• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

UA-RU-NATO | DISCUSSIONS | 7th Jan - 4th June '24

Status
Not open for further replies.
So basically what you are saying is a nuclear power can do what ever the hell they want.
In all your arguments you ignore culpability and put the extremist actions and statements on the west and completely ignore Russias actions.
If that is your take on what I said than that doesn't surprise me. But any of your questions in my post are all answered already. You choose not to see it is a you issue. Just like the rest of you who don't understand. GOODLUCK with that 😉🙂🙄🤦‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️🤣😂🤣
 
If that is your take on what I said than that doesn't surprise me. But any of your questions in my post are all answered already. You choose not to see it is a you issue. Just like the rest of you who don't understand. GOODLUCK with that 😉🙂🙄🤦‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️🤣😂🤣
Unfortunately American foreign policies create unnecessary enemies that in reality didn't and or don't exist. But apparently must be created and sustained for financial,political and power reasons only in 90% of cases. The west is not open to so many peaceful opportunities solely for its own gain and control. Russia is not what most think. Just like the days of the USSR who did more and lost more than any western country during ww2. And America has always had the habit of watching everyone else fight well before joining in towards the end to try and claim glory of which others did majority. Ww2 - Vietnam etc.
The west will be the creation of ww3 full stop. And in all honesty I wouldn't be surprised if first launch is made by the west as no-one would ever know or find out later it wasn't. The true warmongers on this planet is the west since ww2. That is my opinion and nothing will change that. Should Putin launch first i totally understand why and no blame from me will point his direction. Haters knock yourself out and smash that dislike button. Because once those codes are activated I'll be thinking of you giving me the only reason to smile.
 
Last edited:
I appreciate the kind words. I used to be a "win at all costs" scorched earth debater, going for pithy soundbites and clever name calling. I tended to invest emotionally in my arguments, and it was all to my determinant and loss of objectivity. People would not take me seriously both at work and in friendships. I have learned the very hard way that objectivity is better. So to see this compliment is affirming. Thank you I appreciate it.
Ok, but our confrontation would not have required emotionally investment or "clever name calling". It was a very neutral confrontation (by my side) and in general I never make personal attack. I don't think you had to "contain you". If we were all agree, there will be no confrontation at all. Basically, if there are no personal insults, one must be very stupid (there are...) if he become angry because an other think differently.
 
Last edited:
The level never flinched because the issue was not as big as some media and people make it out to be. At least in our evaluation.
I don't understand how the issue could be not as big as some media and people make it out to be.
Better said: of course we are not at DEFCON 1... but 5 seems to me very very optimistic.

2 Russian warning system radars are been hit. One of the 2 is likely to have been destroyed.

Some NATO Countries have authorized the use of long range weapons inside Russia. And we all know that such weapons can be used only by means of NATO objective acquisition systems and can be programmed only by NATO personnel.

Some NATO Countries are being to send officialy troops in Ukraine.

In a few words: we are at the point in which NATO is on the verge to strike into Russia. I don't think that could be considered such a mitigating facts that it's not actually NATO, but some NATO Countries, or that the finger pressing the button will possibly be Ukrainian.

I make an example. Russia said that F-16 will be downed, as well as the take off sites will be hit.
In order to avoid a retaliation against Poland, it will be enough to send an F-16 from Korczowa (Poland, near the border) to slightly tap the runway of Krakovests (Ukraine, near the border) in order to force Russia to consider that the attack becomes from Krakovests, in Ukraine? There must be a limit to how much the Russians can allow themselves to be made out to be fools.

I post here a consideration read on a Telegram channel, and translated.
"If tomorrow Red Square was hit by a SCALP cruise missile, how would they know if it was an Italian or French missile?
Then, even if they assumed that it was a French missile because Paris authorized the Ukrainians to use them to hit Russian territory while Rome denied it and, therefore, they decided to hit Paris in retaliation, in any case Italy - and all the countries Europeans - would be immediately involved because a NATO country would have been attacked and the obligation of collective defense envisaged by NATO would come into play.
If an F-16 bombed a Russian city, how do the Russians understand if it is an F-16 donated by the Netherlands which has granted authorization to use it against Russian territory or a Belgian F-16 which does not have authorization from Brussels? And even if the Russians assumed that it was Dutch, and bombed a Dutch city in retaliation in accordance with Article 5 of the Atlantic Treaty which obliges collective defense, we would all have to go to war.
The real truth is that these truffle distinctions which are completely irrelevant."


And I add to these considerations: IMO the fact that some NATO Countries allow to hit Russia and some other they don't, it seems to be a joke, not a kind of caution from some NATO Countries. As to say: it's not Italy more prudent than France, but "militarily speaking", it's a NATO way in order to put Russia in the doubt about the origin of the strike, so to put Russia in the doubt about against who it should retaliate.

However, it seems to me quite clear that we are playing with the fire. It is true that Russia has always demostrated to not have red lines at all, but we can consider that an inviolable rule? As to say: an attack with NATO weapons deep inside Russia, at the moment, could accour at any time. Assuming DEFCON 5 is as we are saying with certitude that there will not be significat retaliations. But where does it comes from this certitude? By the fact that it will surely be an other red line crossed without reactions?
 
I don't understand how the issue could be not as big as some media and people make it out to be.
Better said: of course we are not at DEFCON 1... but 5 seems to me very very optimistic.

2 Russian warning system radars are been hit. One of the 2 is likely to have been destroyed.

Some NATO Countries have authorized the use of long range weapons inside Russia. And we all know that such weapons can be used only by means of NATO objective acquisition systems and can be programmed only by NATO personnel.

Some NATO Countries are being to send officialy troops in Ukraine.

In a few words: we are at the point in which NATO is on the verge to strike into Russia. I don't think that could be considered such a mitigating facts that it's not actually NATO, but some NATO Countries, or that the finger pressing the button will possibly be Ukrainian.

I make an example. Russia said that F-16 will be downed, as well as the take off sites will be hit.
In order to avoid a retaliation against Poland, it will be enough to send an F-16 from Korczowa (Poland, near the border) to slightly tap the runway of Krakovests (Ukraine, near the border) in order to force Russia to consider that the attack becomes from Krakovests, in Ukraine? There must be a limit to how much the Russians can allow themselves to be made out to be fools.

I post here a consideration read on a Telegram channel, and translated.
"If tomorrow Red Square was hit by a SCALP cruise missile, how would they know if it was an Italian or French missile?
Then, even if they assumed that it was a French missile because Paris authorized the Ukrainians to use them to hit Russian territory while Rome denied it and, therefore, they decided to hit Paris in retaliation, in any case Italy - and all the countries Europeans - would be immediately involved because a NATO country would have been attacked and the obligation of collective defense envisaged by NATO would come into play.
If an F-16 bombed a Russian city, how do the Russians understand if it is an F-16 donated by the Netherlands which has granted authorization to use it against Russian territory or a Belgian F-16 which does not have authorization from Brussels? And even if the Russians assumed that it was Dutch, and bombed a Dutch city in retaliation in accordance with Article 5 of the Atlantic Treaty which obliges collective defense, we would all have to go to war.
The real truth is that these truffle distinctions which are completely irrelevant."


And I add to these considerations: IMO the fact that some NATO Countries allow to hit Russia and some other they don't, it seems to be a joke, not a kind of caution from some NATO Countries. As to say: it's not Italy more prudent than France, but "militarily speaking", it's a NATO way in order to put Russia in the doubt about the origin of the strike, so to put Russia in the doubt about against who it should retaliate.

However, it seems to me quite clear that we are playing with the fire. It is true that Russia has always demostrated to not have red lines at all, but we can consider that an inviolable rule? As to say: an attack with NATO weapons deep inside Russia, at the moment, could accour at any time. Assuming DEFCON 5 is as we are saying with certitude that there will not be significat retaliations. But where does it comes from this certitude? By the fact that it will surely be an other red line crossed without reactions?
Russia may have been using those radars to track the ballistic trajectory of ATACMS.
It does not compromise the abilities of Russia's strategic missile force to detect enemy missile launches.

Until we see something more concrete than the current rhetoric coming out of Russia, we can't justify going to DEFCON 4.
Okay, let's say we went to DEFCON 4. When would you go back to 5 (remember, you can't stay at 4 for more than a few months)?
Because that Western equipment is there now, by your statements we'd have to stay at 4 for the rest of the war, which we can't.

I think Russia is claiming the red lines are closer than in reality. Remember, Russia has officially annexed parts of Ukraine, so technically from Russia's point of view Ukraine has been bombing their sovereign territory for a while now. If Russia retaliated against a strike on military positions inside internationally recognised Russia they would have to acknowledge that their annexed parts of Ukraine aren't their territory.

Putin doesn't want a war with NATO any more than NATO does, he plays up the nuclear threats to deter aid to Ukraine. When it comes down to brass tacks, Putin won't bomb the Netherlands because an F-16 donated from them bombs military targets.

Are things more escalated than usual? Yes.
Does it warrant a level change at the moment? No.
 
Last edited:
Russia may have been using those radars to track the ballistic trajectory of ATACMS.
It does not compromise the abilities of Russia's strategic missile force to detect enemy missile launches.
With statements like these, you may justify just about anything.

But it is certain and available, that these radars are incapable of tracking Ukrainian weaponry, let alone ATACMS.
More of that, they are facing south, away from Ukraine.

First and foremost, Russian early warning system relies on a series of satellites to detect missile launches. These radar installations are serving as the "last layer of confirmation of an incoming missile attack", to combine alarms received from satellites with ground radar readings, to give a certain order, and prevent a misfire that nearly occured in the 1980ies.

By targeting these radars, you guys just escalated the nuclear threat by rising a probability of a strategic strike order being issued even upon false alarm.
As of now, U.S. is working hard on militarisation of space, so targeting satellites is expected. If you do something to warning satellites as well - which options you would leave Russia with, when it's main nuclear doctrine of "response with retaliatory strike" being dismantled when it got blind, but still armed to the teeth? You do not actually threaten Russian Nuclear Forces whatsoever, who are capable of striking regardless these radars. You are threatening your own security by kicking out a pillar under the balance of power.

Clap clap clap, bravo, guys, job well done.
 
Last edited:
Important upcoming dates:
June 6, 2024, celebrations of the Normandy landings in France, for the first time, Russia is excluded,
even during the Cold War she was invited.
June 14, 2024, start of the Euro Cup in Germany, Russia excluded.
July 26, start of the Olympic Games in France, Russian banner banned, and Russia has not yet decided on the participation of Russian athletes.
 
With statements like these, you may justify just about anything.

But it is certain and available, that these radars are incapable of tracking Ukrainian weaponry, let alone ATACMS.
More of that, they are facing south, away from Ukraine.

First and foremost, Russian early warning system relies on a series of satellites to detect missile launches. These radar installations are serving as the "last layer of confirmation of an incoming missile attack", to combine alarms received from satellites with ground radar readings, to give a certain order, and prevent a misfire that nearly occured in the 1980ies.

By targeting these radars, you guys just escalated the nuclear threat by rising a probability of a strategic strike order being issued even upon false alarm.
As of now, U.S. is working hard on militarisation of space, so targeting satellites is expected. If you do something to warning satellites as well - which options you would leave Russia with, when it's main nuclear doctrine of "response with retaliatory strike" being dismantled when it got blind, but still armed to the teeth? You do not actually threaten Russian Nuclear Forces whatsoever, who are capable of striking regardless these radars. You are threatening your own security by kicking out a pillar under the balance of power.

Clap clap clap, bravo, guys, job well done.
These people play the do as we say not as we do game. Unfortunately this attitude is backed up unconditionally with false beliefs. Let them play the game . Just a pity contact won't be possible afterwards. Then again what does that matter. Justice will have been served to the minority. Once it's done and I'm settled like I stated the smile will be the only priceless gift I'll experience from such people.
 
Unfortunately American foreign policies create unnecessary enemies that in reality didn't and or don't exist. But apparently must be created and sustained for financial,political and power reasons only in 90% of cases. The west is not open to so many peaceful opportunities solely for its own gain and control. Russia is not what most think. Just like the days of the USSR who did more and lost more than any western country during ww2. And America has always had the habit of watching everyone else fight well before joining in towards the end to try and claim glory of which others did majority. Ww2 - Vietnam etc.
The west will be the creation of ww3 full stop. And in all honesty I wouldn't be surprised if first launch is made by the west as no-one would ever know or find out later it wasn't. The true warmongers on this planet is the west since ww2. That is my opinion and nothing will change that. Should Putin launch first i totally understand why and no blame from me will point his direction. Haters knock yourself out and smash that dislike button. Because once those codes are activated I'll be thinking of you giving me the only reason to smile.
Yes I always forget that the west pushed Ukraine to invade Russia, oh yeah and they definitely pushed Georgia too, and Transnitria 🙄. This logic is the thought process that started ww2 you’d rather just let Putin run wild and take as much territory as he wants rather than give Ukraine the means to defend himself. I don’t understand how so many people can be Putin apologists when he is literally committing a genocide against Ukraine in the form of bringing captured Ukrainian children to Russia. They literally say Ukraine does not exist and made the destruction of the Ukrainian nation state a goal but somehow the fact this conflict goes on is the west fault because they’re letting Ukraine defend itself?
 
Yes I always forget that the west pushed Ukraine to invade Russia, oh yeah and they definitely pushed Georgia too, and Transnitria 🙄. This logic is the thought process that started ww2 you’d rather just let Putin run wild and take as much territory as he wants rather than give Ukraine the means to defend himself. I don’t understand how so many people can be Putin apologists when he is literally committing a genocide against Ukraine in the form of bringing captured Ukrainian children to Russia. They literally say Ukraine does not exist and made the destruction of the Ukrainian nation state a goal but somehow the fact this conflict goes on is the west fault because they’re letting Ukraine defend itself?
In your words what do you think Russia's motivation is behind the war in Ukraine?
 
Russia may have been using those radars to track the ballistic trajectory of ATACMS.
It does not compromise the abilities of Russia's strategic missile force to detect enemy missile launches.

Until we see something more concrete than the current rhetoric coming out of Russia, we can't justify going to DEFCON 4.
Okay, let's say we went to DEFCON 4. When would you go back to 5 (remember, you can't stay at 4 for more than a few months)?
Because that Western equipment is there now, by your statements we'd have to stay at 4 for the rest of the war, which we can't.

I think Russia is claiming the red lines are closer than in reality. Remember, Russia has officially annexed parts of Ukraine, so technically from Russia's point of view Ukraine has been bombing their sovereign territory for a while now. If Russia retaliated against a strike on military positions inside internationally recognised Russia they would have to acknowledge that their annexed parts of Ukraine aren't their territory.

Putin doesn't want a war with NATO any more than NATO does, he plays up the nuclear threats to deter aid to Ukraine. When it comes down to brass tacks, Putin won't bomb the Netherlands because an F-16 donated from them bombs military targets.

Are things more escalated than usual? Yes.
Does it warrant a level change at the moment? No.
Thank's you for the exaustive answer. I understand what you say and I rely very much on your DEFCON level prevision. Therefore, as I always agree with that prevision, I think you are right and that I am miscalcotaing the risk.
However, I want to point out some considerations:

1. as he had just said Citizen-21, the attack against the radar is extremely serious in itself and has strategic rilevance;
2.
I think Russia is claiming the red lines are closer than in reality. Remember, Russia has officially annexed parts of Ukraine, so technically from Russia's point of view Ukraine has been bombing their sovereign territory for a while now. If Russia retaliated against a strike on military positions inside internationally recognised Russia they would have to acknowledge that their annexed parts of Ukraine aren't their territory.
I don't know if Russia makes this raisonement. As I better said in one of my last posts, there is a difference between a disputed territory - as Crimea - and a not disputed territory. As I said, I suppose that Russia had not heavily retaliated to the strikes against Crimea, beacuse it adopted a kind of "Plan B", in which military operations could have continued with success from the north-est: Crimea would have been in peace, once finished the war. So, to escalate the war for a disputed territory, while the desired end-state could have been achieved in a less dangererous way, was not a rewarding choice. But now the situation is different: there are 2 "good" reasons for Russia to react differently.
The first: Russia, once its rears into Russian soil are hit, it will not have anymore other sides where to move from, in order to continue its military operations. So, basically, if it doesn't escalate, Russia will finally has not other choices but to retreat. But a retreat leaves also Crimea alone: without the possibility to win the war, there will be not chances for Crimea to avoid to be hit by Ukraine. So, the retreat actually means to leave Crimea to Ukraine.
The second: strikes inside Russia, will give to Russians the idea that their Country is under attack, and it is extremely dangerous: it's the Ukranian war starting go outside Ukraine. It will became for Russia a defensive war in its own territory. So, what Russia is supposed to do to make the attacks end? Let's suppose that Russia retreats into its recognized borders (that it finally means, as I said, to leave also Crimea), then who can ensures Russia that Ukraine/NATO strikes into Russia will end? Ukraine will likely ask to Russia to create, into its own territory, a buffer area garanting the impossibility to make in the future further attacks in Ukraine. Then it could ask something else. It could enter Russia in order to free the population who lives there from the Putin's regime. Then it will be the collapse of Russia, which is the maximum desired end-state for NATO. Russia know all these things. And these things are the consequences of the strikes into Russian territory without an "appropriate" reaction. So, if strikes inside Russia territory begin, I don't think that Russian raisonement will be "I do nothing, because if I do, it is an admission that other part of Ukraine aren't my territory";
3.
Okay, let's say we went to DEFCON 4. When would you go back to 5 (remember, you can't stay at 4 for more than a few months)?
Because that Western equipment is there now, by your statements we'd have to stay at 4 for the rest of the war, which we can't.
Not necessarily. At the moment, we can just make hypothesis about the future. But for example we can see that strikes against Russian territory will be the usual red line 1000 miles large. We can see that Russia will actually retreat. We can see an other kind of unexpected balance settling down, a kind of brend "new normal", allowing to return to 5. Who knows. Or maybe it could be established a long time situation in which it become hard to say if DEFCON is 5 or 4. I hate the sites the sites going to DEFCON 1 for silly reasons, but I currently agree with DEFCON 5 only for the trust I have in your judgment, who you surely have more information then me.
4.
Putin doesn't want a war with NATO any more than NATO does, he plays up the nuclear threats to deter aid to Ukraine. When it comes down to brass tacks, Putin won't bomb the Netherlands because an F-16 donated from them bombs military targets.
I didn't said that DEFCON level could be 2. At the litterally present day, it's hard to imagine as impeding what you said. But something like that is just where are centered the mechanisms put in motion. and they seems to be not so far. Something like that is not unthinkable onces "NATO" stikes into Russia become true. To consider deterrence as something purely formal, it's like to consider a nuclear state as it is not a nuclear state at all. I know you don't have this positions, but I am persuaded that when Putin speaks about nuclear threats, it's because he sees the direction of the events. And at the "end" of these events, the use of some kind of nuke seems to be a little more then "formal".
 
Last edited:
In your words what do you think Russia's motivation is behind the war in Ukraine?
Distance between nato and Russia. 2007-08 announced and warned.2014 west changes Ukraine government. Now Ukraine has an illegitimate leader yet no one cares and still supports and pushes. Everyone is looking at this as intended by the west. So be it 😉🙄🤷🏻‍♂️
 
In your words what do you think Russia's motivation is behind the war in Ukraine?
Russian expansionism plain and simple. Russia can’t scream about a so called buffer state when the Baltics and now Sweden and Finland are in NATO. That and their defacto take over of Belarus. Their was never a buffer state during the Cold War between the Warsaw pact and NATO and their has not been a buffer between Russia and NATO in decades.
 
Brainwashed is supporting Putin into genocide.
To elaborate
Here’s the Russian and Belarusian government admitting to kidnapping Ukranian children and bringing them into Belarus.
And here’s the UN convention on genocide I point you to article 2 point e where one is defined as committing genocide in the event of
“Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.”
Now tell me if they are only concerned about NATO on their border what’s the reason for taking children from Ukraine?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom