• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

Differentiating Between Staff/DWS Offical Analysis & Their Personal Opinions

What I have not noticed anybody note is that this site has to abide by the laws of the country it operates in. Thus despite claims of freedom of expression there is still a standard that they are expected to adhere to.
Whatcha talking about?

Please clarify and extend your statement or not. That is allowed as well.
 
Ok I am:

One: Posting your statement on the wall in my office <managing expectations: it’s a farm so any room that’s manure free is an office>
LMAO. I am proud to be in a manure-free room.

Two: Mention that I completely disagree with you about Israel and their right to prosecute a declared war. Attn: @GBS61 that my boss and I just publicly disagreed so not a echo chamber.
You're both allowed and welcome to disagree with me. I'm married, so I'm used to it.

Not surprised and not the first time. Won't be the last, either. I don't take it personally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ovz
For the record, my *personal* opinion is that Russia is in the wrong for invading Crimea and the rest of Ukraine. I believe Israel has a right to defend itself, but is and has been committing war crimes against the Palestinians. And I believe the US is complicit in both of those situations.
I would question what is a war crime?
War in its broadest and bloodiest sense is a crime.
Whether a nation or group is committing war crimes is a pretty subjective and situationally dependent issue. So while we or they can express horror or condemnation about actions taken in war.
But a crime? Well by a loosely followed treaty from the last century and recent historical precedent I suppose they can be labeled a crime.
Whether it’s proven historically to be a crime mostly depends upon who writes the history.

Actions committed in war can absolutely be labeled as abhorrent or excessively immoral. I also believe rather loosely that what actions a nation engages in to defeat an enemy are very much determined in large part by the actions of their enemy and necessities needed to defeat them.

If your enemies commitment to winning means to the last man especially too a fanatical extreme.
Then it likely means you might have to exterminate virtually all Fighting Age Males. I used exterminate on purpose because in the end that might be the choice your left with to end the attacks against your citizens.

If your enemy uses women and children to shield their FAM or as suicide bombers. Well then that nation is left with some very very unpleasant decisions to make.
So I will withhold my condemnation of Israel’s actions.
If the enemy hides its C&C, soldiers and weapons in civilian structures. Then those civilian structures are coming down.
If the enemy is engaging in a house to house guerrilla campaign then most of the homes in that city are going to be destroyed. Add to this guerrilla fighting a extensive tunnel system. Then the destruction is likely going to go up exponentially.
 
HOWEVER this is a western based site, and sources of Russian information were essentially banned from consumption on the Western Wide Web
We do not ban Russian information. In fact, for some time, we had a Russian as a Staff member.

Unfortunately, a lot of Russian press is controlled by the Russian government and is subject to control.

Western press is generally free of government control but is beholden to personal politics, making it not as reliable as it should be.
 
For the record, my *personal* opinion is that Russia is in the wrong for invading Crimea and the rest of Ukraine. I believe Israel has a right to defend itself, but is and has been committing war crimes against the Palestinians. And I believe the US is complicit in both of those situations.
I agree with you regarding Russia. What Russia does in Russia and even to a certain degree their subversive and insurgency campaign can be tolerated.
They seemingly have re-elected Putin so there free to do what they choose.
I would even include influencing campaigns in western nations. As long as they’re not encouraging or aiding in violent behavior.
I don’t like it but I’m not blind to it.
Just as I’m not blind to the fact the US does the same thing in other nations as well.
We’re supposed to be adults so maybe just acknowledging that shit happens and dealing with it as you can.

However when they started seizing and eventually invading sovereign states.
That I cannot defend in any measurable manner. Arguing that well it’s Russians sphere of influence and we really have no business sticking out noses in their colonial territories. To me is just an excuse to look away or ignore their invasion.
I could spin thst logic to justify the US invading Cuba. That fails also
 
  • Like
Reactions: Torch
I would question what is a war crime?
War in its broadest and bloodiest sense is a crime.
This is true. The argument could be made that the concept of "rules" in war are contradictory to the nature of war itself. I also agree that collateral damage can sometimes not be avoided. However, I do believe that targeting of unarmed civilians should be kept to an absolute minimum. My personal opinion is that some actions taken by Israel in Gaza have crossed that line.
 
I could spin thst logic to justify the US invading Cuba. That fails also
There was no justification for that military action either. The US is just as guilty of what I'm accusing Russia of, many times over.
 
This is true. The argument could be made that the concept of "rules" in war are contradictory to the nature of war itself. I also agree that collateral damage can sometimes not be avoided. However, I do believe that targeting of unarmed civilians should be kept to an absolute minimum. My personal opinion is that some actions taken by Israel in Gaza have crossed that line.
You very possible are correct about Israeli actions in Gaza. In light of how Hamas initiated the violence on Oct 7th and continues by holding civilians. As well as shielding their FAM in civilian occupied buildings.
I just simply don’t care to invest much brain power in evaluating excessive use of force by the Israeli army.
Hamas sacrificed their right expect a humane response from Israel or cry foul.
 
You very possible are correct about Israeli actions in Gaza. In light of how Hamas initiated the violence on Oct 7th and continues by holding civilians. As well as shielding their FAM in civilian occupied buildings.
I just simply don’t care to invest much brain power in evaluating excessive use of force by the Israeli army.
Hamas sacrificed their right expect a humane response from Israel or cry foul.
Hamas sacrificed that right, yes. Palestinian civilians did not.

Using the upcoming change of US administration as an analogy: If Trump were to launch a massive attack against Canada after taking office, then he, his administration, and the members of the military following his orders are valid targets for Canadian retaliation. The civilians who voted Trump into office are not, and neither are any civilian employees of the federal government who have no say in policy.

I hope that makes sense. I know it's not an apples to apple comparison, but I think you know what I'm trying to say.
 
Hamas sacrificed that right, yes. Palestinian civilians did not.

Using the upcoming change of US administration as an analogy: If Trump were to launch a massive attack against Canada after taking office, then he, his administration, and the members of the military following his orders are valid targets for Canadian retaliation. The civilians who voted Trump into office are not, and neither are any civilian employees of the federal government who have no say in policy.

I hope that makes sense. I know it's not an apples to apple comparison, but I think you know what I'm trying to say.
I understand and don’t disagree with your logic. I either because of personal bias or just the historic trends in the Levant, probably both. As I said just don’t see the necessity to invest much of my brain capacity to sort that out.

That and given the fanatical nature of Hamas Hezbollah and Fahta. I’m not wholly convinced that anything but total brutal war will instigate any kind of lasting peace.


in the complete flip side of the whole war crime question. I’m not one inclined to go around investigation and even prosecuting military members who have gone to far.
We train and equip these young men and women to hunt down and kill the enemy.
Who am I to come in and try and impose some kind of moral code on individuals who’ve been trained and then thrown in to chaotic violent situations.
I can and would impose a moral judgment regarding physical actions against true non-combatants. But even there in the amped up heat of combat terrible mistakes can be made.

I don’t know, by definition war is an action that goes against virtually all social and moral norms, except defend your nation and your brothers.
If we were not there how are we to know or judge.
 
Hamas sacrificed that right, yes. Palestinian civilians did not.

Using the upcoming change of US administration as an analogy: If Trump were to launch a massive attack against Canada after taking office, then he, his administration, and the members of the military following his orders are valid targets for Canadian retaliation. The civilians who voted Trump into office are not, and neither are any civilian employees of the federal government who have no say in policy.

I hope that makes sense. I know it's not an apples to apple comparison, but I think you know what I'm trying to say.
So when a nation is left like in WW 2 the choice of systematically attacking and destroying a nations cities, Germany and Japan, in order to force them to surrender. We were using violence against civilians to force surrender. How is that different thsn systematically raising Gaza. The Allies decided it was necessary to raise Berlin Frankfurt Tokyo. I believe it might be entirely necessary for Israel to do something similar to bring an end to Hamas and Hezbohla
 
Hamas sacrificed that right, yes. Palestinian civilians did not.

Using the upcoming change of US administration as an analogy: If Trump were to launch a massive attack against Canada after taking office, then he, his administration, and the members of the military following his orders are valid targets for Canadian retaliation. The civilians who voted Trump into office are not, and neither are any civilian employees of the federal government who have no say in policy.

I hope that makes sense. I know it's not an apples to apple comparison, but I think you know what I'm trying to say.
silly comparison mostly because canada would immediately capitulate.
 
So when a nation is left like in WW 2 the choice of systematically attacking and destroying a nations cities, Germany and Japan, in order to force them to surrender. We were using violence against civilians to force surrender. How is that different thsn systematically raising Gaza. The Allies decided it was necessary to raise Berlin Frankfurt Tokyo. I believe it might be entirely necessary for Israel to do something similar to bring an end to Hamas and Hezbohla
We didn't have the technology to allow for surgical strikes in WWII that we do now. That being said, I am still of the opinion that the use of nuclear weapons against Japan was not as necessary as the US government led us to believe. The US crossed a line back then as well.

I won't go into detail here. If you're interested, look up the plans of the Soviet Union to invade Japan in August of 1945, which the US knew about, and the timing of that invasion compared to the timing of the Hiroshima bomb.
 
Are people forgetting the dancing in the streets and giving of candy in celebration of 9/11 that happened in the Palestinian streets? Or how happy they were when the October massacre happened?

Poll after poll shows how much the population supports what Hamas and Hezbollah are doing.

You can't say these people are "innocent".
 
Are people forgetting the dancing in the streets and giving of candy in celebration of 9/11 that happened in the Palestinian streets? Or how happy they were when the October massacre happened?

Poll after poll shows how much the population supports what Hamas and Hezbollah are doing.

You can't say these people are "innocent".
That speaks to the reality that often times surfaces in international relations.
Sometimes peoples and nations arrive at the place where they’re just your enemies. They want your land and would be happy to see you dead.
 
Are people forgetting the dancing in the streets and giving of candy in celebration of 9/11 that happened in the Palestinian streets? Or how happy they were when the October massacre happened?

Poll after poll shows how much the population supports what Hamas and Hezbollah are doing.

You can't say these people are "innocent".
They are brainwashed and controlled. Not all Palestinians support the war and Hamas.

Remember, I support Israel.
 
Strange some here see reports and footage of large groups of people reacting to a subject, than try to claim that must be the whole population or majority. I remember large groups protest on covid in Australia but funny enough it still didn't represent more than 15-25% of the population. But at the time numbers looked huge.
Judgements like some make here are so incredibly incorrect it is sad to see a population tarred and feathered over a minority.
 
Judgements like some make here are so incredibly incorrect it is sad to see a population tarred and feathered over a minority.
According to a PSR poll, 71% of people in Gaza supported the Oct attack.

Not a "minority."
 
According to a PSR poll, 71% of people in Gaza supported the Oct attack.

Not a "minority."
I would call that a clear supermajority....

One could argue that if they supported the Gaza attack, then by implication, they support an Israeli response. (They have to know that Israel would respond in some fashion to an attack of this size. To not believe so is foolish....)
So I am going to reposition this poll as 71% of people in Gaza support a response from Israel to the October attack..... :cool:
 
Are people forgetting the dancing in the streets and giving of candy in celebration of 9/11 that happened in the Palestinian streets? Or how happy they were when the October massacre happened?

Poll after poll shows how much the population supports what Hamas and Hezbollah are doing.

You can't say these people are "innocent".
You're assuming that the Palestinian public has access to the same information that the rest of the world does. If the narrative they are being fed is what Hamas and Hezbollah want them to hear, then of course they support what Hamas and Hezbollah are doing. They don't know any better. On top of that, I don't think anyone here is living under occupation conditions like the Palestinians, and so I'm hesitant to pass judgement on them.

Again, I am making a clear distinction between civilians and government/military.

A certain percentage of Americans support the US government deporting people who are legally US citizens. That doesn't make them valid military targets.
 
Back
Top Bottom