• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7th Jan - 4th June '24

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Russians never threatened to deploy them to Cuba, they just did and it was by getting lucky that the USA found them weeks before they were all setup. Telling the Russians that the USA is gonna setup nukes next door before they are operational would be very braindead to do. The only time it would be worth saying so is when the need is greatest and only the highest of command would know that. How do we know for sure there are none there as we speak? I don't think they are there but it is very well possible.
If you think there’s even a possibility the U.S. has nukes in Ukraine and the Russians wouldn’t go crazy publishing it then I don’t know what to tell you. Also ICBMs are wayyyyyy more widespread now then during the Cuban missile crisis and so are SLBMs so the whole Cuba issue wouldn’t be as relevant today.
 
If you think there’s even a possibility the U.S. has nukes in Ukraine and the Russians wouldn’t go crazy publishing it then I don’t know what to tell you. Also ICBMs are wayyyyyy more widespread now then during the Cuban missile crisis and so are SLBMs so the whole Cuba issue wouldn’t be as relevant today.
I don't believe they are in Ukraine but they could be in other NATO countries closer to Russia.
 
Even if they do Russia has nukes in Kaliningrad and Belarus the ship has sailed on that one.
Doesn't matter. Cuts flight time to the states by a few minutes. Only really matters to Europeans. And they never really put up a stink about it. They also aren't as hostile to the Russians without the guys across the sea telling them to be.
 
The Cuban blockade aid was about Russian nuclear missiles being deployed to Cuba.
Not Russian bilateral economic and military partnership with Cuba.
Yes you are correct. Apparently people have forgotten their world history.

A relationship that continues to exist even today.
What about Russias affront to the US “sphere of influence” rights regarding Venezuela or Nicaragua.

Has the US invaded Venezuela or Nicaragua with open warfare to defend their sphere of influence you site as justification for Russias actions and the US’s nefarious ambitions.
Sure we did all kinds of economic and covert actions to try and thwart Russias influence in these three nations.
But when we failed at it we did not wage open warfare.
No we did not wage open warfare last time I checked the history books on those nations.

Or worse yet start warning them and Russia that if they don’t see things our way we will regard it as an attack on the sovereignty of the US. That if this threat persist we can’t guarantee we might be forced to escalate with nuclear weapons.

Sorry this comparison simply does not equate.
giphy.gif

I still say we need a clap emoji in the reaction list for the forums.
 
The Russians never threatened to deploy them to Cuba, they just did and it was by getting lucky that the USA found them weeks before they were all setup. Telling the Russians that the USA is gonna setup nukes next door before they are operational would be very braindead to do. The only time it would be worth saying so is when the need is greatest and only the highest of command would know that. How do we know for sure there are none there as we speak? I don't think they are there but it is very well possible.
Oh good grief!
 
Thats the old doctrine, from ww2 sphere of interrests something Stalin and Hitler cooked up. Time to move forward from that. ( although I understand the Russian trying to invoke the old soviet mindset because it stabilized the world for a time ) But the USA is a global power with no equal, and therefor see no need in such spheres. Btw If I remmember right the Cuba crisis became a thing after the Americans wanted to put nukes in Turkey, pretty sure they agreed on not putting tritons in Turkey and the Soviets moved theirs from Cuba or something like that.
 
Thats the old doctrine, from ww2 sphere of interrests something Stalin and Hitler cooked up. Time to move forward from that. ( although I understand the Russian trying to invoke the old soviet mindset because it stabilized the world for a time ) But the USA is a global power with no equal, and therefor see no need in such spheres. Btw If I remmember right the Cuba crisis became a thing after the Americans wanted to put nukes in Turkey, pretty sure they agreed on not putting tritons in Turkey and the Soviets moved theirs from Cuba or something like that.
That’s correct and given the time it was mostly reasonable for the USSR to take issue with it and react in the way they did.
That old foreign relations term from the Cold War comes to mind, “Parity”.
 
I have just read the Nuclear War Threat Assessment 6/2/24.

Russia says that if British weapons are used in Ukraine [<---- IS IT A MISTAKE? MAYBE "RUSSIA" IS CORRECT? British weapons are not already used in Ukraine?] , Russia could strike British military installations and equipment anywhere in the world. Russia also warns of the possibility of attacks on NATO territory should NATO become more deeply involved in Russia's war with Ukraine. Poland considers whether to involve its air defences in shooting down Russian missiles over Ukrainian territory.


How does the above statement mach with DEFCON 5? If the Russian threat to stike at British military installation somewhere in the world is a bluff, then 5 is correct. But let's suppose that Russia actually strike at a British military installation as soon as a British weapon is used into Russia, then what is supposed to become the DEFCON level? 3... maybe 2? But if it is like that, is not better to start from 4? The situation seems to me quite worrying.
 
Last edited:
I have just read the Nuclear War Threat Assessment 6/2/24.

Russia says that if British weapons are used in Ukraine [<---- IS IT A MISTAKE? MAYBE "RUSSIA" IS CORRECT? British weapons are not already used in Ukraine?] , Russia could strike British military installations and equipment anywhere in the world. Russia also warns of the possibility of attacks on NATO territory should NATO become more deeply involved in Russia's war with Ukraine. Poland considers whether to involve its air defences in shooting down Russian missiles over Ukrainian territory.


How does the above statement mach with DEFCON 5? If the Russian threat to stike at British military installation somewhere in the world is a bluff, then 5 is correct. But let's suppose that Russia actually strike at a British military installation as soon as a British weapon is used into Russia, then what is supposed to become the DEFCON level? 3... maybe 2? But if it is like that, is not better to start from 4? The situation seems to me quite worrying.
It seems many politicians globally in the west have become desensitised to reality.
I dare say my concern for here and the current situation may also match. I think some have come to the point of not taking much seriously anymore. Calling Putin bluff for all Western activities and actions being invincible to retaliation is extremely concerning yet sadly enough not surprising. Becoming complacent to the possibility as if it simply doesn't exist anymore. I can only say it is not for me to have expectations of anyone else here or abroad as what happens, happened. With no surprise or shock . Only disappointment that comes at no surprise.
 
It seems many politicians globally in the west have become desensitised to reality.
I dare say my concern for here and the current situation may also match. I think some have come to the point of not taking much seriously anymore. Calling Putin bluff for all Western activities and actions being invincible to retaliation is extremely concerning yet sadly enough not surprising. Becoming complacent to the possibility as if it simply doesn't exist anymore. I can only say it is not for me to have expectations of anyone else here or abroad as what happens, happened. With no surprise or shock . Only disappointment that comes at no surprise.

It's like you say, but it's also a Russian fault. If you allow that all your red lines are crossed, and your only kind of retaliation is a deadly nuclear strike post on Twitter made by Medvedev, no wonder if then the enney goes always a little further, while Occidental public opinions argue about some theatrical pieces put in place by some actors pretending to be politicians about if a men is a men and a woman is a woman.

As I read on a reply made by an unknown, on a Telegram article:

"It's the most comic escalation of the history."
 
Last edited:
It's like you say, but it's also a Russian fault. If you allow that all your red lines are crossed, and your only kind of retaliation is deadly nuclear strike post on Twitter made by Medvedev, no wonder if then the enney goes always a little further, while Occidental public opinions argue about some theatrical piece put in place by some actors pretending to be politicians about if a men is a men and a woman is a woman.
Yes well you can't say they didn't warn of consequences. Over and over and over again. Still doesn't mean we should not believe it. I know personally if I gave multiple plus warnings it absolutely removes any guilt over time leading to absolute justification. Just imagine as much as you don't want to launch nukes the constant reminder may also be a fatigue and call my bluff game. This would lead to a surprise attack as no one believed it until it was to late . Strategic play should it come to launch. First strike may well be hacking while simultaneously taking out satellites within minutes than a few more minutes launch. Who knows as really how ever it goes down the results are the same. Like I stated before I wouldn't be surprised if the West launched first as no-one would ever know the truth. Especially if media got a chance to air the narrative.
 
Yes well you can't say they didn't warn of consequences. Over and over and over again. Still doesn't mean we should not believe it. I know personally if I gave multiple plus warnings it absolutely removes any guilt over time leading to absolute justification. Just imagine as much as you don't want to launch nukes the constant reminder may also be a fatigue and call my bluff game. This would lead to a surprise attack as no one believed it until it was to late . Strategic play should it come to launch. First strike may well be hacking while simultaneously taking out satellites within minutes than a few more minutes launch. Who knows as really how ever it goes down the results are the same. Like I stated before I wouldn't be surprised if the West launched first as no-one would ever know the truth. Especially if media got a chance to air the narrative.

I don't think that NATO or Russia are willing to escalate passing from 0 to 100. It could be something in between, but maybe not so much. Russia will have to decide: or to retreat, or to escalate. Escalating not necessarily means passing from 0 to 100. Then we have to see how NATO could respond: escalating or de-escalating. Seeing what is happened until now, althogh all started from Russian invasion of Ukraine (let's pretend that there were no motivations...), then is always been NATO escalating at each step. So it's likely that NATO will decide to escalate. In order to escalate much more, both the parts are waiting to receive an "appropriate offence". For the Russian POV, things as German weapons striking over the Russian soil, looks a lot like something like that.
 
I don't think that NATO or Russia are willing to escalate passing from 0 to 100. It could be something in between, but maybe not so much. Russia will have to decide: or to retreat, or to escalate. Escalating not necessarily means passing from 0 to 100. Then we have to see how NATO could respond: escalating or de-escalating. Seeing what is happened until now, althogh all started from Russian invasion of Ukraine (let's pretend that there were no motivations...), then is always been NATO escalating at each step. So it's likely that NATO will decide to escalate. In order to escalate much more, both the parts are waiting to receive an "appropriate offence". For the Russian POV, things as German weapons striking over the Russian soil, looks a lot like something like that.
Russian move on Ukraine was done with reasons dating back to 2007-8 and more ingrained at 2014. No such thing as 0-100 considering how many times the west has been warned is absolutely ridiculous making it more like 50+ -100 though I see by this stage 85-100 by this scale scenario.
 
Russian move on Ukraine was done with reasons dating back to 2007-8 and more ingrained at 2014. No such thing as 0-100 considering how many times the west has been warned is absolutely ridiculous making it more like 50+ -100 though I see by this stage 85-100 by this scale scenario.
😂🥱
 
But let's suppose that Russia actually strike at a British military installation as soon as a British weapon is used into Russia, then what is supposed to become the DEFCON level? 3... maybe 2? But if it is like that, is not better to start from 4? The situation seems to me quite worrying.
If Russia were to strike a British military installation outside of Ukraine, it would certainly be a major escalation.
 
If Russia were to strike a British military installation outside of Ukraine, it would certainly be a major escalation.
Well that would be the beginnings of WWIII. That action from Russia would be interpreted no other way then a declaration of war on UK, then subsequently the rest of the West as a result.

Not a normal "escalation" like sending better weapons to Ukraine. 😂
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom