian federation which means Russia just moved their own border to NATO. Also war is hell but let’s not pretend that war and genocide are equal, there’s a big difference between accidental civilian casualties and deliberately deporting Ukrainian children to Russia.
In fact, I have believed from the beginning that Ukraine has no chance of winning without NATO soldiers.
I am afraid that Ukraine will lose part of its territory.
About war crimes, in history, these crimes have not always been committed by the government in place in the country, but by the army, in the case of Putin, I don't know. In a war,
the truth is secondary, we often know afterwards.
 
In fact, I have believed from the beginning that Ukraine has no chance of winning without NATO soldiers.
I am afraid that Ukraine will lose part of its territory.
About war crimes, in history, these crimes have not always been committed by the government in place in the country, but by the army, in the case of Putin, I don't know. In a war,
the truth is secondary, we often know afterwards.
Who controls the Russian army again? Also Putin has knowingly mentioned its happening. There’s nothing about the truth is secondary when they literally admit they’re doing it.
 
Russian expansionism plain and simple.
That is where you are wrong.
Their motivation for the war is not simply gaining more land or people.
The reasons for the war in Ukraine are: 1) A western backed puppet government installed in Ukraine in 2014.
2) NATO intending to bring Ukraine into the fold.
3) Russia needing to secure land based choke points.
4) Securing Crimea.

To explain these points:
1. Needs no explanation.
2. Needs no explanation.
3. The distance from the Carpathian mountains to the Baltic Sea is a much smaller frontline than their current western boarder. Obviously this benefits defense when you can concentrate your forces and don't need to move them around as far. As well this reduces the maneuverability of your enemy to get around the defensive lines.
4. With defensive lines much further away from Crimea it is significantly harder to cut it off.

Why does Russia need to have a shorter defensive line/more secure Crimea?

This is because the west are seen as enemies because of the NATO expansion and the installation of a puppet government in Ukraine. Had one or both of those not happened I highly doubt Russia would feel the need to secure the land based choke points and protect Crimea.

Why is finland not as important?

Natural land based choke point between them and Russia. Taking over finland would provide no additional security. If you look on a map you will see that between st Petersburg and the white sea is fairly small. In a war this would be the main choke point. Everything that is Russia and north of that would be basically undefended. If Finland would be taken over you have a similar size choke point at their western edge. No more advantageous for defense. The only thing that would be gained is more access to Baltic Sea, more people and more land to defend. In other words not worth it.

As to the Baltic states.

I don't know why Russia didn't invade them at the time. A few reasons could be that they weren't ready, they still believed there was an opportunity to be friendly with the west. Maybe they feel like they wouldn't it's not much of a threat because they can cut off reinforcements to that region fairly easily?

Let's say Ukraine was still friendly to Russia like Belarus and that the Baltics were not in NATO yet. In a circumstance such as this I believe if the Baltics were to join NATO they would've been invaded 100%.

I think Russia would've liked to invade them before they could officially joint NATO back in the 2000s but for some reason they weren't able to or willing to.
 
Unfortunately American foreign policies create unnecessary enemies that in reality didn't and or don't exist. But apparently must be created and sustained for financial,political and power reasons only in 90% of cases. The west is not open to so many peaceful opportunities solely for its own gain and control. Russia is not what most think. Just like the days of the USSR who did more and lost more than any western country during ww2. And America has always had the habit of watching everyone else fight well before joining in towards the end to try and claim glory of which others did majority. Ww2 - Vietnam etc.
The west will be the creation of ww3 full stop. And in all honesty I wouldn't be surprised if first launch is made by the west as no-one would ever know or find out later it wasn't. The true warmongers on this planet is the west since ww2. That is my opinion and nothing will change that. Should Putin launch first i totally understand why and no blame from me will point his direction. Haters knock yourself out and smash that dislike button. Because once those codes are activated I'll be thinking of you giving me the only reason to smile.
Wow that post could have been made by Medvedev himself.
You reserve all of the vitriol and criticism solely for the US as the singular nemesis of the world.
Which for me at least indicates your own confirmation biases cloud your ability to acknowledge or even recognize the failings of Russia or in some cases even China.

You know I am not shy at criticizing my own nations actions or leadership when I believe them to be wrong.
I’ve also defended Russia right to elect Putin as their leader. And Russia right to maneuver and compete internationally for influence and power. I draw the line for myself at invading sovereign nations and then using the specter of nuclear war to defend and even justify its right to do so.

If in the course of a conversation or debate if one party cannot acknowledge the failings of both nations involved. Then it ceases to be a conversation or dialogue.
And that is what leads nations always to war.
- Russia wants Ukraines territory and allegiance.
- Ukrainians don’t want to relinquish it.
- The west is willing however awkwardly to support Ukraine in the fight to resist Russian occupation.
That’s really all there is, It’s a fight then diplomacy by other means.

Everyone here is purportedly blinded by our assumed US supremacy and virtue bias, it is claimed. While all other nations on the world stage are regarded and treated as benign players solely left to react defensively to the actions of a corrupt US empire.

Is that really how simplistic a world view we should sift the actions and motives a the world’s nations down to? It does not seem to me to be one that will ever result in anything other than situational success.


On a secondary note the issue of effort and cost expended by Russias in WW2 has been brought up again. I have to ask myself why. Is this some national inferiority complaint?
It is absolutely true Russia payed a great cost in the war. But they were not a singular factor in defeating Hitler.
Honestly as no one nation was including the US.

The US sent troops to both hemispheres to wage war on two fronts. While also supplying allied nations in that fight.
Would Russia have been better off if after pearl harbor we only focused our war efforts in subduing Japan and left Europe and the Middle East to to Russia and Britian to struggle for. Which I would point out would still have been beneficial to Russia in their own fight with Japan.
There were three allied power players in WW2; the US, Britain, and Russia. This has never been denied in US common history. Would it have been better if the US built the war machine they did and rather than send troops to foreign lands to drive back Japan and German armies. We simply laid claim and occupied the entirety of the western hemisphere. Leaving Japan and Germany to pick over the remains of Europe and Asia.
 
That is where you are wrong.
Their motivation for the war is not simply gaining more land or people.
The reasons for the war in Ukraine are: 1) A western backed puppet government installed in Ukraine in 2014.
2) NATO intending to bring Ukraine into the fold.
3) Russia needing to secure land based choke points.
4) Securing Crimea.

To explain these points:
1. Needs no explanation.
2. Needs no explanation.
3. The distance from the Carpathian mountains to the Baltic Sea is a much smaller frontline than their current western boarder. Obviously this benefits defense when you can concentrate your forces and don't need to move them around as far. As well this reduces the maneuverability of your enemy to get around the defensive lines.
4. With defensive lines much further away from Crimea it is significantly harder to cut it off.

Why does Russia need to have a shorter defensive line/more secure Crimea?

This is because the west are seen as enemies because of the NATO expansion and the installation of a puppet government in Ukraine. Had one or both of those not happened I highly doubt Russia would feel the need to secure the land based choke points and protect Crimea.

Why is finland not as important?

Natural land based choke point between them and Russia. Taking over finland would provide no additional security. If you look on a map you will see that between st Petersburg and the white sea is fairly small. In a war this would be the main choke point. Everything that is Russia and north of that would be basically undefended. If Finland would be taken over you have a similar size choke point at their western edge. No more advantageous for defense. The only thing that would be gained is more access to Baltic Sea, more people and more land to defend. In other words not worth it.

As to the Baltic states.

I don't know why Russia didn't invade them at the time. A few reasons could be that they weren't ready, they still believed there was an opportunity to be friendly with the west. Maybe they feel like they wouldn't it's not much of a threat because they can cut off reinforcements to that region fairly easily?

Let's say Ukraine was still friendly to Russia like Belarus and that the Baltics were not in NATO yet. In a circumstance such as this I believe if the Baltics were to join NATO they would've been invaded 100%.

I think Russia would've liked to invade them before they could officially joint NATO back in the 2000s but for some reason they weren't able to or willing to.
All true and valid points to a degree.
Did the US instal a puppet gov? I don’t know did they? It’s certainly likes to be claimed they did. Maybe the three letter agencies pulled something off successfully for once. What kind of coercive power did the Russian foreign service use to keep Ukraine as a vassal state for almost a century.
So the puppet gov argument is mute.
Russia lost that round in 2014. Nothing more nothing less.

Did Russias decision to launch a land war for an entire sovereign nation in 2021 pay off. Which is more of a puppet government one instigated by internal revolt and overthrow or one installed by military invasion.

The argument for buffer zones for Russia while an actual thing in the old land war model. I suspect it’s actually less of a strategic deterrent today as it once was when Catherine the Great made it state policy.

So Russia has a strategic need, even a mandate for this buffer zone. Does the perceived needs of the Putin government supersede the will of external nations that neighbor them?

Or we back to playing by the old colonial rules where large nation states can do what ever they want.
Maybe Germany wants to reestablish their own buffer zone in Eastern Europe by seizing quasi control of Poland and Czech. Kaliningrad was an old Prussian state are Germany and Russia going to start haggling over this as well?
 
That is where you are wrong.
Their motivation for the war is not simply gaining more land or people.
The reasons for the war in Ukraine are: 1) A western backed puppet government installed in Ukraine in 2014.
2) NATO intending to bring Ukraine into the fold.
3) Russia needing to secure land based choke points.
4) Securing Crimea.
again if all of these are really the reason then explain deportation of children to Russia, destruction of cultural heritage, and denial of Ukraine as a sovereign state then. Also how does annexing Ukraine make NATO any less of a threat?
 
It's called
All true and valid points to a degree.
Did the US instal a puppet gov? I don’t know did they? It’s certainly likes to be claimed they did. Maybe the three letter agencies pulled something off successfully for once. What kind of coercive power did the Russian foreign service use to keep Ukraine as a vassal state for almost a century.
So the puppet gov argument is mute.
Russia lost that round in 2014. Nothing more nothing less.

Did Russias decision to launch a land war for an entire sovereign nation in 2021 pay off. Which is more of a puppet government one instigated by internal revolt and overthrow or one installed by military invasion.

The argument for buffer zones for Russia while an actual thing in the old land war model. I suspect it’s actually less of a strategic deterrent today as it once was when Catherine the Great made it state policy.

So Russia has a strategic need, even a mandate for this buffer zone. Does the perceived needs of the Putin government supersede the will of external nations that neighbor them?

Or we back to playing by the old colonial rules where large nation states can do what ever they want.
Maybe Germany wants to reestablish their own buffer zone in Eastern Europe by seizing quasi control of Poland and Czech. Kaliningrad was an old Prussian state are Germany and Russia going to start haggling over this as well?
It's called spheres of influence and is and equally important concept to that of MAD. The USA certainly has its own sphere of influence. An example of that was the CMC. The USA couldn't abide by what the Russian's were doing in there own back yard. The blockade of Cuba is similar to the invasion Ukraine in that it was a response by one great power to confront another who was trying to work in their sphere of influence. And who here could argue that the response by the USA was a bad thing? Probably no one. Fact of the matter is spheres of influence needs to be respected and is of more importantance than minor nation states.
 
again if all of these are really the reason then explain deportation of children to Russia, destruction of cultural heritage, and denial of Ukraine as a sovereign state then. Also how does annexing Ukraine make NATO any less of a threat?
For your two points.
1) the children deportation issue which I believe is probably happening I don't agree with. I think this is an area where Russia is the bad guy.
2) please see my post about choke points. Making it more difficult for NATO to manoeuvre around the Russian defenses would make the NATO armies less of a threat on the ground than if they had more room. Plus the front lines would be farther away from Moscow, st Petersburg, Crimea and it would be easier to cut off the Baltic states.
 
It's called

It's called spheres of influence and is and equally important concept to that of MAD. The USA certainly has its own sphere of influence. An example of that was the CMC. The USA couldn't abide by what the Russian's were doing in there own back yard. The blockade of Cuba is similar to the invasion Ukraine in that it was a response by one great power to confront another who was trying to work in their sphere of influence. And who here could argue that the response by the USA was a bad thing? Probably no one. Fact of the matter is spheres of influence needs to be respected and is of more importantance than minor nation states.
Can we please put the comparison of the Cuban missile crisis and blockaid to bed as somehow being analogous to US actions in Ukraines. Or NATO’s expansion as valid comparison.


The Cuban blockade aid was about Russian nuclear missiles being deployed to Cuba.
Not Russian bilateral economic and military partnership with Cuba.
A relationship that continues to exist even today.
What about Russias affront to the US “sphere of influence” rights regarding Venezuela or Nicaragua.

Has the US invaded Venezuela or Nicaragua with open warfare to defend their sphere of influence you site as justification for Russias actions and the US’s nefarious ambitions.
Sure we did all kinds of economic and covert actions to try and thwart Russias influence in these three nations.
But when we failed at it we did not wage open warfare. Or worse yet start warning them and Russia that if they don’t see things our way we will regard it as an attack on the sovereignty of the US. That if this threat persist we can’t guarantee we might be forced to escalate with nuclear weapons.

Sorry this comparison simply does not equate.
 
Fact of the matter is spheres of influence needs to be respected and is of more importantance than minor nation states.
This is the same foundation as colonialism when extrapolated out to justify invasion and war.

A powerful nation can use economic and diplomatic influence to expand or protect their sphere of influence.

And are you actually claiming Russias paranoia and claims of influence is actually more important than another nations right to exist independent of Russia control solely because they are small. Or as old monarchs used to claim “of little importance”.
That sad
 
Can we please put the comparison of the Cuban missile crisis and blockaid to bed as somehow being analogous to US actions in Ukraines. Or NATO’s expansion as valid comparison.


The Cuban blockade aid was about Russian nuclear missiles being deployed to Cuba.
Not Russian bilateral economic and military partnership with Cuba.
A relationship that continues to exist even today.
What about Russias affront to the US “sphere of influence” rights regarding Venezuela or Nicaragua.

Has the US invaded Venezuela or Nicaragua with open warfare to defend their sphere of influence you site as justification for Russias actions and the US’s nefarious ambitions.
Sure we did all kinds of economic and covert actions to try and thwart Russias influence in these three nations.
But when we failed at it we did not wage open warfare. Or worse yet start warning them and Russia that if they don’t see things our way we will regard it as an attack on the sovereignty of the US. That if this threat persist we can’t guarantee we might be forced to escalate with nuclear weapons.

Sorry this comparison simply does not equate.
I disagree that the situations are similar and can be compared and I would also say the two south American countries listed are inconsequential unless of course the Russians moved nukes over there.
 
This is the same foundation as colonialism when extrapolated out to justify invasion and war.

A powerful nation can use economic and diplomatic influence to expand or protect their sphere of influence.

And are you actually claiming Russias paranoia and claims of influence is actually more important than another nations right to exist independent of Russia control solely because they are small. Or as old monarchs used to claim “of little importance”.
That sad
It is my belief.
 
I disagree that the situations are similar and can be compared and I would also say the two south American countries listed are inconsequential unless of course the Russians moved nukes over there.
And again where is the comparison. Has nato threatened to deploy nukes to Ukraine or Baltics Finland or Romania?

And you disagree, we have nothing more to discuss. “My view is correct and you’re in the wrong” you cannot be convinced to see the things my way and I’m not convinced by your reasoning.
The only thing left is who prevails.

How it started or who is at fault is irrelevant.
Diplomacy by another means.
 
And again where is the comparison. Has nato threatened to deploy nukes to Ukraine or Baltics Finland or Romania?

And you disagree, we have nothing more to discuss. “My view is correct and you’re in the wrong” you cannot be convinced to see the things my way and I’m not convinced by your reasoning.
The only thing left is who prevails.

How it started or who is at fault is irrelevant.
Diplomacy by another means.
The Russians never threatened to deploy them to Cuba, they just did and it was by getting lucky that the USA found them weeks before they were all setup. Telling the Russians that the USA is gonna setup nukes next door before they are operational would be very braindead to do. The only time it would be worth saying so is when the need is greatest and only the highest of command would know that. How do we know for sure there are none there as we speak? I don't think they are there but it is very well possible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom