It's an interesting idea but not one I support. I don't support eliminating taxes on tips either. The government keeps expanding its spending and liabilities while regularly restricting its tax sources (or finding new ones nobody likes, such as ideas floating around to tax health benefits that an employer provides). This is a recipe for financial disaster and government default. As we decrease the tax burdens on people at the lower ends of the income spectrum and the middle class, the tax burden shifts remarkably to the wealthier, along with the government experiencing increased deficits and an ever increasing debt. This sounds great if you believe in the politics of class warfare. But it has unintended consequences:
- Higher income/net wealth individuals will engage in further legal tax avoidance strategies to reduce their tax burden.
- Higher income/net wealth individuals will reduce capital investments in the US.
- Higher income/net wealth individuals will move their investments, their businesses (i.e. jobs), and perhaps even themselves to lower tax locations outside of the US.
- People who save for retirement (like they are supposed to) naturally become higher-wealth individuals. Increasing the tax burden on high-wealth individuals will hurt senior citizens who have saved for retirement.
- Oh by the way, with Social Security at risk of becoming insolvent (or providing reduced benefits), seniors get a double-whammy.
- As debt increases, interest payments on the debt also increases. Increasing debt interest payments reduces the funds available for other government services.
Nobody wants to hear this, but it is time to stop constricting income sources for tactical election and polling gains, and instead, time to start reducing government spending and deficits. As much as I prefer cuts to social programs over cuts to military programs, the real fact is, if we do not get this under control, spending
for both will be cut to avoid eventual government default. IMO, out-of-control spending and government deficits are both a financial security and a national security issue.