• Guests may view all public nodes. However, you must be registered to post.

New Russia/Ukraine/NATO Thread - Reports & Analysis Combined

UPDATE: Lithuania continues to expand air-threat warnings as reports of unidentified aerial objects emerge across the country.

UPDATE: Lithuania’s military is now providing further details about the drone incidents that unfolded overnight:
According to Rear Admiral Giedrius Premeneckas, NATO Baltic Air Policing fighter jets made two attempts to shoot down one of the drones that entered Lithuanian airspace, but both attempts were unsuccessful. The drone was tracked over Lithuania, briefly entered Polish airspace before returning, and continued north towards Latvia. It was visually identified near Kaunas, but engaging it over the city was considered too dangerous because of the risk of damage from falling debris. One of the missiles missed the target and later self-destructed. Its remains were subsequently found in the Biržai District. Military officials say they pose no danger.
 
France warns of nuclear miscalculation over Germany’s deep strike missiles.
Paris wants Berlin to clarify when and how it would use long range missiles capable of striking targets more than 2,000 km away, fearing Moscow could mistake a conventional attack deep inside Russia for a strategic escalation. Germany supports developing a joint doctrine with France and the UK to manage escalation risks.
Putin is clear ANY attack of any form will go nuclear. Can you blame him? Land Forces cant take Kyiv and GERMANS threaten to send missiles [two world wars!].
  • The X post by @Defence_Index accurately summarizes a Financial Times report on France urging Germany to define rules for using long-range missiles (500-2,000+ km range) in a potential Russia conflict to prevent Moscow from mistaking conventional deep strikes for nuclear escalation.
  • France, as Europe's nuclear power with established deterrence "grammar," fears Russian misinterpretation under Macron's forward deterrence concept, while Germany is rapidly acquiring ground-launched deep precision strike systems amid broader European rearmament.
  • Germany agrees on the need for a joint doctrine with France and the UK to clarify escalation risks, reflecting ongoing efforts to align non-nuclear and nuclear allies' strategies against Russia. Grok
 
Germany does not possess its own nuclear weapons and is not permitted to develop them.

Germany hosts approximately twenty American tactical nuclear bombs on its territory (notably at the Büchel airbase) as part of NATO’s nuclear sharing policy. However, Berlin has no control over these weapons and may only use them with the consensus and authorization of the United States.
 


Takeaways Up Front


1. Ukraine reportedly deployed 28 armed unmanned ground vehicles in an assault on Russian positions near Lyman in eastern Ukraine.


2. The robotic force included 18 platforms carrying Swedish AT4 anti-tank weapons, two equipped with American Mk 19 automatic grenade launchers and eight kamikaze robots carrying explosives.


3. Russian sources claimed their forces repelled the assault and destroyed all 28 Ukrainian robotic vehicles.
 
German diplomats according to BLID said Russian demands in Abu Dhabi spanned far more than just Ukraine, allegedly they involved:
1. No European troops in Ukraine
2. Moscow would retain the occupied territories and gain control over the entire Donbas region
3. Demilitarized ports in Ukraine (Odesa and Mykolaiv).
4. Freedom of navigation in the Black Sea and Baltic Sea
5. No NATO bases in the Baltic states.
6. Finland to leave NATO.
7. Ukrainian accession to the EU would be permitted, but membership in NATO would be blocked.
8. Restructuring of Moldova: A federal republic comprising the Moldovan core territory, Transnistria, and Gagauzia.
8.1. Should Moldova join the EU, Transnistria and Gagauzia would be granted the right to hold referendums on their own independence.

Russia is clearly not serious about negotiations. It is deeply unfortunate that it is Zelensky who is being coerced and pressured rather than Putin.
 
The NYTimes has obtained a copy of a position paper that Russia presented at Abu Dhabi setting out its broader requirements around the European security architecture, which it has now placed at the centre of the negotiations with (about) Ukraine. The main points are as follows:

▶️ NATO must pull troops and bases back to positions held in 1997 (before its eastward expansion). This would sharply reduce or eliminate the alliance’s military presence on its eastern flank, including in Poland and the Baltic states (Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania).

▶️ No further NATO expansion and a ban on “any military activity” by NATO in Ukraine, Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus, and Central Asia.

▶️ Cessation of “the supply of any type of Western weapons and military equipment and products to Ukraine.”

▶️ Ukraine could join the EU only if it does not participate in the bloc’s common defense policy.

▶️ Assurances that Britain and France would not use their nuclear weapons to protect other European countries (beyond ending NATO nuclear-sharing arrangements).

The paper frames these as necessary to address the “root causes” of the war (Russia’s grievances with NATO expansion and Ukraine). In the talks, Russian officials pointed to Cold War-era spheres of influence (e.g., the Warsaw Pact period) as a model that reduced conflict risk through mutual understandings and divided zones.

 
▶️ NATO must pull troops and bases back to positions held in 1997 (before its eastward expansion). This would sharply reduce or eliminate the alliance’s military presence on its eastern flank, including in Poland and the Baltic states (Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania).
Never happen.

▶️ No further NATO expansion and a ban on “any military activity” by NATO in Ukraine, Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus, and Central Asia.
Never happen.

▶️ Cessation of “the supply of any type of Western weapons and military equipment and products to Ukraine.”
If applied only to the US, that *might* happen. If applied to all Western nations, never happen.

▶️ Ukraine could join the EU only if it does not participate in the bloc’s common defense policy.
Possibly.

▶️ Assurances that Britain and France would not use their nuclear weapons to protect other European countries (beyond ending NATO nuclear-sharing arrangements).
Never happen. That's the whole point for the existence of NATO.
 
Back
Top Bottom