• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

Differentiating Between Staff/DWS Offical Analysis & Their Personal Opinions

Right. Because they don't lie about everything or even realse transparently their own countries internal statistics or economy figures too. Lol
You've quoted out two sentences without the context immediately after that entirely changes the meaning, as I said it's ridiculous in its own right NOT to take them all as lying on face value ie to blindly trust the good guys, but your reply seems to suggest I was saying it's ridiculous to take Russia or Iran as lying by default.
My point is there are no honest actors in war, not that you should see these guys as honest.
 
My point is there are no honest actors in war, not that you should see these guys as honest.
Yes staff here and myself (not staff) have many times over the years say not to trust Ukraine information at face value for this reason many times. Very recent example is when Ukraine claimed Russia used ICBM and I was very quick to say we cannot take what they say at face value and wait for Russia or US to confirm.

I am finding your argument against staff here and this site very mute or null.
 
You've quoted out two sentences without the context immediately after that entirely changes the meaning, as I said it's ridiculous in its own right NOT to take them all as lying on face value ie to blindly trust the good guys, but your reply seems to suggest I was saying it's ridiculous to take Russia or Iran as lying by default.
My point is there are no honest actors in war, not that you should see these guys as honest.
I agree with this. The US is guilty of this tactic as well.

My problem with the original post was the accusation that this organization pushes a narrative as a matter of policy, and nothing is further from the truth. The Director is a firm supporter of free speech - and so am I within reason - and therefore individual members get to voice their opinions on this forum, usually in favor of one side or another. However, staff members do everything we can to keep our analysis and public posts neutral and non-partisan. That's why I found the accusation so offensive.

Don't confuse the personal viewpoints posted on the forums with official policy of DWS. They are not the same thing.
 
Yes staff here and myself (not staff) have many times over the years say not to trust Ukraine information at face value for this reason many times. Very recent example is when Ukraine claimed Russia used ICBM and I was very quick to say we cannot take what they say at face value and wait for Russia or US to confirm.

I am finding your argument against staff here and this site very mute or null.
@Winnitude isn't arguing against us. It was @GBS61 who made the original comment.
 
This is why I mentioned a general tendency on the site, and never said this is something staff explicitly pushed.
In fact I said I disagree with GBS61 that it gets to that point.
If you are going to reply, can you reply to my point, and not something that isn't there? Because there isn't an argument against the way staff conduct it nor is there an argument against the site. There is at no point any argument against any rule, staff decision, or existence of the site.
Just an observation of a general tendency with users.
You seem to have gotten extremely defensive extremely fast due to conclusions you've drawn maybe from associating my point with GBS' or maybe just because you got defensive before reading the whole thing, but either way, I'd appreciate if you are going to address something I've said, to, well, address something I've said.
Yes staff here and myself (not staff) have many times over the years say not to trust Ukraine information at face value for this reason many times. Very recent example is when Ukraine claimed Russia used ICBM and I was very quick to say we cannot take what they say at face value and wait for Russia or US to confirm.

I am finding your argument against staff here and this site very mute or null.
 
I have a huge problem with that accusation, and you best be prepared to back it up with proof of this behavior in our posts or public statements. If you cannot provide specific examples, then your statement is worthless.

Yes, I AM calling you out on your bullshit.
Well, I should have written several members of this site instead of: this site.
As for the opinion of this site, well it's the director's and he's pretty mute.
Then, as for my supposed bullshit, sorry I published the truth.
You just contradicted what you claim: that the staff
allows different opinions, really, plus you call me an idiot.
 
As for the opinion of this site, well it's the director's and he's pretty mute.
Contrary to popular belief, I have my own personal opinions and the site may not necessarily reflect them.

DWS tries its best to remain politically neutral. That doesn't mean individual Staff members can't have their own opinions. In fact, I encourage the Staff to express their opinions, even (or especially) when they conflict with my own or even the official position of DWS.

Politically and even religiously, Staff have ranged from hard left atheist to hard right religious. And amazingly we all get along.
 
So, who is this site???
The Director - @DEFCON Warning System - is the owner of this site and the person ultimately responsible for final policy decisions. Additionally, we have staff members who discuss geopolitical situations behind the scenes so we can arrive at a consensus that will be made public and represent the official position of this organization. On top of that we have forum moderators who aren't necessarily involved with behind-the-scenes discussions but enforce this site's policies for public posting.

What you see here in these forums are personal opinions of various visitors, members, staff and moderators. That is not the same thing as the official position of the organization.

Well, I should have written several members of this site instead of: this site.
As for the opinion of this site, well it's the director's and he's pretty mute.
Then, as for my supposed bullshit, sorry I published the truth.
You did not publish the truth. You posted your perception of the truth, and that perception was incorrect because you were operating from a false premise.

You just contradicted what you claim: that the staff
allows different opinions
Yes, opinions are fine and supported, unless it's a personal attack or can be proven false. It is also perfectly acceptable to require people to support those opinions with provable facts, which is what I did.

really, plus you call me an idiot.
I did no such thing. I said you were wrong. You can be an intelligent person and still be wrong. You can also be an idiot and be right.
 
I don't necessarily agree that this forum pushes that, but there does seem to generally be a tendency here to take one side's word (NATO, or Israel, or whoever in a given conflict) at face value but then take the other side (Russia, Iran/their proxies) as always lying by default.
I’d be willing to agree that the member content of this site constitutes a western bias, HOWEVER this is a western based site, and sources of Russian information were essentially banned from consumption on the Western Wide Web, so yeah we mostly have our own propaganda to form opinions off of.

It’s important to take both sides of information to make an informed opinion. If westerners were allowed to see both perspectives, it might lead to too much critical thinking amongst the potato chip and Netflix crowd.
 
I’d be willing to agree that the member content of this site constitutes a western bias, HOWEVER this is a western based site, and sources of Russian information were essentially banned from consumption on the Western Wide Web, so yeah we mostly have our own propaganda to form opinions off of.

It’s important to take both sides of information to make an informed opinion. If westerners were allowed to see both perspectives, it might lead to too much critical thinking amongst the potato chip and Netflix crowd.
For the record, my *personal* opinion is that Russia is in the wrong for invading Crimea and the rest of Ukraine. I believe Israel has a right to defend itself, but is and has been committing war crimes against the Palestinians. And I believe the US is complicit in both of those situations.
 
You can be an intelligent person and still be wrong. You can also be an idiot and be right.
Ok I am:

One: Posting your statement on the wall in my office <managing expectations: it’s a farm so any room that’s manure free is an office>

Two: Mention that I completely disagree with you about Israel and their right to prosecute a declared war. Attn: @GBS61 that my boss and I just publicly disagreed so not a echo chamber.
 
Last edited:
The Director - @DEFCON Warning System - is the owner of this site and the person ultimately responsible for final policy decisions. Additionally, we have staff members who discuss geopolitical situations behind the scenes so we can arrive at a consensus that will be made public and represent the official position of this organization. On top of that we have forum moderators who aren't necessarily involved with behind-the-scenes discussions but enforce this site's policies for public posting.

What you see here in these forums are personal opinions of various visitors, members, staff and moderators. That is not the same thing as the official position of the organization.

What I have not noticed anybody note is that this site has to abide by the laws of the country it operates in. Thus despite claims of freedom of expression there is still a standard that they are expected to adhere to.
 
Back
Top Bottom