• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | Discussions 2024

Status
Not open for further replies.
ALL nations that have joined NATO did so willingly & ASKED to join. It's a defensive alliance & Putin knows its no threat,
This is unfortunately untrue. Putin does indeed view NATO as a threat. Russians are paranoid, and Putin more so.

Absolutely Russia views NATO as a threat.
 
This is unfortunately untrue. Putin does indeed view NATO as a threat. Russians are paranoid, and Putin more so.

Absolutely Russia views NATO as a threat.
Agree. And Russia does have a valid gripe about this.
If the original purpose of NATO was to "provide collective security against the Soviet Union" (source), then after the USSR dissolved, why did NATO continue its eastward expansion?

The purpose of the following statement is not to excuse Russia for its belligerence. I merely offer this as background for discussion.
Look at this from Russia's point of view. The Warsaw Pact ended. The USSR was relegated to the ash heap of history, and was done so VOLUNTARILY by its constituent members. Eastward expansion of NATO for Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Romania, Slovakia and Slovenia occurred in 2004, before Russia really cranked up its regional bullying. If I were Russia, "why is NATO moving closer to me" is a very valid question I would be asking myself....
 
  • Like
Reactions: JPod
This is unfortunately untrue. Putin does indeed view NATO as a threat. Russians are paranoid, and Putin more so.

Absolutely Russia views NATO as a threat.
No he knows NATO isn't a threat, he just uses it as an excuse to exploit political gains at home and a excuse for him to invade his neighbors wrongfully.
 
  • Dislike
Reactions: GBS61
On what do you base that on?
Durring the war (sometime last year & reported here) Putin moved all AA assets out of St. Petersburg to move closer to Ukraine because Putin knows St. Petersburg or anywhere in Russia is not threatened by NATO. 🥱 There where satellite photos showing the absence entirly of AA systems in St. Petersburg last year.

Again he uses it as a excuse and not a valid one.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Agree. And Russia does have a valid gripe about this.
If the original purpose of NATO was to "provide collective security against the Soviet Union" (source), then after the USSR dissolved, why did NATO continue its eastward expansion?

The purpose of the following statement is not to excuse Russia for its belligerence. I merely offer this as background for discussion.
Look at this from Russia's point of view. The Warsaw Pact ended. The USSR was relegated to the ash heap of history, and was done so VOLUNTARILY by its constituent members. Eastward expansion of NATO for Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Romania, Slovakia and Slovenia occurred in 2004, before Russia really cranked up its regional bullying. If I were Russia, "why is NATO moving closer to me" is a very valid question I would be asking myself....
So as nato was expanding what was Russia doing while they were in active talks and military exchanges with the idea to join NATO?
Nato expansion was not necessarily in opposition to Russia so much so there were talks of them joining nato.
So all is not black and white. nato did this thus Russia provoked to do that.

I know you’re not making this point to defend them.
Up until very recently nato had been very steadfast that Ukraine would not be joining nato.

Nations / leaders make mistakes misread intention. I am not adamant regarding the effects nato growth might or might not had on Russia.
Only it being used as a singular excuse to defend Russias invasion and actions since. And thus seeking to assign singular blame for this war upon NATO.

The war will continue until one side loses or capitulates. Currently the why’s mean nothing except to justify support or lobby for the other to waiver.

Mewling about WW 3 doesn’t change the facts either.
NATO is in military conflict with Russia sans direct troop engagement. I Have said that from the beginning.

So Putin is going to use nukes before capitulation. We’ll see, that too unfortunately makes no difference either. Because here we are.
How about this Russia gets to keep territories they currently occupy but has no say on Ukrainian nato membership.
Won’t happen because Putin will never relent on nato membership.
And just exactly who is going to stand in the gap while national boarders are redrawn. No one!
It’s a CF as most wars. Seldom if ever are there clean moral imperatives in war. There is the cost of waging them verses the cost of not. And it will have serious long term consequences, decades more unfortunately. FE will be left watching this conflict manifesting itself long after most of us are gone.
Or! we can see it through to conclusion.
 
There where satellite photos showing the absence entirly of AA systems in St. Petersburg last year.
If Putin truly thought NATO was a threat he would have never left St Petersburg entirely open to NATO attack. But he did so because he knows there's no threat from NATO unless their attacked first. Good grief.

I understand listening to the other side. But this is getting a little ridiculous entertaining the ludicrous idea that the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine is somehow NATO's fault let alone Putin thinks NATO is a threat which is just an absolute joke.

He uses it as an excuse to cling to power and uses it as an excuse to wage his wars. Get real people.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If Putin truly thought NATO was a threat he would have never left St Petersburg entirely open to NATO attack. But he did so because he knows there's no threat from NATO unless their attacked first. Good grief.

I understand listening to the other side. But this is getting a little ridiculous entertaining the ludicrous idea that the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine is somehow NATO's fault let alone Putin thinks NATO is a threat which is just an absolute joke.

He uses it as an excuse to cling to power and uses it as an excuse to wage his wars. Get real people.
Putin may truly believe NATO is an existential threat. But maybe he does not believe an attack from NATO is imminent. So based on this, or other intelligence Russia may think it has, the Russian military rationally moved some weapons systems around or away from St. Petersburg.

I am not suggesting Russia's invasion of Ukraine is NATO's fault. But NATO has been moving closer to Russia. Combine this with the facts that 1) Russia misguidedly believes that the Orange Revolution was a coup fomented by western influence, and 2) that Ukraine has historically been in the Russian or Soviet sphere of influence, and I can see some motivation as to why Russia invaded Ukraine to ensure western influence did get any further entrenched. (I see their motivation, but I am not excusing it. And I can say that, up to this point, their attempts to keep western influence out of Ukraine has completely backfired.)

Make no mistake - Russia is the aggressor in the Ukraine conflict. Russia made the decision to invade Ukraine. NATO did not force Russia to invade.
 
historically been in the Russian or Soviet sphere of influence
Sorry for my French. But what the hell does that have to do with anything or matter? Kaliningrad was historically a part of Germany & you don't see Germany invading Kaliningrad. If anything this further validates my point of Putins cosplaying Soviet Union wannabee behind. That is the weakest excuse Russia has.

No my statement stands firm. NATO isn't a threat to Russia & Putin knows it. He uses it as a excuse just like anything else he can to make excuses for his unjustified wars he wages and to cling to power.

It's just really weak sauce all around.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Putin may truly believe NATO is an existential threat. But maybe he does not believe an attack from NATO is imminent. So based on this, or other intelligence Russia may think it has, the Russian military rationally moved some weapons systems around or away from St. Petersburg.

I am not suggesting Russia's invasion of Ukraine is NATO's fault. But NATO has been moving closer to Russia. Combine this with the facts that 1) Russia misguidedly believes that the Orange Revolution was a coup fomented by western influence, and 2) that Ukraine has historically been in the Russian or Soviet sphere of influence, and I can see some motivation as to why Russia invaded Ukraine to ensure western influence did get any further entrenched. (I see their motivation, but I am not excusing it. And I can say that, up to this point, their attempts to keep western influence out of Ukraine has completely backfired.)

Make no mistake - Russia is the aggressor in the Ukraine conflict. Russia made the decision to invade Ukraine. NATO did not force Russia to invade.
Personally I think Russia believes NATO is a threat but not in a they’re going to invade us tomorrow type of way. More so a threat to the way they want the world to be. In Russia’s eyes we’re in Cold War 2.0 which isn’t necessarily wrong.
 
Personally I think Russia believes NATO is a threat but not in a they’re going to invade us tomorrow type of way. More so a threat to the way they want the world to be. In Russia’s eyes we’re in Cold War 2.0 which isn’t necessarily wrong.
Well of course NATO can be a threat. BUT ONLY if attacked first and Putin knows this. He knows NATO isn't a threat so long as he doesn't attack. He uses it as a convenient excuse.

Kinda smart actually. Still not sure why people can't see through their weak propaganda sauce.
 
But what the hell does that have to do with anything or matter? Kaliningrad was historically a part of Germany you don't see Germany invading Kaliningrad. That is the weakest excuse Russia has.
Ukraine historically being in the Russian sphere of influence is not a justification for invasion. I offer it as background insight into what might be motivating Russia to behave the way it is.

I am not sure the Königsberg example is the best analogy here because it was turned over it to Russia as part of the Potsdam Agreement in 1945 after WWII, and was ultimately formally accepted by Germany in 1990 in the "Treaty on the Final Settlement with Respect to Germany". It was basically given to Russia as the spoils of war. That is not the case with Russian influence of Ukraine. That said, I do fully understand the point you are making.

No my statement stands firm. NATO isn't a threat to Russia & Putin knows it.
So is the statement "Putin may truly believe NATO is an existential threat, but maybe he does not believe an attack from NATO is imminent" a compromise between your position and @DEFCON Warning System 's position?

Sorry for my French.
I was not offended by your French :)
 
Last edited:
Well of course NATO can be a threat. BUT ONLY if attacked first and Putin knows this. He knows NATO isn't a threat so long as he doesn't attack. He uses it as a convenient excuse.

Kinda smart actually. Still not sure why people can't see through their weak propaganda sauce.
I’m not saying it’s a physical threat more so an ideological one it’s just easier for them to present it as a physical be whether it actually is or not.
 
I’m not saying it’s a physical threat more so an ideological one it’s just easier for them to present it as a physical be whether it actually is or not.
Also let's be really clear, it is not an existential threat to Russia, it's an existential threat to Putins power or his grasp on power.

BIG, big, difference. Russia isn't threatened, it's Putins power/control that is.

Typical Autocrat.. more concerned about holding onto power rather then the good of the nation. Why they ALWAYS fail in the end.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think this can be viewed in two ways depending on your perspective of Putin and how far-going his plans were upon becoming a politician. If you have the view that he always wanted to restore the lost glory of the Soviet Union (which meant getting old territory that had broken free back) and start a new imperial adventure for Russia, countries in and out of NATO regarding expansion don't exactly matter. Putin's goal would still have been the same and he would have found another excuse to invade the countries inbetween even if the expansion had been limited at best. If you don't have that view, then it can be a question of perceived threat and hostility, but after the collapse of the Soviet Union there were many opportunities for Russia to cooperate with NATO in many regards, and in most cases it was their leaders own paranoia mixed with incompetence (*cough* Yeltsin *cough*) that lead them into a spiral, plus the notion of 'spheres of influence'.
 
I think this can be viewed in two ways depending on your perspective of Putin and how far-going his plans were upon becoming a politician. If you have the view that he always wanted to restore the lost glory of the Soviet Union (which meant getting old territory that had broken free back) and start a new imperial adventure for Russia, countries in and out of NATO regarding expansion don't exactly matter. Putin's goal would still have been the same and he would have found another excuse to invade the countries inbetween even if the expansion had been limited at best. If you don't have that view, then it can be a question of perceived threat and hostility, but after the collapse of the Soviet Union there were many opportunities for Russia to cooperate with NATO in many regards, and in most cases it was their leaders own paranoia mixed with incompetence (*cough* Yeltsin *cough*) that lead them into a spiral, plus the notion of 'spheres of influence'.
I'd like to shake your hand sir. 🤝 Well said!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Torch
Here is a great example of how we got where we have and reason for outcome. Lack of interest, understanding and respect regardless of belief.
You know who you are enjoy 🙄😉
Oh, there is plenty of interest, and to the extent I do, I understand the world for what it actually is, not what I wish it to be, there will never be Heavon on Earth, and Hell does not exist. War and peace alternate always, the world, like all of nature, is always trying to reach a state of equilibrium, but never quite realizes it. Cheers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom